Skip to content

Update e2e test to be less flaky #533

New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

Merged
merged 3 commits into from
Aug 3, 2017
Merged

Conversation

sebastienvas
Copy link
Contributor

NONE

@istio-merge-robot
Copy link

[APPROVALNOTIFIER] This PR is NOT APPROVED

This pull-request has been approved by: sebastienvas
We suggest the following additional approver: rshriram

Assign the PR to them by writing /assign @rshriram in a comment when ready.

No associated issue. Update pull-request body to add a reference to an issue, or get approval with /approve no-issue

The full list of commands accepted by this bot can be found here.

Needs approval from an approver in each of these OWNERS Files:

You can indicate your approval by writing /approve in a comment
You can cancel your approval by writing /approve cancel in a comment

@ldemailly
Copy link
Member

ldemailly commented Aug 2, 2017

which linter complains about string(byteBuffer) I'm curious ? (also i don't see those)

@sebastienvas
Copy link
Contributor Author

@ldemailly I just ran go get -u on gometalinter and megacheck

@sebastienvas
Copy link
Contributor Author

/test all

@ldemailly
Copy link
Member

it's odd because I don't see those lints even after -u (/running mixer's bin/install_linter.sh)
what are your exact command line/steps?

@sebastienvas sebastienvas changed the title WIP - Fix demo test Update e2e test to be less flaky Aug 3, 2017
@sebastienvas
Copy link
Contributor Author

@ldemailly go get -u github.com/alecthomas/gometalinter && go get -u honnef.co/go/tools/cmd/megacheck

Copy link
Member

@ldemailly ldemailly left a comment

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.

Magic constants are magic...

@sebastienvas sebastienvas merged commit ed7de7f into istio:master Aug 3, 2017
@sebastienvas sebastienvas deleted the e2e branch August 3, 2017 02:20
@ldemailly
Copy link
Member

somehow got it to work after doing install -f -u

@douglas-reid
Copy link
Contributor

so, we've increased our backoffs... but can we figure out what exactly is happening?

@sebastienvas
Copy link
Contributor Author

There might be an underlying performance issue (Istio feature or k8s 1.7). I hate those blind retries, and sleep. I think the right way to do that would have to query istio and check if a rule has been applied or not and check under 30 s timeout or something that make sense.

@ldemailly
Copy link
Member

it should only take seconds for a pod to come up - we should find out why it takes more so often

mandarjog pushed a commit to mandarjog/istio that referenced this pull request Oct 30, 2017
* Add a String method for KindSet to print a user-readable message. Update various error messages to help make it clearer what's happening for an operator

* Use a pooled buffer for constructing the KindSet String rather than concatting strings together.


Former-commit-id: 7cf1e3c4873e817ee10b8dcf81045d3868c4eded
rshriram pushed a commit that referenced this pull request Oct 30, 2017
* Fix devel linters issue

* Move TestDefaultRouting to Setup

* Increase retries on mixer test


Former-commit-id: ed7de7f
mandarjog pushed a commit that referenced this pull request Oct 31, 2017
* Add a String method for KindSet to print a user-readable message. Update various error messages to help make it clearer what's happening for an operator

* Use a pooled buffer for constructing the KindSet String rather than concatting strings together.


Former-commit-id: f88245be75e9aef0e9e9b6a97af2b81a7f8002f1
vbatts pushed a commit to vbatts/istio that referenced this pull request Oct 31, 2017
* Fix devel linters issue

* Move TestDefaultRouting to Setup

* Increase retries on mixer test


Former-commit-id: ed7de7f
mandarjog pushed a commit that referenced this pull request Nov 2, 2017
* Fix devel linters issue

* Move TestDefaultRouting to Setup

* Increase retries on mixer test


Former-commit-id: ed7de7f
rshriram pushed a commit to rshriram/istio that referenced this pull request Jul 31, 2018
…istio#533)

* Rename Resource => Envelope & Resource.contents => Envelope.resource.

* Add missing python file.
howardjohn added a commit to howardjohn/istio that referenced this pull request Jan 12, 2020
* Sync labels with istio/istio

I don't fully understand the details of it, but Kubernetes gets mad when
you change labels sometimes, our tools depend on some labels (like
istioctl), and users may have tools/scripts that do as well. For
consistency, make these the same as istio/istio

* Fix mixer

* Fix mixer

* Fix injector
luksa pushed a commit to luksa/istio that referenced this pull request Sep 15, 2022
MAISTRA-2051: Add xns-informer for Kubernetes types (istio#223)

* vendor: Add github.com/maistra/xns-informer

* Update mirrored licenses to fix gen-check

* MAISTRA-2051: Add xns-informer for Kubernetes types

This integrates the xns-informer library for multi-namespace support,
but only for core Kubernetes types.  The informers are hard-coded to
watch all namespaces here.  The integration with MemberRoll will come
in a follow-up.

MAISTRA-2051 Add xns-informer for Istio types (istio#221)

MAISTRA-2051: Add MemberRollController (istio#227)

* MAISTRA-2051: Add MemberRollController

Includes the following:

* 75742b0 - Add Makefile for Maistra client generation

This adds a Makefile with tasks for generating the Maistra specific
clients. It is adapted from the one in the Istio client-go repository.

* 5f8562c - Add MemberRollController

Squashed commit, consisting of:

  * MAISTRA-417: Add MemberRollController

  * MAISTRA-450: Switch across to ConfiguredMembers and check existing
    config for changes

  * MAISTRA-1005 Do not expect namespaces to have a stable ordering

The clients have also been regenerated.

* 1b7a89d - Add missing licenses

* fe2f8cd - Fix Copyright holder

* 06ea2db - MAISTRA-1666: Add `go mod vendor` as part of `make gen`

This is to make sure all PR's will have an updated
vendor directory. The `gencheck` prow job will ensure that.

* MAISTRA-2051: Update MemberRollController for xns-informers

* MAISTRA-2051: Add AddMemberRoll to kube client

* MAISTRA-2051: Configure MemberRoll controller in istiod

MAISTRA-2051: Add xns-informer for Service APIs (istio#229)

* MAISTRA-2051: Update xns-informers

* MAISTRA-2051: Add xns-informer for Service APIs

MAISTRA-2051: Use shared Kubernetes client in galley (istio#241)

This moves galley to the shared Kubernetes client, which will let it
use xns-informers for multi-namespace support like everything else.

MAISTRA-2051: Update xns-informers to latest (istio#252)

* MAISTRA-2051: Reset Kubernetes client to release-1.8 state

* MAISTRA-2051: Use xns-informers in Kubernetes client

* MAISTRA-2051: Un-skip tests with xns-informers issues

These tests were skipped because of issues with xns-informers, which
have now been solved.  They should no longer be skipped.

* MAISTRA-2051: Update xns-informers to latest

* MAISTRA-2051: Skip problematic integration test: TestDashboard

MAISTRA-2051: Use MultiNamespaceInformer in galley (istio#254)

* Revert "MAISTRA-2051: Use shared Kubernetes client in galley (istio#241)"

This reverts commit 0b1567a.

* MAISTRA-2051: Use MultiNamespaceInformer in galley

This is a rework of the previous change that used the central
Kubernetes client in Galley.  The watchers in Galley manage stopping
and starting individual informers, which doesn't work well with the
factory returning cached informers.  This creates multi-namespace
informers individually instead of using the central factory.  It's
also a much smaller change overall and doesn't affect the tests.

* MAISTRA-2051: Add GetMemberRoll method to Kubernetes client

* MAISTRA-2051: Integrate MemberRoll with Galley

This configures the mulit-namespace aware infomers in Galley to
respond to changes in the set of namespaces via the MemberRoll.

This includes parts of the following:

  - 4b70b8d MAISTRA-1895 Add option to enable/disable CRD scan
  - 6e8019e MAISTRA-1968 allow analyzer to work with multi list watcher

MAISTRA-1724: Don't watch namespaces if MemberRoll is used (istio#257)

Rewrite of the following for Maistra 2.1 / Istio 1.8 rebase:

a161a53 - MAISTRA-1724 Don't watch namespaces if MRC is used (istio#161)

MAISTRA-1755: invoke UpdateNamespaces() as part of MemberRollController.Register()

Cherry-pick of f0eed15 for Maistra 2.1 / Istio 1.8 rebase.

MAISTRA-1724: Better hanlde deletion in NamespaceController

MAISTRA-2153: Disable namespace informer if MemberRoll is used (istio#283)

This causes istiod to skip creating the namespace informer in the
Kubernetes service registry controller if a MemberRoll is specified,
because Maistra cannot read namespace objects.  This will affect the
behavior of multi-network deployments that do not use mesh networks
for configuration, i.e. a namespace cannot be labeled with a default
network now.

MAISTRA-2197: Push first update when cache is warm (istio#294)

Change SMMR Controller behavior to only send the first update to
listeners when it has a list of members ready. In other words, when
cache is synced.

Before this, the first update was sent with only one hardcoded member:
The control plane namespace. Now it is sent with the full list of SMMR
members.

While on that, switch to our own log scope, to facilitate debugging.

Manual cherry pick of maistra/istio#291

MAISTRA-2233: Start xns-informers with empty namespace set (istio#303)

The multi-namespace informers created by xns-informers default to
watching all namespaces to match upstream behaviour.  This causes
permissions issues in Maistra because they will do this until the
first update from the MemberRoll controller sets the correct set of
namespaces on each informer.  We should instead explicitly configure
them with an empty set of namespaces at startup.

MAISTRA-2234: Seed MemberRoll listeners with system namespace (istio#302)

The MemberRoll controller was changed in MAISTRA-2197 to not send the
initial update with just the system namespace to all listeners.  This
can be a problem when the user hasn't created an SMMR resource yet,
because any listeners registered before the caches sync may never get
an update informing them to watch the system namespace.

This attempts to work around the issue by having all listeners
individually wait on the caches to sync, then seed just the system
namespace if no SMMR resource is found.

MAISTRA-2271: Update xns-informers to fix delete events issue (istio#315)

This updates xns-informers to include a fix for sending delete events
for all objects when a namespace is no longer watched.

See: maistra/xns-informer#12

Co-authored-by: Brad Ison <brad.ison@redhat.com>
luksa pushed a commit to luksa/istio that referenced this pull request Aug 16, 2023
MAISTRA-2051: Add xns-informer for Kubernetes types (istio#223)

* Update mirrored licenses to fix gen-check

* MAISTRA-2051: Add xns-informer for Kubernetes types

This integrates the xns-informer library for multi-namespace support,
but only for core Kubernetes types.  The informers are hard-coded to
watch all namespaces here.  The integration with MemberRoll will come
in a follow-up.

MAISTRA-2051 Add xns-informer for Istio types (istio#221)

MAISTRA-2051: Add MemberRollController (istio#227)

* MAISTRA-2051: Add MemberRollController

Includes the following:

* 75742b0 - Add Makefile for Maistra client generation

This adds a Makefile with tasks for generating the Maistra specific
clients. It is adapted from the one in the Istio client-go repository.

* 5f8562c - Add MemberRollController

Squashed commit, consisting of:

  * MAISTRA-417: Add MemberRollController

  * MAISTRA-450: Switch across to ConfiguredMembers and check existing
    config for changes

  * MAISTRA-1005 Do not expect namespaces to have a stable ordering

The clients have also been regenerated.

* 1b7a89d - Add missing licenses

* fe2f8cd - Fix Copyright holder

This is to make sure all PR's will have an updated
vendor directory. The `gencheck` prow job will ensure that.

* MAISTRA-2051: Update MemberRollController for xns-informers

* MAISTRA-2051: Add AddMemberRoll to kube client

* MAISTRA-2051: Configure MemberRoll controller in istiod

MAISTRA-2051: Add xns-informer for Service APIs (istio#229)

* MAISTRA-2051: Update xns-informers

* MAISTRA-2051: Add xns-informer for Service APIs

MAISTRA-2051: Use shared Kubernetes client in galley (istio#241)

This moves galley to the shared Kubernetes client, which will let it
use xns-informers for multi-namespace support like everything else.

MAISTRA-2051: Update xns-informers to latest (istio#252)

* MAISTRA-2051: Reset Kubernetes client to release-1.8 state

* MAISTRA-2051: Use xns-informers in Kubernetes client

* MAISTRA-2051: Un-skip tests with xns-informers issues

These tests were skipped because of issues with xns-informers, which
have now been solved.  They should no longer be skipped.

* MAISTRA-2051: Update xns-informers to latest

* MAISTRA-2051: Skip problematic integration test: TestDashboard

MAISTRA-2051: Use MultiNamespaceInformer in galley (istio#254)

* Revert "MAISTRA-2051: Use shared Kubernetes client in galley (istio#241)"

This reverts commit 0b1567a.

* MAISTRA-2051: Use MultiNamespaceInformer in galley

This is a rework of the previous change that used the central
Kubernetes client in Galley.  The watchers in Galley manage stopping
and starting individual informers, which doesn't work well with the
factory returning cached informers.  This creates multi-namespace
informers individually instead of using the central factory.  It's
also a much smaller change overall and doesn't affect the tests.

* MAISTRA-2051: Add GetMemberRoll method to Kubernetes client

* MAISTRA-2051: Integrate MemberRoll with Galley

This configures the mulit-namespace aware infomers in Galley to
respond to changes in the set of namespaces via the MemberRoll.

This includes parts of the following:

  - 4b70b8d MAISTRA-1895 Add option to enable/disable CRD scan
  - 6e8019e MAISTRA-1968 allow analyzer to work with multi list watcher

MAISTRA-1724: Don't watch namespaces if MemberRoll is used (istio#257)

Rewrite of the following for Maistra 2.1 / Istio 1.8 rebase:

a161a53 - MAISTRA-1724 Don't watch namespaces if MRC is used (istio#161)

MAISTRA-1755: invoke UpdateNamespaces() as part of MemberRollController.Register()

Cherry-pick of f0eed15 for Maistra 2.1 / Istio 1.8 rebase.

MAISTRA-1724: Better hanlde deletion in NamespaceController

MAISTRA-2153: Disable namespace informer if MemberRoll is used (istio#283)

This causes istiod to skip creating the namespace informer in the
Kubernetes service registry controller if a MemberRoll is specified,
because Maistra cannot read namespace objects.  This will affect the
behavior of multi-network deployments that do not use mesh networks
for configuration, i.e. a namespace cannot be labeled with a default
network now.

MAISTRA-2197: Push first update when cache is warm (istio#294)

Change SMMR Controller behavior to only send the first update to
listeners when it has a list of members ready. In other words, when
cache is synced.

Before this, the first update was sent with only one hardcoded member:
The control plane namespace. Now it is sent with the full list of SMMR
members.

While on that, switch to our own log scope, to facilitate debugging.

Manual cherry pick of maistra/istio#291

MAISTRA-2233: Start xns-informers with empty namespace set (istio#303)

The multi-namespace informers created by xns-informers default to
watching all namespaces to match upstream behaviour.  This causes
permissions issues in Maistra because they will do this until the
first update from the MemberRoll controller sets the correct set of
namespaces on each informer.  We should instead explicitly configure
them with an empty set of namespaces at startup.

MAISTRA-2234: Seed MemberRoll listeners with system namespace (istio#302)

The MemberRoll controller was changed in MAISTRA-2197 to not send the
initial update with just the system namespace to all listeners.  This
can be a problem when the user hasn't created an SMMR resource yet,
because any listeners registered before the caches sync may never get
an update informing them to watch the system namespace.

This attempts to work around the issue by having all listeners
individually wait on the caches to sync, then seed just the system
namespace if no SMMR resource is found.

MAISTRA-2271: Update xns-informers to fix delete events issue (istio#315)

This updates xns-informers to include a fix for sending delete events
for all objects when a namespace is no longer watched.

See: maistra/xns-informer#12

Co-authored-by: Brad Ison <brad.ison@redhat.com>

OSSM-2006 Fix multiNamespaceInformer.HasSynced()

fix(xns-informer): only sync nsInformer when not nil (istio#684)

Fix shutting down namespace controller

Signed-off-by: Jacek Ewertowski <jewertow@redhat.com>

OSSM-2233: uses maistra.io/api instead of copying

    Before we were generating and copying Maistra API types, now we use it
    as a dependency.

    Additionally following changes are introduced:

     - vendoring has been removed, as we now use embedded manifests from maistra/api in tests
     - cleans up Makefiles
     - removes unnecessary files (generated API)

OSSM-2375 Log the list of member namespaces on every change (istio#716)

Co-authored-by: Marko Lukša <marko.luksa@gmail.com>

OSSM-3703: Fix AUTO_RELOAD_PLUGIN_CERTS in multi-tenant mode (istio#778)

* OSSM-3703: Fix AUTO_RELOAD_PLUGIN_CERTS in multi-tenant mode

Signed-off-by: Jacek Ewertowski <jewertow@redhat.com>

* Revert unnecessary variable declaration

Signed-off-by: Jacek Ewertowski <jewertow@redhat.com>

---------

Signed-off-by: Jacek Ewertowski <jewertow@redhat.com>
dgn added a commit to dgn/istio that referenced this pull request Jun 13, 2024
MAISTRA-2051: Add xns-informer for Kubernetes types (istio#223)

* Update mirrored licenses to fix gen-check

* MAISTRA-2051: Add xns-informer for Kubernetes types

This integrates the xns-informer library for multi-namespace support,
but only for core Kubernetes types.  The informers are hard-coded to
watch all namespaces here.  The integration with MemberRoll will come
in a follow-up.

MAISTRA-2051 Add xns-informer for Istio types (istio#221)

MAISTRA-2051: Add MemberRollController (istio#227)

* MAISTRA-2051: Add MemberRollController

Includes the following:

* 75742b0 - Add Makefile for Maistra client generation

This adds a Makefile with tasks for generating the Maistra specific
clients. It is adapted from the one in the Istio client-go repository.

* 5f8562c - Add MemberRollController

Squashed commit, consisting of:

  * MAISTRA-417: Add MemberRollController

  * MAISTRA-450: Switch across to ConfiguredMembers and check existing
    config for changes

  * MAISTRA-1005 Do not expect namespaces to have a stable ordering

The clients have also been regenerated.

* 1b7a89d - Add missing licenses

* fe2f8cd - Fix Copyright holder

This is to make sure all PR's will have an updated
vendor directory. The `gencheck` prow job will ensure that.

* MAISTRA-2051: Update MemberRollController for xns-informers

* MAISTRA-2051: Add AddMemberRoll to kube client

* MAISTRA-2051: Configure MemberRoll controller in istiod

MAISTRA-2051: Add xns-informer for Service APIs (istio#229)

* MAISTRA-2051: Update xns-informers

* MAISTRA-2051: Add xns-informer for Service APIs

MAISTRA-2051: Use shared Kubernetes client in galley (istio#241)

This moves galley to the shared Kubernetes client, which will let it
use xns-informers for multi-namespace support like everything else.

MAISTRA-2051: Update xns-informers to latest (istio#252)

* MAISTRA-2051: Reset Kubernetes client to release-1.8 state

* MAISTRA-2051: Use xns-informers in Kubernetes client

* MAISTRA-2051: Un-skip tests with xns-informers issues

These tests were skipped because of issues with xns-informers, which
have now been solved.  They should no longer be skipped.

* MAISTRA-2051: Update xns-informers to latest

* MAISTRA-2051: Skip problematic integration test: TestDashboard

MAISTRA-2051: Use MultiNamespaceInformer in galley (istio#254)

* Revert "MAISTRA-2051: Use shared Kubernetes client in galley (istio#241)"

This reverts commit 0b1567a.

* MAISTRA-2051: Use MultiNamespaceInformer in galley

This is a rework of the previous change that used the central
Kubernetes client in Galley.  The watchers in Galley manage stopping
and starting individual informers, which doesn't work well with the
factory returning cached informers.  This creates multi-namespace
informers individually instead of using the central factory.  It's
also a much smaller change overall and doesn't affect the tests.

* MAISTRA-2051: Add GetMemberRoll method to Kubernetes client

* MAISTRA-2051: Integrate MemberRoll with Galley

This configures the mulit-namespace aware infomers in Galley to
respond to changes in the set of namespaces via the MemberRoll.

This includes parts of the following:

  - 4b70b8d MAISTRA-1895 Add option to enable/disable CRD scan
  - 6e8019e MAISTRA-1968 allow analyzer to work with multi list watcher

MAISTRA-1724: Don't watch namespaces if MemberRoll is used (istio#257)

Rewrite of the following for Maistra 2.1 / Istio 1.8 rebase:

a161a53 - MAISTRA-1724 Don't watch namespaces if MRC is used (istio#161)

MAISTRA-1755: invoke UpdateNamespaces() as part of MemberRollController.Register()

Cherry-pick of f0eed15 for Maistra 2.1 / Istio 1.8 rebase.

MAISTRA-1724: Better hanlde deletion in NamespaceController

MAISTRA-2153: Disable namespace informer if MemberRoll is used (istio#283)

This causes istiod to skip creating the namespace informer in the
Kubernetes service registry controller if a MemberRoll is specified,
because Maistra cannot read namespace objects.  This will affect the
behavior of multi-network deployments that do not use mesh networks
for configuration, i.e. a namespace cannot be labeled with a default
network now.

MAISTRA-2197: Push first update when cache is warm (istio#294)

Change SMMR Controller behavior to only send the first update to
listeners when it has a list of members ready. In other words, when
cache is synced.

Before this, the first update was sent with only one hardcoded member:
The control plane namespace. Now it is sent with the full list of SMMR
members.

While on that, switch to our own log scope, to facilitate debugging.

Manual cherry pick of maistra/istio#291

MAISTRA-2233: Start xns-informers with empty namespace set (istio#303)

The multi-namespace informers created by xns-informers default to
watching all namespaces to match upstream behaviour.  This causes
permissions issues in Maistra because they will do this until the
first update from the MemberRoll controller sets the correct set of
namespaces on each informer.  We should instead explicitly configure
them with an empty set of namespaces at startup.

MAISTRA-2234: Seed MemberRoll listeners with system namespace (istio#302)

The MemberRoll controller was changed in MAISTRA-2197 to not send the
initial update with just the system namespace to all listeners.  This
can be a problem when the user hasn't created an SMMR resource yet,
because any listeners registered before the caches sync may never get
an update informing them to watch the system namespace.

This attempts to work around the issue by having all listeners
individually wait on the caches to sync, then seed just the system
namespace if no SMMR resource is found.

MAISTRA-2271: Update xns-informers to fix delete events issue (istio#315)

This updates xns-informers to include a fix for sending delete events
for all objects when a namespace is no longer watched.

See: maistra/xns-informer#12

Co-authored-by: Brad Ison <brad.ison@redhat.com>

OSSM-2006 Fix multiNamespaceInformer.HasSynced()

fix(xns-informer): only sync nsInformer when not nil (istio#684)

Fix shutting down namespace controller

Signed-off-by: Jacek Ewertowski <jewertow@redhat.com>

OSSM-2233: uses maistra.io/api instead of copying

    Before we were generating and copying Maistra API types, now we use it
    as a dependency.

    Additionally following changes are introduced:

     - vendoring has been removed, as we now use embedded manifests from maistra/api in tests
     - cleans up Makefiles
     - removes unnecessary files (generated API)

OSSM-2375 Log the list of member namespaces on every change (istio#716)

Co-authored-by: Marko Lukša <marko.luksa@gmail.com>

OSSM-3703: Fix AUTO_RELOAD_PLUGIN_CERTS in multi-tenant mode (istio#778)

* OSSM-3703: Fix AUTO_RELOAD_PLUGIN_CERTS in multi-tenant mode

Signed-off-by: Jacek Ewertowski <jewertow@redhat.com>

* Revert unnecessary variable declaration

Signed-off-by: Jacek Ewertowski <jewertow@redhat.com>

---------

Co-authored-by: Marko Lukša <marko.luksa@gmail.com>
Co-authored-by: Jacek Ewertowski <jewertow@redhat.com>
Co-authored-by: Daniel Grimm <dgrimm@redhat.com>
Co-authored-by: Brad Ison <brad.ison@redhat.com>
Signed-off-by: Yann Liu <yannliu@redhat.com>
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Labels
None yet
Projects
None yet
Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

5 participants