Rate limit the processing of rumoured addresses #22387

sipa · 2021-07-02T00:53:33Z

The rate at which IP addresses are rumoured (through ADDR and ADDRV2 messages) on the network seems to vary from 0 for some non-participating nodes, to 0.005-0.025 addr/s for recent Bitcoin Core nodes. However, the current codebase will happily accept and process an effectively unbounded rate from attackers. There are measures to limit the influence attackers can have on the addrman database (bucket restrictions based on source IPs), but still - there is no need to permit them to feed us addresses at a rate that's orders of magnitude larger than what is common on the network today, especially as it will cause us to spam our peers too.

This PR implements a token bucket based rate limiter, allowing an average of 0.1 addr/s per connection, with bursts up to 1000 addresses at once. Whitelisted peers as well as responses to GETADDR requests are exempt from the limit. New connections start with 1 token, so as to not interfere with the common practice of peers' self-announcement.

DrahtBot · 2021-07-02T01:41:05Z

The following sections might be updated with supplementary metadata relevant to reviewers and maintainers.

Conflicts

Reviewers, this pull request conflicts with the following ones:

test: Disable automatic connections per default in the functional tests #22490 by mzumsande
[p2p] Reduce addr blackholes #21528 by amitiuttarwar

If you consider this pull request important, please also help to review the conflicting pull requests. Ideally, start with the one that should be merged first.

ghost · 2021-07-02T03:08:32Z

There are measures to limit the influence attackers can have on the addrman database (bucket restrictions based on IPs), but still - there is no need to permit them to feed us addresses at a rate that's orders of magnitude larger than what is common on the network today, especially as it will cause us to spam our peers too.

Concept ACK

vasild · 2021-07-02T08:02:16Z

Concept ACK

jnewbery

Concept ACK

src/net_processing.cpp

test/functional/p2p_addr_relay.py

ghost · 2021-07-02T17:04:11Z

Compiled the branch but don't want to run test/functional/p2p_addr_relay.py. I want to test it manually on testnet.

Can we do send_and_ping used in the test with some RPC?
How can we try this on testnet? I am assuming: Compile branch, run two nodes on testnet, use addnode, spam other node with random addresses (not sure how to do this?) and compare the results for getnodeaddresses doing same on master branch.

sipa · 2021-07-02T17:13:26Z

@prayank23 No, it's testing a P2P aspect, you can't do that through RPC. There is the addpeeraddress RPC for injecting new addresses, but it doesn't have (or need) the same rate limiting.

mzumsande · 2021-07-02T19:11:30Z

Concept ACK to introducing a rate limiting mechanism for addr relay, some general questions about the approach:

The approach of a constant counter increase doesn't scale with the total number of self-announcing nodes in the network, while addr traffic to a node probably does (or at least should?). Did you consider the possibility of an adaptive rate limiting approach (e.g. let the token counter increase based on recently observed addr frequency from outbound peers or something like that) that could adapt to changes in network size or in the general efficiency of gossip relay over time - or would that be too complicated/have some other downsides?

Choosing the rate limit of 0.1 addr/s based on current observations of 0.005-0.025 addr/s also kind of says that we are happy with the current efficiency of addr gossip - are we though? (#21528 would likely increase it, though I'm not sure by how much)

It would be great to have some historical references about observed addr/s rate (to see whether it has changed significantly over the years with increasing SPV nodes, introduction of block-relay-only connections etc.), but I would assume this kind of data doesn't exist anywhere...

sipa · 2021-07-02T19:26:18Z

@mzumsande Those are reasonable points. My thinking is mostly that some limit here is necessary, and if this appears to be too restrictive as the network or other aspects of addr relay change, they can be revisited - those are unlikely to cause dramatic changes in short periods of time. I think an adaptive limit is too easily exploited.

amitiuttarwar · 2021-07-03T19:00:59Z

So sorry for that accidental close / open 😳

src/net_processing.cpp

test/functional/p2p_addr_relay.py

mzumsande · 2021-07-04T21:50:31Z

src/net_processing.cpp

+        }
+        peer->m_addr_token_timestamp = current_time;
+
+        Shuffle(vAddr.begin(), vAddr.end(), FastRandomContext());


What is the reason for adding the Shuffle here, considering that the token counter grows deterministically and our peer could calculate anyway how many addrs of the packet we would process/discard if they cared to keep track of that?

The idea is that if we're going to be dropping some part of incoming messages because of rate-limiting, we should do it uniformly. This isn't to stop any kind of attack, but to give slightly fairer treatment to existing nodes on the network, which don't randomize on sending (there is random replacement once the outgoing buffer hits 1000, but that is rarely if ever hit under normal network conditions).

vasild

Approach ACK dade562, need to stare a bit more at the test.

src/net_processing.cpp

test/functional/p2p_addr_relay.py

jnewbery

Code review ACK dade562

src/net_processing.cpp

test/functional/p2p_invalid_messages.py

test/functional/p2p_addr_relay.py

vasild · 2021-07-06T16:16:35Z

test/functional/p2p_addr_relay.py

+            # Advance the time by 100 seconds, permitting the processing of 10 more addresses. Send 200,
+            # but verify that no more than 10 are processed.
+            self.mocktime += 100
+            self.nodes[0].setmocktime(self.mocktime)
+            if not no_relay:
+                tokens += 10
+            peer.send_and_ping(self.setup_rand_addr_msg(200))
+            addr_count_4 = len(self.nodes[0].getnodeaddresses(0))
+            assert_greater_than_or_equal(tokens, addr_count_4)
+            assert_greater_than_or_equal(addr_count_3 + 10, addr_count_4)
+
+            # Advance the time by 1000 seconds, permitting the processing of 100 more addresses. Send 200,
+            # but verify that no more than 100 are processed (and at least some).
+            self.mocktime += 1000
+            self.nodes[0].setmocktime(self.mocktime)
+            if not no_relay:
+                tokens += 100
+            peer.send_and_ping(self.setup_rand_addr_msg(200))
+            addr_count_5 = len(self.nodes[0].getnodeaddresses(0))
+            assert_greater_than_or_equal(tokens, addr_count_5)
+            assert_greater_than_or_equal(addr_count_4 + 100, addr_count_5)
+            assert_equal(addr_count_5 > addr_count_4, not no_relay)


Isn't the Advance the time by 100 seconds test unnecessary given the Advance the time by 1000 seconds test? I think the latter is testing everything that the former does.

Perhaps, I'm not entirely sure. The issue is that the last test is a bit weak, as a ton of entries have already been added to addrman (which fills up the relevant buckets asymptotically), so not that much is expected to be added anymore. The test before happens at a point when it's somewhat less full, so it's more appropriate a place to test that not too much is being added. The value of the last test is really only the ability to test that it incremented at all (which isn't guaranteed with 10 extra tokens).

glozow

code review ACK dade562

src/net_processing.cpp

jnewbery

ACK dc8a186

src/net_processing.cpp

vasild

dc8a186 looks good. The 0.005-0.025 addr/s and 0.1 addr/s (MAX_ADDR_RATE_PER_SECOND) numbers may have to be reconsidered though.

I added a prinout to observe the rates on my node.

added printout

         if (peer->m_addr_token_bucket < MAX_ADDR_PROCESSING_TOKEN_BUCKET) {
             // Don't increment bucket if it's already full
             const auto time_diff = std::max(current_time - peer->m_addr_token_timestamp, 0us);
             const double increment = CountSecondsDouble(time_diff) * MAX_ADDR_RATE_PER_SECOND;
             peer->m_addr_token_bucket = std::min<double>(peer->m_addr_token_bucket + increment, MAX_AD
+            LogPrintf("RATE LIMIT: received %u addresses, tokens %u, since last addr message: "
+                      "%.6lf addr/sec, peer %s\n",
+                      vAddr.size(),
+                      peer->m_addr_token_bucket,
+                      vAddr.size() / CountSecondsDouble(time_diff),
+                      pfrom.addr.ToStringIP());
         }

log output

2021-07-07T09:03:34Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 2.86322, since last addr message: 0.034926 addr/sec, peer 70.64.27.12
2021-07-07T09:03:37Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 2.20653, since last addr message: 0.045320 addr/sec, peer 60.244.109.19
2021-07-07T09:03:42Z RATE LIMIT: received 47 addresses, tokens 2.62511, since last addr message: 6.168826 addr/sec, peer 70.64.27.12
2021-07-07T09:03:45Z RATE LIMIT: received 5 addresses, tokens 1.39594, since last addr message: 1.262827 addr/sec, peer shh2ewyegnuwnmdse5kl5toybdvzkvk2yj4zcowz6iwhhh3ykdfa.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:03:45Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 0.396861, since last addr message: 108.236822 addr/sec, peer shh2ewyegnuwnmdse5kl5toybdvzkvk2yj4zcowz6iwhhh3ykdfa.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:03:50Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 2.46857, since last addr message: 0.079237 addr/sec, peer 60.244.109.19
2021-07-07T09:03:55Z RATE LIMIT: received 9 addresses, tokens 7.73186, since last addr message: 0.133693 addr/sec, peer 94.237.44.67
2021-07-07T09:03:56Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 2.12585, since last addr message: 0.152142 addr/sec, peer 60.244.109.19
2021-07-07T09:04:09Z RATE LIMIT: received 10 addresses, tokens 8.06892, since last addr message: 0.141464 addr/sec, peer 140.143.155.41
2021-07-07T09:04:10Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 2.82477, since last addr message: 0.041188 addr/sec, peer shh2ewyegnuwnmdse5kl5toybdvzkvk2yj4zcowz6iwhhh3ykdfa.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:04:12Z RATE LIMIT: received 80 addresses, tokens 3.63509, since last addr message: 2.657828 addr/sec, peer 70.64.27.12
2021-07-07T09:04:15Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 1.87683, since last addr message: 0.053281 addr/sec, peer 168.119.79.89
2021-07-07T09:04:21Z RATE LIMIT: received 3 addresses, tokens 3.55889, since last addr message: 0.123303 addr/sec, peer 60.244.109.19
2021-07-07T09:04:35Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 2.8863, since last addr message: 0.049764 addr/sec, peer 168.119.79.89
2021-07-07T09:04:38Z RATE LIMIT: received 2 addresses, tokens 6.57941, since last addr message: 0.030398 addr/sec, peer 83.150.56.145
2021-07-07T09:04:48Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 3.14096, since last addr message: 0.079703 addr/sec, peer 168.119.79.89
2021-07-07T09:04:53Z RATE LIMIT: received 2 addresses, tokens 6.00251, since last addr message: 0.140538 addr/sec, peer 83.150.56.145
2021-07-07T09:04:53Z RATE LIMIT: received 2 addresses, tokens 4.79277, since last addr message: 0.048104 addr/sec, peer 70.64.27.12
2021-07-07T09:04:55Z RATE LIMIT: received 4 addresses, tokens 9.27792, since last addr message: 0.043113 addr/sec, peer 2a01:4f8:140:948b::2
2021-07-07T09:04:59Z RATE LIMIT: received 2 addresses, tokens 4.60033, since last addr message: 0.334550 addr/sec, peer 83.150.56.145
2021-07-07T09:05:10Z RATE LIMIT: received 2 addresses, tokens 5.48676, since last addr message: 0.040585 addr/sec, peer 60.244.109.19
2021-07-07T09:05:10Z RATE LIMIT: received 2 addresses, tokens 3.28665, since last addr message: 0.155442 addr/sec, peer 35.197.140.219
2021-07-07T09:05:10Z RATE LIMIT: received 4 addresses, tokens 8.39984, since last addr message: 0.047620 addr/sec, peer q5csjdscadbsm27ceyuk7naxveak5yevqlnrowhgcnaxxauwc24zvhqd.onion
2021-07-07T09:05:21Z RATE LIMIT: received 2 addresses, tokens 7.83468, since last addr message: 0.078224 addr/sec, peer 2a01:4f8:140:948b::2
2021-07-07T09:05:22Z RATE LIMIT: received 2 addresses, tokens 2.4901, since last addr message: 0.166190 addr/sec, peer 35.197.140.219
2021-07-07T09:05:30Z RATE LIMIT: received 5 addresses, tokens 9.84058, since last addr message: 0.062377 addr/sec, peer shh2ewyegnuwnmdse5kl5toybdvzkvk2yj4zcowz6iwhhh3ykdfa.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:05:40Z RATE LIMIT: received 7 addresses, tokens 12.8494, since last addr message: 0.059075 addr/sec, peer ppsmb5ln3rx6mfdzx2nwsleug5etsavbbzjkdealaybrh2jo2n6a.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:05:49Z RATE LIMIT: received 4 addresses, tokens 7.42107, since last addr message: 0.101670 addr/sec, peer 60.244.109.19
2021-07-07T09:05:56Z RATE LIMIT: received 5 addresses, tokens 9.09188, since last addr message: 0.079376 addr/sec, peer 70.64.27.12
2021-07-07T09:05:58Z RATE LIMIT: received 4 addresses, tokens 9.56812, since last addr message: 0.107140 addr/sec, peer 2a01:4f8:140:948b::2
2021-07-07T09:06:03Z RATE LIMIT: received 13 addresses, tokens 9.68901, since last addr message: 0.172230 addr/sec, peer 168.119.79.89
2021-07-07T09:06:05Z RATE LIMIT: received 5 addresses, tokens 8.38568, since last addr message: 0.141040 addr/sec, peer shh2ewyegnuwnmdse5kl5toybdvzkvk2yj4zcowz6iwhhh3ykdfa.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:06:06Z RATE LIMIT: received 10 addresses, tokens 9.32125, since last addr message: 0.148789 addr/sec, peer 83.150.56.145
2021-07-07T09:06:11Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 1.4728, since last addr message: 0.127586 addr/sec, peer 168.119.79.89
2021-07-07T09:06:15Z RATE LIMIT: received 4 addresses, tokens 5.84985, since last addr message: 0.074630 addr/sec, peer 35.197.140.219
2021-07-07T09:06:16Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 1.37637, since last addr message: 0.094775 addr/sec, peer 83.150.56.145
2021-07-07T09:06:17Z RATE LIMIT: received 4 addresses, tokens 11.158, since last addr message: 0.059187 addr/sec, peer q5csjdscadbsm27ceyuk7naxveak5yevqlnrowhgcnaxxauwc24zvhqd.onion
2021-07-07T09:06:18Z RATE LIMIT: received 176 addresses, tokens 6.29241, since last addr message: 7.998060 addr/sec, peer 70.64.27.12
2021-07-07T09:06:28Z RATE LIMIT: received 6 addresses, tokens 8.51784, since last addr message: 0.203409 addr/sec, peer 2a01:4f8:140:948b::2
2021-07-07T09:06:30Z RATE LIMIT: received 2 addresses, tokens 1.46008, since last addr message: 0.171282 addr/sec, peer 70.64.27.12
2021-07-07T09:06:30Z RATE LIMIT: received 4 addresses, tokens 1.75868, since last addr message: 0.289371 addr/sec, peer 83.150.56.145
2021-07-07T09:06:36Z RATE LIMIT: received 2 addresses, tokens 2.9657, since last addr message: 0.080228 addr/sec, peer 168.119.79.89
2021-07-07T09:06:36Z RATE LIMIT: received 3 addresses, tokens 3.91656, since last addr message: 0.145159 addr/sec, peer 35.197.140.219
2021-07-07T09:06:39Z RATE LIMIT: received 10 addresses, tokens 11.8759, since last addr message: 0.084204 addr/sec, peer 99.108.237.173
2021-07-07T09:06:44Z RATE LIMIT: received 2 addresses, tokens 7.27696, since last addr message: 0.051397 addr/sec, peer shh2ewyegnuwnmdse5kl5toybdvzkvk2yj4zcowz6iwhhh3ykdfa.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:06:49Z RATE LIMIT: received 91 addresses, tokens 12.7167, since last addr message: 1.325119 addr/sec, peer ppsmb5ln3rx6mfdzx2nwsleug5etsavbbzjkdealaybrh2jo2n6a.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:06:51Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 2.41899, since last addr message: 0.066559 addr/sec, peer 35.197.140.219
2021-07-07T09:07:01Z RATE LIMIT: received 94 addresses, tokens 3.825, since last addr message: 3.065569 addr/sec, peer 83.150.56.145
2021-07-07T09:07:03Z RATE LIMIT: received 8 addresses, tokens 10.7864, since last addr message: 0.108616 addr/sec, peer 60.244.109.19
2021-07-07T09:07:03Z RATE LIMIT: received 6 addresses, tokens 7.15104, since last addr message: 0.320157 addr/sec, peer shh2ewyegnuwnmdse5kl5toybdvzkvk2yj4zcowz6iwhhh3ykdfa.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:07:07Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 1.54945, since last addr message: 0.250995 addr/sec, peer shh2ewyegnuwnmdse5kl5toybdvzkvk2yj4zcowz6iwhhh3ykdfa.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:07:07Z RATE LIMIT: received 6 addresses, tokens 4.06796, since last addr message: 0.193407 addr/sec, peer 168.119.79.89
2021-07-07T09:07:08Z RATE LIMIT: received 4 addresses, tokens 12.2409, since last addr message: 0.078696 addr/sec, peer q5csjdscadbsm27ceyuk7naxveak5yevqlnrowhgcnaxxauwc24zvhqd.onion
2021-07-07T09:07:11Z RATE LIMIT: received 2 addresses, tokens 0.442696, since last addr message: 0.533716 addr/sec, peer 168.119.79.89
2021-07-07T09:07:16Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 1.41633, since last addr message: 0.115357 addr/sec, peer shh2ewyegnuwnmdse5kl5toybdvzkvk2yj4zcowz6iwhhh3ykdfa.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:07:16Z RATE LIMIT: received 5 addresses, tokens 5.07261, since last addr message: 0.108400 addr/sec, peer 70.64.27.12
2021-07-07T09:07:17Z RATE LIMIT: received 2 addresses, tokens 4.17754, since last addr message: 0.143771 addr/sec, peer 60.244.109.19
2021-07-07T09:07:22Z RATE LIMIT: received 8 addresses, tokens 6.1308, since last addr message: 0.188019 addr/sec, peer 99.108.237.173
2021-07-07T09:07:22Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 4.49512, since last addr message: 0.032508 addr/sec, peer 35.197.140.219
2021-07-07T09:07:29Z RATE LIMIT: received 14 addresses, tokens 3.67892, since last addr message: 0.490554 addr/sec, peer 83.150.56.145
2021-07-07T09:07:40Z RATE LIMIT: received 2 addresses, tokens 1.93094, since last addr message: 0.111102 addr/sec, peer 99.108.237.173
2021-07-07T09:07:51Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 2.06634, since last addr message: 0.088075 addr/sec, peer 99.108.237.173
2021-07-07T09:07:56Z RATE LIMIT: received 2 addresses, tokens 4.44477, since last addr message: 0.049647 addr/sec, peer shh2ewyegnuwnmdse5kl5toybdvzkvk2yj4zcowz6iwhhh3ykdfa.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:07:57Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 6.9955, since last addr message: 0.028568 addr/sec, peer 35.197.140.219
2021-07-07T09:08:05Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 2.4855, since last addr message: 0.070464 addr/sec, peer 99.108.237.173
2021-07-07T09:08:20Z RATE LIMIT: received 10 addresses, tokens 5.77878, since last addr message: 0.196084 addr/sec, peer 83.150.56.145
2021-07-07T09:08:24Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 1.10281, since last addr message: 0.308609 addr/sec, peer 83.150.56.145
2021-07-07T09:08:28Z RATE LIMIT: received 7 addresses, tokens 9.35216, since last addr message: 0.097566 addr/sec, peer 60.244.109.19
2021-07-07T09:08:30Z RATE LIMIT: received 10 addresses, tokens 16.4104, since last addr message: 0.122406 addr/sec, peer q5csjdscadbsm27ceyuk7naxveak5yevqlnrowhgcnaxxauwc24zvhqd.onion
2021-07-07T09:08:33Z RATE LIMIT: received 5 addresses, tokens 9.62191, since last addr message: 0.137877 addr/sec, peer 35.197.140.219
2021-07-07T09:08:34Z RATE LIMIT: received 83 addresses, tokens 8.73494, since last addr message: 1.000935 addr/sec, peer 168.119.79.89
2021-07-07T09:08:40Z RATE LIMIT: received 2 addresses, tokens 3.47649, since last addr message: 0.177884 addr/sec, peer 60.244.109.19
2021-07-07T09:08:46Z RATE LIMIT: received 199 addresses, tokens 12.4127, since last addr message: 1.701439 addr/sec, peer ppsmb5ln3rx6mfdzx2nwsleug5etsavbbzjkdealaybrh2jo2n6a.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:08:49Z RATE LIMIT: received 2 addresses, tokens 7.70887, since last addr message: 0.037993 addr/sec, peer shh2ewyegnuwnmdse5kl5toybdvzkvk2yj4zcowz6iwhhh3ykdfa.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:08:52Z RATE LIMIT: received 15 addresses, tokens 9.61034, since last addr message: 0.157270 addr/sec, peer 70.64.27.12
2021-07-07T09:08:59Z RATE LIMIT: received 8 addresses, tokens 31.1254, since last addr message: 0.026321 addr/sec, peer 94.237.44.67
2021-07-07T09:08:59Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 6.76573, since last addr message: 0.094620 addr/sec, peer shh2ewyegnuwnmdse5kl5toybdvzkvk2yj4zcowz6iwhhh3ykdfa.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:08:59Z RATE LIMIT: received 7 addresses, tokens 9.35899, since last addr message: 0.237402 addr/sec, peer q5csjdscadbsm27ceyuk7naxveak5yevqlnrowhgcnaxxauwc24zvhqd.onion
2021-07-07T09:09:04Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 7.66611, since last addr message: 0.032849 addr/sec, peer 35.197.140.219
2021-07-07T09:09:06Z RATE LIMIT: received 2 addresses, tokens 6.43881, since last addr message: 0.297140 addr/sec, peer shh2ewyegnuwnmdse5kl5toybdvzkvk2yj4zcowz6iwhhh3ykdfa.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:09:06Z RATE LIMIT: received 3 addresses, tokens 7.07634, since last addr message: 0.049372 addr/sec, peer 88.99.167.186
2021-07-07T09:09:08Z RATE LIMIT: received 4 addresses, tokens 4.15081, since last addr message: 0.117101 addr/sec, peer 168.119.79.89
2021-07-07T09:09:09Z RATE LIMIT: received 6 addresses, tokens 4.63341, since last addr message: 0.132433 addr/sec, peer 83.150.56.145
2021-07-07T09:09:09Z RATE LIMIT: received 2 addresses, tokens 7.86447, since last addr message: 0.031353 addr/sec, peer 99.108.237.173
2021-07-07T09:09:14Z RATE LIMIT: received 2 addresses, tokens 4.91522, since last addr message: 0.058161 addr/sec, peer 60.244.109.19
2021-07-07T09:09:17Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 6.63053, since last addr message: 0.130539 addr/sec, peer 99.108.237.173
2021-07-07T09:09:20Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 1.77158, since last addr message: 0.087860 addr/sec, peer 83.150.56.145
2021-07-07T09:09:21Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 6.02009, since last addr message: 0.256700 addr/sec, peer 99.108.237.173
2021-07-07T09:09:33Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 2.69065, since last addr message: 0.039372 addr/sec, peer 168.119.79.89
2021-07-07T09:09:37Z RATE LIMIT: received 4 addresses, tokens 6.63737, since last addr message: 0.247329 addr/sec, peer 99.108.237.173
2021-07-07T09:09:42Z RATE LIMIT: received 5 addresses, tokens 2.89588, since last addr message: 0.235373 addr/sec, peer 83.150.56.145
2021-07-07T09:09:44Z RATE LIMIT: received 3 addresses, tokens 2.74131, since last addr message: 0.285537 addr/sec, peer 168.119.79.89
2021-07-07T09:09:48Z RATE LIMIT: received 6 addresses, tokens 6.61979, since last addr message: 0.096663 addr/sec, peer ppsmb5ln3rx6mfdzx2nwsleug5etsavbbzjkdealaybrh2jo2n6a.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:09:58Z RATE LIMIT: received 2 addresses, tokens 7.25036, since last addr message: 0.030120 addr/sec, peer 70.64.27.12
2021-07-07T09:10:03Z RATE LIMIT: received 6 addresses, tokens 1.12039, since last addr message: 4.983790 addr/sec, peer kokkmpquqlkptu5hkmzqlttsmtwxicldr4so7wqsufk6bwf32nma.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:10:03Z RATE LIMIT: received 10 addresses, tokens 35.459, since last addr message: 0.028256 addr/sec, peer 140.143.155.41
2021-07-07T09:10:04Z RATE LIMIT: received 4 addresses, tokens 8.84326, since last addr message: 0.061688 addr/sec, peer q5csjdscadbsm27ceyuk7naxveak5yevqlnrowhgcnaxxauwc24zvhqd.onion
2021-07-07T09:10:06Z RATE LIMIT: received 2 addresses, tokens 3.35639, since last addr message: 0.081284 addr/sec, peer 83.150.56.145
2021-07-07T09:10:08Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 8.26627, since last addr message: 0.018688 addr/sec, peer 60.244.109.19
2021-07-07T09:10:21Z RATE LIMIT: received 2 addresses, tokens 11.9936, since last addr message: 0.026473 addr/sec, peer shh2ewyegnuwnmdse5kl5toybdvzkvk2yj4zcowz6iwhhh3ykdfa.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:10:22Z RATE LIMIT: received 22 addresses, tokens 25.9338, since last addr message: 0.093953 addr/sec, peer 2a01:4f8:140:948b::2
2021-07-07T09:10:25Z RATE LIMIT: received 6 addresses, tokens 14.8514, since last addr message: 0.073303 addr/sec, peer 35.197.140.219
2021-07-07T09:10:28Z RATE LIMIT: received 6 addresses, tokens 7.7032, since last addr message: 0.118441 addr/sec, peer 99.108.237.173
2021-07-07T09:10:28Z RATE LIMIT: received 4 addresses, tokens 5.13672, since last addr message: 0.091004 addr/sec, peer 168.119.79.89
2021-07-07T09:10:30Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 1.98525, since last addr message: 0.354553 addr/sec, peer 99.108.237.173
2021-07-07T09:10:31Z RATE LIMIT: received 3 addresses, tokens 3.85494, since last addr message: 0.120070 addr/sec, peer 83.150.56.145
2021-07-07T09:10:33Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 5.02189, since last addr message: 0.091907 addr/sec, peer 2a01:4f8:140:948b::2
2021-07-07T09:10:34Z RATE LIMIT: received 8 addresses, tokens 7.1298, since last addr message: 0.130510 addr/sec, peer 188.166.69.73
2021-07-07T09:10:37Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 10.0062, since last addr message: 0.086591 addr/sec, peer 35.197.140.219
2021-07-07T09:10:40Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 1.95125, since last addr message: 0.103520 addr/sec, peer 99.108.237.173
2021-07-07T09:10:40Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 1.76504, since last addr message: 0.109878 addr/sec, peer 83.150.56.145
2021-07-07T09:10:53Z RATE LIMIT: received 3 addresses, tokens 6.07525, since last addr message: 0.146101 addr/sec, peer 2a01:4f8:140:948b::2
2021-07-07T09:11:01Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 11.3949, since last addr message: 0.041864 addr/sec, peer 35.197.140.219
2021-07-07T09:11:01Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 7.93659, since last addr message: 0.013667 addr/sec, peer ppsmb5ln3rx6mfdzx2nwsleug5etsavbbzjkdealaybrh2jo2n6a.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:11:04Z RATE LIMIT: received 4 addresses, tokens 4.73447, since last addr message: 0.111181 addr/sec, peer 168.119.79.89
2021-07-07T09:11:06Z RATE LIMIT: received 5 addresses, tokens 12.0644, since last addr message: 0.073378 addr/sec, peer 70.64.27.12
2021-07-07T09:11:10Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 1.39425, since last addr message: 0.151567 addr/sec, peer 168.119.79.89
2021-07-07T09:11:19Z RATE LIMIT: received 7 addresses, tokens 7.78929, since last addr message: 0.091278 addr/sec, peer kokkmpquqlkptu5hkmzqlttsmtwxicldr4so7wqsufk6bwf32nma.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:11:25Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 12.7883, since last addr message: 0.041782 addr/sec, peer 35.197.140.219
2021-07-07T09:11:27Z RATE LIMIT: received 4 addresses, tokens 9.56786, since last addr message: 0.152018 addr/sec, peer ppsmb5ln3rx6mfdzx2nwsleug5etsavbbzjkdealaybrh2jo2n6a.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:11:30Z RATE LIMIT: received 11 addresses, tokens 16.8545, since last addr message: 0.160329 addr/sec, peer shh2ewyegnuwnmdse5kl5toybdvzkvk2yj4zcowz6iwhhh3ykdfa.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:11:33Z RATE LIMIT: received 5 addresses, tokens 15.7998, since last addr message: 0.058592 addr/sec, peer 60.244.109.19
2021-07-07T09:11:37Z RATE LIMIT: received 7 addresses, tokens 14.1585, since last addr message: 0.075146 addr/sec, peer q5csjdscadbsm27ceyuk7naxveak5yevqlnrowhgcnaxxauwc24zvhqd.onion
2021-07-07T09:11:38Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 13.0788, since last addr message: 0.077490 addr/sec, peer 35.197.140.219
2021-07-07T09:11:38Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 6.52139, since last addr message: 0.017372 addr/sec, peer 83.150.56.145
2021-07-07T09:11:44Z RATE LIMIT: received 2 addresses, tokens 10.8577, since last addr message: 0.052725 addr/sec, peer 70.64.27.12
2021-07-07T09:11:49Z RATE LIMIT: received 3 addresses, tokens 8.67377, since last addr message: 0.053586 addr/sec, peer 2a01:4f8:140:948b::2
2021-07-07T09:11:53Z RATE LIMIT: received 4 addresses, tokens 8.10142, since last addr message: 0.157881 addr/sec, peer ppsmb5ln3rx6mfdzx2nwsleug5etsavbbzjkdealaybrh2jo2n6a.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:11:54Z RATE LIMIT: received 5 addresses, tokens 8.37188, since last addr message: 0.067380 addr/sec, peer 99.108.237.173
2021-07-07T09:11:55Z RATE LIMIT: received 6 addresses, tokens 4.32853, since last addr message: 0.169528 addr/sec, peer kokkmpquqlkptu5hkmzqlttsmtwxicldr4so7wqsufk6bwf32nma.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:12:05Z RATE LIMIT: received 6 addresses, tokens 1.37154, since last addr message: 1.614886 addr/sec, peer bitcornrd36coazsbzsz4pdebyzvaplmsalq4kpoljmn6cg6x5zq.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:12:10Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 1.8576, since last addr message: 0.065399 addr/sec, peer kokkmpquqlkptu5hkmzqlttsmtwxicldr4so7wqsufk6bwf32nma.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:12:18Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 1.6976, since last addr message: 0.075411 addr/sec, peer bitcornrd36coazsbzsz4pdebyzvaplmsalq4kpoljmn6cg6x5zq.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:12:25Z RATE LIMIT: received 3 addresses, tokens 2.36533, since last addr message: 0.198975 addr/sec, peer kokkmpquqlkptu5hkmzqlttsmtwxicldr4so7wqsufk6bwf32nma.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:12:27Z RATE LIMIT: received 4 addresses, tokens 9.48712, since last addr message: 0.104895 addr/sec, peer 2a01:4f8:140:948b::2
2021-07-07T09:12:27Z RATE LIMIT: received 4 addresses, tokens 11.5973, since last addr message: 0.069652 addr/sec, peer shh2ewyegnuwnmdse5kl5toybdvzkvk2yj4zcowz6iwhhh3ykdfa.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:12:33Z RATE LIMIT: received 3 addresses, tokens 8.14854, since last addr message: 0.074127 addr/sec, peer ppsmb5ln3rx6mfdzx2nwsleug5etsavbbzjkdealaybrh2jo2n6a.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:12:35Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 8.33247, since last addr message: 0.136026 addr/sec, peer shh2ewyegnuwnmdse5kl5toybdvzkvk2yj4zcowz6iwhhh3ykdfa.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:12:36Z RATE LIMIT: received 14 addresses, tokens 8.95071, since last addr message: 0.163619 addr/sec, peer 168.119.79.89
2021-07-07T09:12:40Z RATE LIMIT: received 4 addresses, tokens 17.5469, since last addr message: 0.059285 addr/sec, peer 60.244.109.19
2021-07-07T09:12:48Z RATE LIMIT: received 2 addresses, tokens 7.52695, since last addr message: 0.098047 addr/sec, peer 2a01:4f8:140:948b::2
2021-07-07T09:12:56Z RATE LIMIT: received 11 addresses, tokens 13.2845, since last addr message: 0.141696 addr/sec, peer 83.150.56.145
2021-07-07T09:12:57Z RATE LIMIT: received 2 addresses, tokens 15.1406, since last addr message: 0.025056 addr/sec, peer q5csjdscadbsm27ceyuk7naxveak5yevqlnrowhgcnaxxauwc24zvhqd.onion
2021-07-07T09:12:57Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 16.1891, since last addr message: 0.013640 addr/sec, peer 70.64.27.12
2021-07-07T09:12:58Z RATE LIMIT: received 7 addresses, tokens 9.76227, since last addr message: 0.109539 addr/sec, peer 99.108.237.173
2021-07-07T09:13:02Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 20.5312, since last addr message: 0.011831 addr/sec, peer 35.197.140.219
2021-07-07T09:13:05Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 3.88256, since last addr message: 0.034108 addr/sec, peer 168.119.79.89
2021-07-07T09:13:13Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 20.5826, since last addr message: 0.095115 addr/sec, peer 35.197.140.219
2021-07-07T09:13:18Z RATE LIMIT: received 2 addresses, tokens 17.2855, since last addr message: 0.053496 addr/sec, peer 60.244.109.19
2021-07-07T09:13:19Z RATE LIMIT: received 2 addresses, tokens 4.66017, since last addr message: 0.084186 addr/sec, peer 83.150.56.145
2021-07-07T09:13:21Z RATE LIMIT: received 6 addresses, tokens 5.90778, since last addr message: 0.108256 addr/sec, peer kokkmpquqlkptu5hkmzqlttsmtwxicldr4so7wqsufk6bwf32nma.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:13:23Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 17.7021, since last addr message: 0.039794 addr/sec, peer 70.64.27.12
2021-07-07T09:13:28Z RATE LIMIT: received 6 addresses, tokens 7.67042, since last addr message: 0.086048 addr/sec, peer bitcornrd36coazsbzsz4pdebyzvaplmsalq4kpoljmn6cg6x5zq.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:13:30Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 21.2579, since last addr message: 0.059689 addr/sec, peer 35.197.140.219
2021-07-07T09:13:34Z RATE LIMIT: received 2 addresses, tokens 11.2143, since last addr message: 0.032972 addr/sec, peer ppsmb5ln3rx6mfdzx2nwsleug5etsavbbzjkdealaybrh2jo2n6a.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:13:34Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 17.8771, since last addr message: 0.085106 addr/sec, peer 70.64.27.12
2021-07-07T09:13:38Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 6.73124, since last addr message: 0.025195 addr/sec, peer 99.108.237.173
2021-07-07T09:13:42Z RATE LIMIT: received 3 addresses, tokens 14.0147, since last addr message: 0.044895 addr/sec, peer shh2ewyegnuwnmdse5kl5toybdvzkvk2yj4zcowz6iwhhh3ykdfa.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:13:42Z RATE LIMIT: received 4 addresses, tokens 10.9478, since last addr message: 0.073789 addr/sec, peer 2a01:4f8:140:948b::2
2021-07-07T09:13:45Z RATE LIMIT: received 66 addresses, tokens 6.83065, since last addr message: 1.671692 addr/sec, peer 168.119.79.89
2021-07-07T09:13:52Z RATE LIMIT: received 9 addresses, tokens 52.4549, since last addr message: 0.030686 addr/sec, peer 94.237.44.67
2021-07-07T09:13:54Z RATE LIMIT: received 2 addresses, tokens 7.35356, since last addr message: 0.123280 addr/sec, peer 99.108.237.173
2021-07-07T09:13:57Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 4.54626, since last addr message: 0.034772 addr/sec, peer bitcornrd36coazsbzsz4pdebyzvaplmsalq4kpoljmn6cg6x5zq.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:14:00Z RATE LIMIT: received 2 addresses, tokens 19.4917, since last addr message: 0.076494 addr/sec, peer 70.64.27.12
2021-07-07T09:14:08Z RATE LIMIT: received 2 addresses, tokens 5.61784, since last addr message: 0.042462 addr/sec, peer kokkmpquqlkptu5hkmzqlttsmtwxicldr4so7wqsufk6bwf32nma.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:14:12Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 9.95957, since last addr message: 0.033203 addr/sec, peer 2a01:4f8:140:948b::2
2021-07-07T09:14:20Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 25.3504, since last addr message: 0.019637 addr/sec, peer 35.197.140.219
2021-07-07T09:14:21Z RATE LIMIT: received 2 addresses, tokens 14.9628, since last addr message: 0.050657 addr/sec, peer shh2ewyegnuwnmdse5kl5toybdvzkvk2yj4zcowz6iwhhh3ykdfa.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:14:29Z RATE LIMIT: received 3 addresses, tokens 9.6525, since last addr message: 0.042904 addr/sec, peer 83.150.56.145
2021-07-07T09:14:34Z RATE LIMIT: received 2 addresses, tokens 14.2092, since last addr message: 0.160458 addr/sec, peer shh2ewyegnuwnmdse5kl5toybdvzkvk2yj4zcowz6iwhhh3ykdfa.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:14:34Z RATE LIMIT: received 2 addresses, tokens 11.1131, since last addr message: 0.092873 addr/sec, peer 2a01:4f8:140:948b::2
2021-07-07T09:14:34Z RATE LIMIT: received 2 addresses, tokens 22.9471, since last addr message: 0.026104 addr/sec, peer 60.244.109.19
2021-07-07T09:14:37Z RATE LIMIT: received 4 addresses, tokens 23.1445, since last addr message: 0.039984 addr/sec, peer q5csjdscadbsm27ceyuk7naxveak5yevqlnrowhgcnaxxauwc24zvhqd.onion
2021-07-07T09:14:39Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 21.4509, since last addr message: 0.198521 addr/sec, peer 60.244.109.19
2021-07-07T09:14:44Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 19.7678, since last addr message: 0.160441 addr/sec, peer q5csjdscadbsm27ceyuk7naxveak5yevqlnrowhgcnaxxauwc24zvhqd.onion
2021-07-07T09:14:44Z RATE LIMIT: received 3 addresses, tokens 6.76405, since last addr message: 0.050561 addr/sec, peer 168.119.79.89
2021-07-07T09:14:49Z RATE LIMIT: received 5 addresses, tokens 7.78816, since last addr message: 0.119895 addr/sec, peer kokkmpquqlkptu5hkmzqlttsmtwxicldr4so7wqsufk6bwf32nma.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:14:57Z RATE LIMIT: received 2 addresses, tokens 9.54201, since last addr message: 0.033357 addr/sec, peer bitcornrd36coazsbzsz4pdebyzvaplmsalq4kpoljmn6cg6x5zq.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:14:58Z RATE LIMIT: received 3 addresses, tokens 11.7892, since last addr message: 0.046615 addr/sec, peer 99.108.237.173
2021-07-07T09:15:00Z RATE LIMIT: received 2 addresses, tokens 5.3318, since last addr message: 0.127571 addr/sec, peer 168.119.79.89
2021-07-07T09:15:10Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 21.4629, since last addr message: 0.037105 addr/sec, peer q5csjdscadbsm27ceyuk7naxveak5yevqlnrowhgcnaxxauwc24zvhqd.onion
2021-07-07T09:15:13Z RATE LIMIT: received 3 addresses, tokens 11.0482, since last addr message: 0.068249 addr/sec, peer 83.150.56.145
2021-07-07T09:15:19Z RATE LIMIT: received 2 addresses, tokens 10.858, since last addr message: 0.096673 addr/sec, peer 99.108.237.173
2021-07-07T09:15:20Z RATE LIMIT: received 10 addresses, tokens 16.8365, since last addr message: 0.216110 addr/sec, peer shh2ewyegnuwnmdse5kl5toybdvzkvk2yj4zcowz6iwhhh3ykdfa.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:15:22Z RATE LIMIT: received 4 addresses, tokens 30.4833, since last addr message: 0.065221 addr/sec, peer 35.197.140.219
2021-07-07T09:15:26Z RATE LIMIT: received 2 addresses, tokens 14.3614, since last addr message: 0.038107 addr/sec, peer 2a01:4f8:140:948b::2
2021-07-07T09:15:30Z RATE LIMIT: received 3 addresses, tokens 20.8126, since last addr message: 0.025866 addr/sec, peer ppsmb5ln3rx6mfdzx2nwsleug5etsavbbzjkdealaybrh2jo2n6a.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:15:32Z RATE LIMIT: received 4 addresses, tokens 25.7308, since last addr message: 0.075759 addr/sec, peer 60.244.109.19
2021-07-07T09:15:35Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 10.4747, since last addr message: 0.061857 addr/sec, peer 99.108.237.173
2021-07-07T09:15:42Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 22.7058, since last addr message: 0.102559 addr/sec, peer 60.244.109.19
2021-07-07T09:15:44Z RATE LIMIT: received 214 addresses, tokens 27.8031, since last addr message: 2.075361 addr/sec, peer 70.64.27.12
2021-07-07T09:15:46Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 19.4894, since last addr message: 0.059634 addr/sec, peer ppsmb5ln3rx6mfdzx2nwsleug5etsavbbzjkdealaybrh2jo2n6a.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:15:53Z RATE LIMIT: received 2 addresses, tokens 9.19042, since last addr message: 0.031239 addr/sec, peer kokkmpquqlkptu5hkmzqlttsmtwxicldr4so7wqsufk6bwf32nma.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:15:56Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 12.2993, since last addr message: 0.023523 addr/sec, peer 83.150.56.145
2021-07-07T09:16:00Z RATE LIMIT: received 8 addresses, tokens 13.8318, since last addr message: 0.127190 addr/sec, peer bitcornrd36coazsbzsz4pdebyzvaplmsalq4kpoljmn6cg6x5zq.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:16:04Z RATE LIMIT: received 5 addresses, tokens 23.8656, since last addr message: 0.231506 addr/sec, peer 60.244.109.19
2021-07-07T09:16:07Z RATE LIMIT: received 6 addresses, tokens 8.72865, since last addr message: 0.077633 addr/sec, peer 34.64.249.186
2021-07-07T09:16:08Z RATE LIMIT: received 2 addresses, tokens 12.7048, since last addr message: 0.061916 addr/sec, peer 99.108.237.173
2021-07-07T09:16:13Z RATE LIMIT: received 4 addresses, tokens 12.1641, since last addr message: 0.075080 addr/sec, peer shh2ewyegnuwnmdse5kl5toybdvzkvk2yj4zcowz6iwhhh3ykdfa.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:16:14Z RATE LIMIT: received 2 addresses, tokens 9.2765, since last addr message: 0.095874 addr/sec, peer kokkmpquqlkptu5hkmzqlttsmtwxicldr4so7wqsufk6bwf32nma.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:16:21Z RATE LIMIT: received 2 addresses, tokens 27.4736, since last addr message: 0.028528 addr/sec, peer q5csjdscadbsm27ceyuk7naxveak5yevqlnrowhgcnaxxauwc24zvhqd.onion
2021-07-07T09:16:24Z RATE LIMIT: received 2 addresses, tokens 4.89172, since last addr message: 0.048917 addr/sec, peer 70.64.27.12
2021-07-07T09:16:25Z RATE LIMIT: received 6 addresses, tokens 63.6259, since last addr message: 0.015720 addr/sec, peer 140.143.155.41
2021-07-07T09:16:31Z RATE LIMIT: received 5 addresses, tokens 33.3879, since last addr message: 0.072416 addr/sec, peer 35.197.140.219
2021-07-07T09:16:36Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 9.4441, since last addr message: 0.046134 addr/sec, peer kokkmpquqlkptu5hkmzqlttsmtwxicldr4so7wqsufk6bwf32nma.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:16:36Z RATE LIMIT: received 16 addresses, tokens 12.9596, since last addr message: 0.166185 addr/sec, peer 168.119.79.89
2021-07-07T09:16:36Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 22.1182, since last addr message: 0.030745 addr/sec, peer 60.244.109.19
2021-07-07T09:16:38Z RATE LIMIT: received 3 addresses, tokens 9.64981, since last addr message: 0.078575 addr/sec, peer bitcornrd36coazsbzsz4pdebyzvaplmsalq4kpoljmn6cg6x5zq.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:16:40Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 10.8341, since last addr message: 0.037454 addr/sec, peer shh2ewyegnuwnmdse5kl5toybdvzkvk2yj4zcowz6iwhhh3ykdfa.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:16:42Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 1.53153, since last addr message: 0.174854 addr/sec, peer 168.119.79.89
2021-07-07T09:16:42Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 4.65103, since last addr message: 0.056841 addr/sec, peer 70.64.27.12
2021-07-07T09:16:45Z RATE LIMIT: received 8 addresses, tokens 20.2268, since last addr message: 0.101711 addr/sec, peer 2a01:4f8:140:948b::2
2021-07-07T09:16:46Z RATE LIMIT: received 2 addresses, tokens 10.4692, since last addr message: 0.314913 addr/sec, peer shh2ewyegnuwnmdse5kl5toybdvzkvk2yj4zcowz6iwhhh3ykdfa.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:16:49Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 7.75894, since last addr message: 0.090161 addr/sec, peer bitcornrd36coazsbzsz4pdebyzvaplmsalq4kpoljmn6cg6x5zq.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:16:50Z RATE LIMIT: received 3 addresses, tokens 22.5355, since last addr message: 0.211675 addr/sec, peer 60.244.109.19
2021-07-07T09:16:51Z RATE LIMIT: received 4 addresses, tokens 28.4708, since last addr message: 0.133455 addr/sec, peer q5csjdscadbsm27ceyuk7naxveak5yevqlnrowhgcnaxxauwc24zvhqd.onion
2021-07-07T09:17:01Z RATE LIMIT: received 2 addresses, tokens 25.9197, since last addr message: 0.026917 addr/sec, peer ppsmb5ln3rx6mfdzx2nwsleug5etsavbbzjkdealaybrh2jo2n6a.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:17:01Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 7.97517, since last addr message: 0.082222 addr/sec, peer bitcornrd36coazsbzsz4pdebyzvaplmsalq4kpoljmn6cg6x5zq.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:17:09Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 6.37987, since last addr message: 0.036646 addr/sec, peer 70.64.27.12
2021-07-07T09:17:15Z RATE LIMIT: received 5 addresses, tokens 12.2982, since last addr message: 0.129731 addr/sec, peer kokkmpquqlkptu5hkmzqlttsmtwxicldr4so7wqsufk6bwf32nma.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:17:27Z RATE LIMIT: received 2 addresses, tokens 34.0466, since last addr message: 0.035344 addr/sec, peer 35.197.140.219
2021-07-07T09:17:28Z RATE LIMIT: received 3 addresses, tokens 9.66036, since last addr message: 0.111724 addr/sec, peer bitcornrd36coazsbzsz4pdebyzvaplmsalq4kpoljmn6cg6x5zq.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:17:31Z RATE LIMIT: received 6 addresses, tokens 12.9883, since last addr message: 0.132769 addr/sec, peer shh2ewyegnuwnmdse5kl5toybdvzkvk2yj4zcowz6iwhhh3ykdfa.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:17:39Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 33.2238, since last addr message: 0.084950 addr/sec, peer 35.197.140.219
2021-07-07T09:17:40Z RATE LIMIT: received 9 addresses, tokens 19.9434, since last addr message: 0.097418 addr/sec, peer 99.108.237.173
2021-07-07T09:17:47Z RATE LIMIT: received 15 addresses, tokens 22.4076, since last addr message: 0.135034 addr/sec, peer 83.150.56.145
2021-07-07T09:17:50Z RATE LIMIT: received 8 addresses, tokens 7.37865, since last addr message: 0.116837 addr/sec, peer 168.119.79.89
2021-07-07T09:17:59Z RATE LIMIT: received 2 addresses, tokens 12.8546, since last addr message: 0.104646 addr/sec, peer 99.108.237.173
2021-07-07T09:18:04Z RATE LIMIT: received 5 addresses, tokens 30.2376, since last addr message: 0.079140 addr/sec, peer ppsmb5ln3rx6mfdzx2nwsleug5etsavbbzjkdealaybrh2jo2n6a.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:18:06Z RATE LIMIT: received 4 addresses, tokens 12.4384, since last addr message: 0.077818 addr/sec, peer kokkmpquqlkptu5hkmzqlttsmtwxicldr4so7wqsufk6bwf32nma.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:18:07Z RATE LIMIT: received 3 addresses, tokens 9.46511, since last addr message: 0.145804 addr/sec, peer 83.150.56.145
2021-07-07T09:18:13Z RATE LIMIT: received 4 addresses, tokens 32.7461, since last addr message: 0.048337 addr/sec, peer q5csjdscadbsm27ceyuk7naxveak5yevqlnrowhgcnaxxauwc24zvhqd.onion
2021-07-07T09:18:18Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 12.7406, since last addr message: 0.053024 addr/sec, peer 99.108.237.173
2021-07-07T09:18:19Z RATE LIMIT: received 9 addresses, tokens 28.4098, since last addr message: 0.101416 addr/sec, peer 60.244.109.19
2021-07-07T09:18:28Z RATE LIMIT: received 7 addresses, tokens 13.2928, since last addr message: 0.088463 addr/sec, peer 70.64.27.12
2021-07-07T09:18:32Z RATE LIMIT: received 2 addresses, tokens 28.085, since last addr message: 0.070241 addr/sec, peer ppsmb5ln3rx6mfdzx2nwsleug5etsavbbzjkdealaybrh2jo2n6a.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:18:34Z RATE LIMIT: received 7 addresses, tokens 4.74655, since last addr message: 0.160260 addr/sec, peer 168.119.79.89
2021-07-07T09:18:37Z RATE LIMIT: received 9 addresses, tokens 71.9678, since last addr message: 0.031565 addr/sec, peer 94.237.44.67
2021-07-07T09:18:44Z RATE LIMIT: received 2 addresses, tokens 10.1363, since last addr message: 0.054478 addr/sec, peer 83.150.56.145
2021-07-07T09:18:46Z RATE LIMIT: received 3 addresses, tokens 8.03067, since last addr message: 0.172626 addr/sec, peer 70.64.27.12
2021-07-07T09:18:46Z RATE LIMIT: received 2 addresses, tokens 5.03104, since last addr message: 540.394488 addr/sec, peer 70.64.27.12
2021-07-07T09:18:46Z RATE LIMIT: received 9 addresses, tokens 14.4638, since last addr message: 0.120394 addr/sec, peer shh2ewyegnuwnmdse5kl5toybdvzkvk2yj4zcowz6iwhhh3ykdfa.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:18:47Z RATE LIMIT: received 2 addresses, tokens 27.5203, since last addr message: 0.139338 addr/sec, peer ppsmb5ln3rx6mfdzx2nwsleug5etsavbbzjkdealaybrh2jo2n6a.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:18:51Z RATE LIMIT: received 4 addresses, tokens 15.0162, since last addr message: 0.122112 addr/sec, peer 99.108.237.173
2021-07-07T09:18:51Z RATE LIMIT: received 9 addresses, tokens 24.8676, since last addr message: 0.071198 addr/sec, peer 2a01:4f8:140:948b::2
2021-07-07T09:18:53Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 2.62657, since last addr message: 0.053191 addr/sec, peer 168.119.79.89
2021-07-07T09:18:53Z RATE LIMIT: received 2 addresses, tokens 3.74545, since last addr message: 0.279951 addr/sec, peer 70.64.27.12
2021-07-07T09:18:53Z RATE LIMIT: received 5 addresses, tokens 13.1584, since last addr message: 0.105932 addr/sec, peer kokkmpquqlkptu5hkmzqlttsmtwxicldr4so7wqsufk6bwf32nma.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:18:56Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 16.3891, since last addr message: 0.191768 addr/sec, peer 2a01:4f8:140:948b::2
2021-07-07T09:19:02Z RATE LIMIT: received 2 addresses, tokens 15.9748, since last addr message: 0.341468 addr/sec, peer 2a01:4f8:140:948b::2
2021-07-07T09:19:03Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 2.73152, since last addr message: 0.101413 addr/sec, peer 70.64.27.12
2021-07-07T09:19:03Z RATE LIMIT: received 14 addresses, tokens 16.171, since last addr message: 0.147203 addr/sec, peer bitcornrd36coazsbzsz4pdebyzvaplmsalq4kpoljmn6cg6x5zq.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:19:06Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 14.3582, since last addr message: 0.260813 addr/sec, peer 2a01:4f8:140:948b::2
2021-07-07T09:19:12Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 3.11512, since last addr message: 0.105922 addr/sec, peer bitcornrd36coazsbzsz4pdebyzvaplmsalq4kpoljmn6cg6x5zq.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:19:15Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 2.39884, since last addr message: 0.352464 addr/sec, peer bitcornrd36coazsbzsz4pdebyzvaplmsalq4kpoljmn6cg6x5zq.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:19:18Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 8.62582, since last addr message: 0.031625 addr/sec, peer shh2ewyegnuwnmdse5kl5toybdvzkvk2yj4zcowz6iwhhh3ykdfa.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:19:27Z RATE LIMIT: received 5 addresses, tokens 43.0025, since last addr message: 0.046388 addr/sec, peer 35.197.140.219
2021-07-07T09:19:30Z RATE LIMIT: received 2 addresses, tokens 38.3174, since last addr message: 0.635193 addr/sec, peer 35.197.140.219
2021-07-07T09:19:32Z RATE LIMIT: received 4 addresses, tokens 15.128, since last addr message: 0.097281 addr/sec, peer 99.108.237.173
2021-07-07T09:19:33Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 30.1271, since last addr message: 0.021707 addr/sec, peer ppsmb5ln3rx6mfdzx2nwsleug5etsavbbzjkdealaybrh2jo2n6a.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:19:33Z RATE LIMIT: received 3 addresses, tokens 16.073, since last addr message: 0.110506 addr/sec, peer 2a01:4f8:140:948b::2
2021-07-07T09:19:33Z RATE LIMIT: received 8 addresses, tokens 13.0779, since last addr message: 0.161893 addr/sec, peer 83.150.56.145
2021-07-07T09:19:34Z RATE LIMIT: received 5 addresses, tokens 26.8733, since last addr message: 0.066993 addr/sec, peer 60.244.109.19
2021-07-07T09:19:37Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 36.9902, since last addr message: 0.148625 addr/sec, peer 35.197.140.219
2021-07-07T09:19:42Z RATE LIMIT: received 6 addresses, tokens 37.6269, since last addr message: 0.067562 addr/sec, peer q5csjdscadbsm27ceyuk7naxveak5yevqlnrowhgcnaxxauwc24zvhqd.onion
2021-07-07T09:19:43Z RATE LIMIT: received 2 addresses, tokens 10.1248, since last addr message: 0.080033 addr/sec, peer shh2ewyegnuwnmdse5kl5toybdvzkvk2yj4zcowz6iwhhh3ykdfa.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:19:44Z RATE LIMIT: received 4 addresses, tokens 4.23541, since last addr message: 0.141016 addr/sec, peer bitcornrd36coazsbzsz4pdebyzvaplmsalq4kpoljmn6cg6x5zq.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:19:46Z RATE LIMIT: received 5 addresses, tokens 13.4185, since last addr message: 0.095056 addr/sec, peer kokkmpquqlkptu5hkmzqlttsmtwxicldr4so7wqsufk6bwf32nma.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:19:50Z RATE LIMIT: received 2 addresses, tokens 8.9049, since last addr message: 0.256379 addr/sec, peer shh2ewyegnuwnmdse5kl5toybdvzkvk2yj4zcowz6iwhhh3ykdfa.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:19:56Z RATE LIMIT: received 2 addresses, tokens 31.4362, since last addr message: 0.086615 addr/sec, peer ppsmb5ln3rx6mfdzx2nwsleug5etsavbbzjkdealaybrh2jo2n6a.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:19:58Z RATE LIMIT: received 4 addresses, tokens 7.20972, since last addr message: 0.073017 addr/sec, peer 70.64.27.12
2021-07-07T09:20:03Z RATE LIMIT: received 2 addresses, tokens 38.6171, since last addr message: 0.076138 addr/sec, peer 35.197.140.219
2021-07-07T09:20:05Z RATE LIMIT: received 3 addresses, tokens 24.9634, since last addr message: 0.097085 addr/sec, peer 60.244.109.19
2021-07-07T09:20:10Z RATE LIMIT: received 3 addresses, tokens 8.72288, since last addr message: 0.082304 addr/sec, peer 83.150.56.145
2021-07-07T09:20:12Z RATE LIMIT: received 2 addresses, tokens 9.03493, since last addr message: 0.093895 addr/sec, peer shh2ewyegnuwnmdse5kl5toybdvzkvk2yj4zcowz6iwhhh3ykdfa.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:20:17Z RATE LIMIT: received 2 addresses, tokens 6.40706, since last addr message: 0.292323 addr/sec, peer 83.150.56.145
2021-07-07T09:20:19Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 7.76774, since last addr message: 0.136461 addr/sec, peer shh2ewyegnuwnmdse5kl5toybdvzkvk2yj4zcowz6iwhhh3ykdfa.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:20:24Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 35.8485, since last addr message: 0.023687 addr/sec, peer q5csjdscadbsm27ceyuk7naxveak5yevqlnrowhgcnaxxauwc24zvhqd.onion
2021-07-07T09:20:32Z RATE LIMIT: received 5 addresses, tokens 5.11436, since last addr message: 0.102481 addr/sec, peer bitcornrd36coazsbzsz4pdebyzvaplmsalq4kpoljmn6cg6x5zq.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:20:35Z RATE LIMIT: received 6 addresses, tokens 6.9078, since last addr message: 0.162246 addr/sec, peer 70.64.27.12
2021-07-07T09:20:38Z RATE LIMIT: received 8 addresses, tokens 12.1765, since last addr message: 0.075830 addr/sec, peer 168.119.79.89
2021-07-07T09:20:43Z RATE LIMIT: received 2 addresses, tokens 18.2824, since last addr message: 0.027955 addr/sec, peer 99.108.237.173
2021-07-07T09:20:50Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 37.4015, since last addr message: 0.039169 addr/sec, peer q5csjdscadbsm27ceyuk7naxveak5yevqlnrowhgcnaxxauwc24zvhqd.onion
2021-07-07T09:20:57Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 37.094, since last addr message: 0.144418 addr/sec, peer q5csjdscadbsm27ceyuk7naxveak5yevqlnrowhgcnaxxauwc24zvhqd.onion
2021-07-07T09:20:59Z RATE LIMIT: received 9 addresses, tokens 15.781, since last addr message: 0.122241 addr/sec, peer kokkmpquqlkptu5hkmzqlttsmtwxicldr4so7wqsufk6bwf32nma.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:21:02Z RATE LIMIT: received 5 addresses, tokens 21.9935, since last addr message: 0.056050 addr/sec, peer 2a01:4f8:140:948b::2
2021-07-07T09:21:03Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 3.16555, since last addr message: 0.032774 addr/sec, peer bitcornrd36coazsbzsz4pdebyzvaplmsalq4kpoljmn6cg6x5zq.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:21:06Z RATE LIMIT: received 4 addresses, tokens 9.3157, since last addr message: 0.081489 addr/sec, peer 83.150.56.145
2021-07-07T09:21:09Z RATE LIMIT: received 3 addresses, tokens 11.7394, since last addr message: 0.060342 addr/sec, peer shh2ewyegnuwnmdse5kl5toybdvzkvk2yj4zcowz6iwhhh3ykdfa.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:21:26Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 19.3838, since last addr message: 0.041837 addr/sec, peer 2a01:4f8:140:948b::2
2021-07-07T09:21:27Z RATE LIMIT: received 3 addresses, tokens 10.5198, since last addr message: 0.168494 addr/sec, peer shh2ewyegnuwnmdse5kl5toybdvzkvk2yj4zcowz6iwhhh3ykdfa.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:21:29Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 7.67079, since last addr message: 0.042461 addr/sec, peer 83.150.56.145
2021-07-07T09:21:31Z RATE LIMIT: received 9 addresses, tokens 30.6118, since last addr message: 0.104065 addr/sec, peer 60.244.109.19
2021-07-07T09:21:33Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 8.1774, since last addr message: 0.152077 addr/sec, peer shh2ewyegnuwnmdse5kl5toybdvzkvk2yj4zcowz6iwhhh3ykdfa.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:21:39Z RATE LIMIT: received 4 addresses, tokens 39.7242, since last addr message: 0.038880 addr/sec, peer ppsmb5ln3rx6mfdzx2nwsleug5etsavbbzjkdealaybrh2jo2n6a.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:21:40Z RATE LIMIT: received 12 addresses, tokens 5.88517, since last addr message: 0.322613 addr/sec, peer bitcornrd36coazsbzsz4pdebyzvaplmsalq4kpoljmn6cg6x5zq.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:21:42Z RATE LIMIT: received 10 addresses, tokens 7.64514, since last addr message: 0.148427 addr/sec, peer 70.64.27.12
2021-07-07T09:21:43Z RATE LIMIT: received 3 addresses, tokens 20.0595, since last addr message: 0.179032 addr/sec, peer 2a01:4f8:140:948b::2
2021-07-07T09:21:44Z RATE LIMIT: received 7 addresses, tokens 11.2075, since last addr message: 0.158139 addr/sec, peer kokkmpquqlkptu5hkmzqlttsmtwxicldr4so7wqsufk6bwf32nma.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:21:48Z RATE LIMIT: received 5 addresses, tokens 22.7058, since last addr message: 0.077841 addr/sec, peer 99.108.237.173
2021-07-07T09:21:49Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 1.24254, since last addr message: 0.412299 addr/sec, peer i3hcdakiz2tyvggkwefvdjoi7444kgvd2mbdfizjvv43q7zukezq.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:21:49Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 4.78603, since last addr message: 0.172842 addr/sec, peer kokkmpquqlkptu5hkmzqlttsmtwxicldr4so7wqsufk6bwf32nma.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:21:55Z RATE LIMIT: received 6 addresses, tokens 41.8893, since last addr message: 0.103532 addr/sec, peer q5csjdscadbsm27ceyuk7naxveak5yevqlnrowhgcnaxxauwc24zvhqd.onion
2021-07-07T09:21:56Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 18.5135, since last addr message: 0.123799 addr/sec, peer 99.108.237.173
2021-07-07T09:21:58Z RATE LIMIT: received 10 addresses, tokens 48.1238, since last addr message: 0.086906 addr/sec, peer 35.197.140.219
2021-07-07T09:21:59Z RATE LIMIT: received 3 addresses, tokens 9.75226, since last addr message: 0.116511 addr/sec, peer shh2ewyegnuwnmdse5kl5toybdvzkvk2yj4zcowz6iwhhh3ykdfa.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:22:01Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 18.8451, since last addr message: 0.056002 addr/sec, peer 2a01:4f8:140:948b::2
2021-07-07T09:22:04Z RATE LIMIT: received 2 addresses, tokens 10.1175, since last addr message: 0.058026 addr/sec, peer 83.150.56.145
2021-07-07T09:22:13Z RATE LIMIT: received 17 addresses, tokens 13.6067, since last addr message: 0.180273 addr/sec, peer 168.119.79.89
2021-07-07T09:22:15Z RATE LIMIT: received 4 addresses, tokens 3.94619, since last addr message: 0.121173 addr/sec, peer 70.64.27.12
2021-07-07T09:22:17Z RATE LIMIT: received 2 addresses, tokens 19.6542, since last addr message: 0.093428 addr/sec, peer 99.108.237.173
2021-07-07T09:22:28Z RATE LIMIT: received 8 addresses, tokens 5.69023, since last addr message: 0.166491 addr/sec, peer bitcornrd36coazsbzsz4pdebyzvaplmsalq4kpoljmn6cg6x5zq.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:22:28Z RATE LIMIT: received 2 addresses, tokens 18.7796, since last addr message: 0.177723 addr/sec, peer 99.108.237.173
2021-07-07T09:22:30Z RATE LIMIT: received 5 addresses, tokens 40.8701, since last addr message: 0.097166 addr/sec, peer ppsmb5ln3rx6mfdzx2nwsleug5etsavbbzjkdealaybrh2jo2n6a.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:22:32Z RATE LIMIT: received 5 addresses, tokens 8.00999, since last addr message: 0.118372 addr/sec, peer kokkmpquqlkptu5hkmzqlttsmtwxicldr4so7wqsufk6bwf32nma.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:22:33Z RATE LIMIT: received 4 addresses, tokens 39.7383, since last addr message: 0.103922 addr/sec, peer q5csjdscadbsm27ceyuk7naxveak5yevqlnrowhgcnaxxauwc24zvhqd.onion
2021-07-07T09:22:38Z RATE LIMIT: received 3 addresses, tokens 21.595, since last addr message: 0.080003 addr/sec, peer 2a01:4f8:140:948b::2
2021-07-07T09:22:41Z RATE LIMIT: received 4 addresses, tokens 3.42258, since last addr message: 0.142050 addr/sec, peer 168.119.79.89
2021-07-07T09:22:41Z RATE LIMIT: received 6 addresses, tokens 11.7974, since last addr message: 0.163051 addr/sec, peer 83.150.56.145
2021-07-07T09:22:44Z RATE LIMIT: received 7 addresses, tokens 5.69418, since last addr message: 0.128402 addr/sec, peer i3hcdakiz2tyvggkwefvdjoi7444kgvd2mbdfizjvv43q7zukezq.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:22:49Z RATE LIMIT: received 3 addresses, tokens 2.77222, since last addr message: 0.144092 addr/sec, peer bitcornrd36coazsbzsz4pdebyzvaplmsalq4kpoljmn6cg6x5zq.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:22:50Z RATE LIMIT: received 2 addresses, tokens 1.28916, since last addr message: 0.336147 addr/sec, peer i3hcdakiz2tyvggkwefvdjoi7444kgvd2mbdfizjvv43q7zukezq.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:22:52Z RATE LIMIT: received 5 addresses, tokens 19.1385, since last addr message: 0.211963 addr/sec, peer 99.108.237.173
2021-07-07T09:22:53Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 4.04238, since last addr message: 0.032869 addr/sec, peer 3.236.255.16
2021-07-07T09:22:53Z RATE LIMIT: received 5 addresses, tokens 29.8344, since last addr message: 0.060808 addr/sec, peer 60.244.109.19
2021-07-07T09:22:55Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 14.3993, since last addr message: 0.383415 addr/sec, peer 99.108.237.173
2021-07-07T09:22:55Z RATE LIMIT: received 7 addresses, tokens 96.6163, since last addr message: 0.017953 addr/sec, peer 140.143.155.41
2021-07-07T09:22:56Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 38.4714, since last addr message: 0.038442 addr/sec, peer ppsmb5ln3rx6mfdzx2nwsleug5etsavbbzjkdealaybrh2jo2n6a.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:22:58Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 38.1765, since last addr message: 0.041014 addr/sec, peer q5csjdscadbsm27ceyuk7naxveak5yevqlnrowhgcnaxxauwc24zvhqd.onion
2021-07-07T09:23:10Z RATE LIMIT: received 2 addresses, tokens 26.4842, since last addr message: 0.121229 addr/sec, peer 60.244.109.19
2021-07-07T09:23:11Z RATE LIMIT: received 67 addresses, tokens 13.97, since last addr message: 0.928271 addr/sec, peer shh2ewyegnuwnmdse5kl5toybdvzkvk2yj4zcowz6iwhhh3ykdfa.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:23:26Z RATE LIMIT: received 8 addresses, tokens 91.8624, since last addr message: 0.027687 addr/sec, peer 94.237.44.67
2021-07-07T09:23:30Z RATE LIMIT: received 4 addresses, tokens 8.40881, since last addr message: 0.053601 addr/sec, peer 70.64.27.12
2021-07-07T09:24:14Z RATE LIMIT: received 11 addresses, tokens 8.88125, since last addr message: 0.245951 addr/sec, peer 70.64.27.12
2021-07-07T09:24:18Z RATE LIMIT: received 2 addresses, tokens 28.5825, since last addr message: 0.020025 addr/sec, peer 2a01:4f8:140:948b::2
2021-07-07T09:24:18Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 1.12454, since last addr message: 0.802931 addr/sec, peer 127.0.0.1
2021-07-07T09:24:31Z RATE LIMIT: received 2 addresses, tokens 14.9516, since last addr message: 0.016748 addr/sec, peer kokkmpquqlkptu5hkmzqlttsmtwxicldr4so7wqsufk6bwf32nma.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:24:31Z RATE LIMIT: received 4 addresses, tokens 32.6281, since last addr message: 0.049116 addr/sec, peer 60.244.109.19
2021-07-07T09:24:34Z RATE LIMIT: received 2 addresses, tokens 17.1213, since last addr message: 0.017662 addr/sec, peer 83.150.56.145
2021-07-07T09:24:49Z RATE LIMIT: received 4 addresses, tokens 10.795, since last addr message: 0.040712 addr/sec, peer shh2ewyegnuwnmdse5kl5toybdvzkvk2yj4zcowz6iwhhh3ykdfa.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:24:51Z RATE LIMIT: received 2 addresses, tokens 48.4897, since last addr message: 0.017679 addr/sec, peer q5csjdscadbsm27ceyuk7naxveak5yevqlnrowhgcnaxxauwc24zvhqd.onion
2021-07-07T09:24:54Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 55.7466, since last addr message: 0.005674 addr/sec, peer 35.197.140.219
2021-07-07T09:24:57Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 13.0575, since last addr message: 0.007832 addr/sec, peer i3hcdakiz2tyvggkwefvdjoi7444kgvd2mbdfizjvv43q7zukezq.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:25:03Z RATE LIMIT: received 2 addresses, tokens 50.1586, since last addr message: 0.015764 addr/sec, peer ppsmb5ln3rx6mfdzx2nwsleug5etsavbbzjkdealaybrh2jo2n6a.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:25:03Z RATE LIMIT: received 139 addresses, tokens 5.77002, since last addr message: 2.843251 addr/sec, peer 70.64.27.12
2021-07-07T09:25:05Z RATE LIMIT: received 2 addresses, tokens 14.8264, since last addr message: 0.013885 addr/sec, peer 168.119.79.89
2021-07-07T09:25:07Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 16.4715, since last addr message: 0.007447 addr/sec, peer 3.236.255.16
2021-07-07T09:25:12Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 15.0343, since last addr message: 0.007012 addr/sec, peer bitcornrd36coazsbzsz4pdebyzvaplmsalq4kpoljmn6cg6x5zq.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:25:24Z RATE LIMIT: received 2 addresses, tokens 14.7207, since last addr message: 0.105579 addr/sec, peer 168.119.79.89
2021-07-07T09:25:28Z RATE LIMIT: received 3 addresses, tokens 15.6521, since last addr message: 0.185433 addr/sec, peer bitcornrd36coazsbzsz4pdebyzvaplmsalq4kpoljmn6cg6x5zq.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:25:29Z RATE LIMIT: received 5 addresses, tokens 28.8106, since last addr message: 0.032444 addr/sec, peer 99.108.237.173
2021-07-07T09:25:32Z RATE LIMIT: received 7 addresses, tokens 89.8954, since last addr message: 0.007798 addr/sec, peer 188.166.69.73
2021-07-07T09:25:35Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 51.3696, since last addr message: 0.031143 addr/sec, peer ppsmb5ln3rx6mfdzx2nwsleug5etsavbbzjkdealaybrh2jo2n6a.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:25:39Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 21.6319, since last addr message: 0.015359 addr/sec, peer 83.150.56.145
2021-07-07T09:25:49Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 14.8163, since last addr message: 0.046206 addr/sec, peer bitcornrd36coazsbzsz4pdebyzvaplmsalq4kpoljmn6cg6x5zq.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:25:50Z RATE LIMIT: received 4 addresses, tokens 35.7147, since last addr message: 0.043801 addr/sec, peer 2a01:4f8:140:948b::2
2021-07-07T09:25:54Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 5.84196, since last addr message: 0.019716 addr/sec, peer 70.64.27.12
2021-07-07T09:25:56Z RATE LIMIT: received 2 addresses, tokens 15.9426, since last addr message: 0.062076 addr/sec, peer 168.119.79.89
2021-07-07T09:25:59Z RATE LIMIT: received 10 addresses, tokens 7.73151, since last addr message: 0.148555 addr/sec, peer 2a03:b0c0:2:d0::4bc:2001
2021-07-07T09:26:09Z RATE LIMIT: received 169 addresses, tokens 6.35832, since last addr message: 11.145061 addr/sec, peer 70.64.27.12
2021-07-07T09:26:27Z RATE LIMIT: received 2 addresses, tokens 13.0207, since last addr message: 0.015509 addr/sec, peer 127.0.0.1
2021-07-07T09:26:28Z RATE LIMIT: received 3 addresses, tokens 108.281, since last addr message: 0.002879 addr/sec, peer 88.99.167.186
2021-07-07T09:26:31Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 25.827, since last addr message: 0.019249 addr/sec, peer 83.150.56.145
2021-07-07T09:26:34Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 24.1384, since last addr message: 0.011538 addr/sec, peer 3.236.255.16
2021-07-07T09:26:37Z RATE LIMIT: received 4 addresses, tokens 41.2226, since last addr message: 0.031760 addr/sec, peer 60.244.109.19
2021-07-07T09:26:47Z RATE LIMIT: received 2 addresses, tokens 57.502, since last addr message: 0.028041 addr/sec, peer ppsmb5ln3rx6mfdzx2nwsleug5etsavbbzjkdealaybrh2jo2n6a.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:26:55Z RATE LIMIT: received 7 addresses, tokens 66.8491, since last addr message: 0.057839 addr/sec, peer 35.197.140.219
2021-07-07T09:27:00Z RATE LIMIT: received 2 addresses, tokens 27.7685, since last addr message: 0.067991 addr/sec, peer 83.150.56.145
2021-07-07T09:27:03Z RATE LIMIT: received 2 addresses, tokens 5.74193, since last addr message: 0.037150 addr/sec, peer 70.64.27.12
2021-07-07T09:27:05Z RATE LIMIT: received 4 addresses, tokens 33.3955, since last addr message: 0.041733 addr/sec, peer 99.108.237.173
2021-07-07T09:27:13Z RATE LIMIT: received 2 addresses, tokens 40.8211, since last addr message: 0.055579 addr/sec, peer 60.244.109.19
2021-07-07T09:27:15Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 15.81, since last addr message: 0.020880 addr/sec, peer 127.0.0.1
2021-07-07T09:27:22Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 31.1008, since last addr message: 0.058641 addr/sec, peer 99.108.237.173
2021-07-07T09:27:23Z RATE LIMIT: received 7 addresses, tokens 22.1772, since last addr message: 0.045507 addr/sec, peer shh2ewyegnuwnmdse5kl5toybdvzkvk2yj4zcowz6iwhhh3ykdfa.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:27:27Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 62.9918, since last addr message: 0.031820 addr/sec, peer 35.197.140.219
2021-07-07T09:27:30Z RATE LIMIT: received 4 addresses, tokens 30.8593, since last addr message: 0.022337 addr/sec, peer kokkmpquqlkptu5hkmzqlttsmtwxicldr4so7wqsufk6bwf32nma.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:27:33Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 6.79025, since last addr message: 0.032805 addr/sec, peer 70.64.27.12
2021-07-07T09:27:41Z RATE LIMIT: received 2 addresses, tokens 41.6232, since last addr message: 0.071376 addr/sec, peer 60.244.109.19
2021-07-07T09:27:42Z RATE LIMIT: received 3 addresses, tokens 17.0461, since last addr message: 0.160520 addr/sec, peer shh2ewyegnuwnmdse5kl5toybdvzkvk2yj4zcowz6iwhhh3ykdfa.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:27:46Z RATE LIMIT: received 8 addresses, tokens 24.9899, since last addr message: 0.072416 addr/sec, peer 168.119.79.89
2021-07-07T09:27:48Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 32.7755, since last addr message: 0.037387 addr/sec, peer 99.108.237.173
2021-07-07T09:27:51Z RATE LIMIT: received 7 addresses, tokens 30.8192, since last addr message: 0.138594 addr/sec, peer 83.150.56.145
2021-07-07T09:27:53Z RATE LIMIT: received 2 addresses, tokens 7.76158, since last addr message: 0.101455 addr/sec, peer 70.64.27.12
2021-07-07T09:27:54Z RATE LIMIT: received 10 addresses, tokens 29.7359, since last addr message: 0.056566 addr/sec, peer i3hcdakiz2tyvggkwefvdjoi7444kgvd2mbdfizjvv43q7zukezq.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:27:55Z RATE LIMIT: received 2 addresses, tokens 18.742, since last addr message: 0.050864 addr/sec, peer 127.0.0.1
2021-07-07T09:28:01Z RATE LIMIT: received 3 addresses, tokens 26.9711, since last addr message: 0.022805 addr/sec, peer bitcornrd36coazsbzsz4pdebyzvaplmsalq4kpoljmn6cg6x5zq.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:28:05Z RATE LIMIT: received 3 addresses, tokens 65.8521, since last addr message: 0.077714 addr/sec, peer 35.197.140.219
2021-07-07T09:28:13Z RATE LIMIT: received 10 addresses, tokens 112.573, since last addr message: 0.034830 addr/sec, peer 94.237.44.67
2021-07-07T09:28:14Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 63.6564, since last addr message: 0.124334 addr/sec, peer 35.197.140.219
2021-07-07T09:28:14Z RATE LIMIT: received 4 addresses, tokens 19.7099, since last addr message: 0.147059 addr/sec, peer 168.119.79.89
2021-07-07T09:28:20Z RATE LIMIT: received 5 addresses, tokens 67.3685, since last addr message: 0.023948 addr/sec, peer q5csjdscadbsm27ceyuk7naxveak5yevqlnrowhgcnaxxauwc24zvhqd.onion
2021-07-07T09:28:42Z RATE LIMIT: received 2 addresses, tokens 10.5981, since last addr message: 0.041352 addr/sec, peer 70.64.27.12
2021-07-07T09:28:43Z RATE LIMIT: received 2 addresses, tokens 37.2551, since last addr message: 0.036499 addr/sec, peer 99.108.237.173
2021-07-07T09:28:45Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 8.97894, since last addr message: 0.262600 addr/sec, peer 70.64.27.12
2021-07-07T09:28:46Z RATE LIMIT: received 2 addresses, tokens 21.842, since last addr message: 0.039216 addr/sec, peer 127.0.0.1
2021-07-07T09:28:46Z RATE LIMIT: received 5 addresses, tokens 34.4238, since last addr message: 0.066099 addr/sec, peer kokkmpquqlkptu5hkmzqlttsmtwxicldr4so7wqsufk6bwf32nma.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:28:47Z RATE LIMIT: received 2 addresses, tokens 20.0081, since last addr message: 1.203536 addr/sec, peer 127.0.0.1
2021-07-07T09:28:55Z RATE LIMIT: received 3 addresses, tokens 25.8147, since last addr message: 0.049352 addr/sec, peer i3hcdakiz2tyvggkwefvdjoi7444kgvd2mbdfizjvv43q7zukezq.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:28:55Z RATE LIMIT: received 5 addresses, tokens 30.2442, since last addr message: 0.077822 addr/sec, peer 83.150.56.145
2021-07-07T09:29:04Z RATE LIMIT: received 4 addresses, tokens 69.2401, since last addr message: 0.029116 addr/sec, peer ppsmb5ln3rx6mfdzx2nwsleug5etsavbbzjkdealaybrh2jo2n6a.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:29:04Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 19.7004, since last addr message: 0.059092 addr/sec, peer 127.0.0.1
2021-07-07T09:29:05Z RATE LIMIT: received 11 addresses, tokens 30.3621, since last addr message: 0.172116 addr/sec, peer bitcornrd36coazsbzsz4pdebyzvaplmsalq4kpoljmn6cg6x5zq.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:29:12Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 66.0485, since last addr message: 0.123702 addr/sec, peer ppsmb5ln3rx6mfdzx2nwsleug5etsavbbzjkdealaybrh2jo2n6a.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:29:12Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 38.1886, since last addr message: 0.034089 addr/sec, peer 99.108.237.173
2021-07-07T09:29:16Z RATE LIMIT: received 4 addresses, tokens 27.2911, since last addr message: 0.195411 addr/sec, peer 83.150.56.145
2021-07-07T09:29:16Z RATE LIMIT: received 10 addresses, tokens 127.77, since last addr message: 0.026210 addr/sec, peer 140.143.155.41
2021-07-07T09:29:17Z RATE LIMIT: received 15 addresses, tokens 52.4344, since last addr message: 0.072395 addr/sec, peer 2a01:4f8:140:948b::2
2021-07-07T09:29:22Z RATE LIMIT: received 3 addresses, tokens 49.6783, since last addr message: 0.029835 addr/sec, peer 60.244.109.19
2021-07-07T09:29:24Z RATE LIMIT: received 2 addresses, tokens 21.2732, since last addr message: 0.104653 addr/sec, peer bitcornrd36coazsbzsz4pdebyzvaplmsalq4kpoljmn6cg6x5zq.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:29:25Z RATE LIMIT: received 8 addresses, tokens 22.8582, since last addr message: 0.111915 addr/sec, peer 168.119.79.89
2021-07-07T09:29:30Z RATE LIMIT: received 7 addresses, tokens 33.8481, since last addr message: 0.158218 addr/sec, peer kokkmpquqlkptu5hkmzqlttsmtwxicldr4so7wqsufk6bwf32nma.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:29:31Z RATE LIMIT: received 11 addresses, tokens 24.9301, since last addr message: 0.101066 addr/sec, peer shh2ewyegnuwnmdse5kl5toybdvzkvk2yj4zcowz6iwhhh3ykdfa.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:29:36Z RATE LIMIT: received 4 addresses, tokens 39.5649, since last addr message: 0.168328 addr/sec, peer 99.108.237.173
2021-07-07T09:29:37Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 20.5993, since last addr message: 0.075412 addr/sec, peer bitcornrd36coazsbzsz4pdebyzvaplmsalq4kpoljmn6cg6x5zq.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:29:38Z RATE LIMIT: received 3 addresses, tokens 22.0442, since last addr message: 0.089719 addr/sec, peer 127.0.0.1
2021-07-07T09:29:38Z RATE LIMIT: received 4 addresses, tokens 71.0752, since last addr message: 0.047512 addr/sec, peer 35.197.140.219
2021-07-07T09:29:39Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 19.1469, since last addr message: 0.973562 addr/sec, peer 127.0.0.1
2021-07-07T09:29:45Z RATE LIMIT: received 10 addresses, tokens 27.8786, since last addr message: 0.197475 addr/sec, peer i3hcdakiz2tyvggkwefvdjoi7444kgvd2mbdfizjvv43q7zukezq.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:29:46Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 20.4307, since last addr message: 0.120277 addr/sec, peer bitcornrd36coazsbzsz4pdebyzvaplmsalq4kpoljmn6cg6x5zq.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:29:53Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 19.5322, since last addr message: 0.072186 addr/sec, peer 127.0.0.1
2021-07-07T09:30:00Z RATE LIMIT: received 2 addresses, tokens 18.3813, since last addr message: 0.056769 addr/sec, peer 168.119.79.89
2021-07-07T09:30:08Z RATE LIMIT: received 6 addresses, tokens 21.6649, since last addr message: 0.268554 addr/sec, peer bitcornrd36coazsbzsz4pdebyzvaplmsalq4kpoljmn6cg6x5zq.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:30:09Z RATE LIMIT: received 3 addresses, tokens 28.6407, since last addr message: 0.056079 addr/sec, peer 83.150.56.145
2021-07-07T09:30:14Z RATE LIMIT: received 7 addresses, tokens 31.2775, since last addr message: 0.158035 addr/sec, peer kokkmpquqlkptu5hkmzqlttsmtwxicldr4so7wqsufk6bwf32nma.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:30:15Z RATE LIMIT: received 4 addresses, tokens 20.8598, since last addr message: 0.134174 addr/sec, peer i3hcdakiz2tyvggkwefvdjoi7444kgvd2mbdfizjvv43q7zukezq.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:30:19Z RATE LIMIT: received 2 addresses, tokens 71.1889, since last addr message: 0.048618 addr/sec, peer 35.197.140.219
2021-07-07T09:30:22Z RATE LIMIT: received 14 addresses, tokens 17.6941, since last addr message: 0.144104 addr/sec, peer 70.64.27.12
2021-07-07T09:30:29Z RATE LIMIT: received 2 addresses, tokens 27.662, since last addr message: 0.098947 addr/sec, peer 83.150.56.145
2021-07-07T09:30:30Z RATE LIMIT: received 7 addresses, tokens 19.8997, since last addr message: 0.117261 addr/sec, peer shh2ewyegnuwnmdse5kl5toybdvzkvk2yj4zcowz6iwhhh3ykdfa.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:30:31Z RATE LIMIT: received 7 addresses, tokens 41.0844, since last addr message: 0.126824 addr/sec, peer 99.108.237.173
2021-07-07T09:30:39Z RATE LIMIT: received 6 addresses, tokens 73.6987, since last addr message: 0.069362 addr/sec, peer ppsmb5ln3rx6mfdzx2nwsleug5etsavbbzjkdealaybrh2jo2n6a.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:30:39Z RATE LIMIT: received 2 addresses, tokens 54.366, since last addr message: 0.026016 addr/sec, peer 60.244.109.19
2021-07-07T09:30:39Z RATE LIMIT: received 7 addresses, tokens 45.6739, since last addr message: 0.084957 addr/sec, peer 2a01:4f8:140:948b::2
2021-07-07T09:30:39Z RATE LIMIT: received 2 addresses, tokens 26.6596, since last addr message: 0.200475 addr/sec, peer 83.150.56.145
2021-07-07T09:30:41Z RATE LIMIT: received 4 addresses, tokens 23.331, since last addr message: 0.083353 addr/sec, peer 127.0.0.1
2021-07-07T09:30:48Z RATE LIMIT: received 3 addresses, tokens 21.1905, since last addr message: 0.062381 addr/sec, peer 168.119.79.89
2021-07-07T09:30:52Z RATE LIMIT: received 2 addresses, tokens 6.60666, since last addr message: 0.068669 addr/sec, peer 70.64.27.12
2021-07-07T09:30:53Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 26.0741, since last addr message: 0.070698 addr/sec, peer 83.150.56.145
2021-07-07T09:30:57Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 20.9865, since last addr message: 0.060407 addr/sec, peer 127.0.0.1
2021-07-07T09:30:57Z RATE LIMIT: received 2 addresses, tokens 19.064, since last addr message: 0.228958 addr/sec, peer 168.119.79.89
2021-07-07T09:31:03Z RATE LIMIT: received 2 addresses, tokens 73.5559, since last addr message: 0.045798 addr/sec, peer 35.197.140.219
2021-07-07T09:31:04Z RATE LIMIT: received 9 addresses, tokens 78.864, since last addr message: 0.054560 addr/sec, peer q5csjdscadbsm27ceyuk7naxveak5yevqlnrowhgcnaxxauwc24zvhqd.onion
2021-07-07T09:31:05Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 17.8422, since last addr message: 0.128491 addr/sec, peer 168.119.79.89
2021-07-07T09:31:08Z RATE LIMIT: received 2 addresses, tokens 16.6413, since last addr message: 0.053454 addr/sec, peer shh2ewyegnuwnmdse5kl5toybdvzkvk2yj4zcowz6iwhhh3ykdfa.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:31:08Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 41.573, since last addr message: 0.034493 addr/sec, peer 2a01:4f8:140:948b::2
2021-07-07T09:31:14Z RATE LIMIT: received 5 addresses, tokens 22.6933, since last addr message: 0.085712 addr/sec, peer i3hcdakiz2tyvggkwefvdjoi7444kgvd2mbdfizjvv43q7zukezq.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:31:18Z RATE LIMIT: received 11 addresses, tokens 22.6464, since last addr message: 0.157558 addr/sec, peer bitcornrd36coazsbzsz4pdebyzvaplmsalq4kpoljmn6cg6x5zq.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:31:18Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 71.2122, since last addr message: 0.074171 addr/sec, peer q5csjdscadbsm27ceyuk7naxveak5yevqlnrowhgcnaxxauwc24zvhqd.onion
2021-07-07T09:31:24Z RATE LIMIT: received 5 addresses, tokens 39.2992, since last addr message: 0.095880 addr/sec, peer 99.108.237.173
2021-07-07T09:31:25Z RATE LIMIT: received 81 addresses, tokens 28.2396, since last addr message: 2.558828 addr/sec, peer 83.150.56.145
2021-07-07T09:31:26Z RATE LIMIT: received 2 addresses, tokens 8.05444, since last addr message: 0.058008 addr/sec, peer 70.64.27.12
2021-07-07T09:31:27Z RATE LIMIT: received 2 addresses, tokens 22.9725, since last addr message: 0.066978 addr/sec, peer 127.0.0.1
2021-07-07T09:31:29Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 16.7921, since last addr message: 0.046493 addr/sec, peer shh2ewyegnuwnmdse5kl5toybdvzkvk2yj4zcowz6iwhhh3ykdfa.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:31:32Z RATE LIMIT: received 9 addresses, tokens 32.0212, since last addr message: 0.116223 addr/sec, peer kokkmpquqlkptu5hkmzqlttsmtwxicldr4so7wqsufk6bwf32nma.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:31:33Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 71.7163, since last addr message: 0.066484 addr/sec, peer q5csjdscadbsm27ceyuk7naxveak5yevqlnrowhgcnaxxauwc24zvhqd.onion
2021-07-07T09:31:33Z RATE LIMIT: received 3 addresses, tokens 73.1855, since last addr message: 0.054677 addr/sec, peer ppsmb5ln3rx6mfdzx2nwsleug5etsavbbzjkdealaybrh2jo2n6a.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:31:37Z RATE LIMIT: received 3 addresses, tokens 20.0313, since last addr message: 0.094072 addr/sec, peer 168.119.79.89
2021-07-07T09:31:43Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 36.1974, since last addr message: 0.052682 addr/sec, peer 99.108.237.173
2021-07-07T09:31:46Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 17.4726, since last addr message: 0.059506 addr/sec, peer shh2ewyegnuwnmdse5kl5toybdvzkvk2yj4zcowz6iwhhh3ykdfa.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:31:47Z RATE LIMIT: received 2 addresses, tokens 24.4996, since last addr message: 0.135285 addr/sec, peer kokkmpquqlkptu5hkmzqlttsmtwxicldr4so7wqsufk6bwf32nma.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:31:51Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 23.3658, since last addr message: 0.041785 addr/sec, peer 127.0.0.1
2021-07-07T09:31:51Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 44.8552, since last addr message: 0.023353 addr/sec, peer 2a01:4f8:140:948b::2
2021-07-07T09:31:53Z RATE LIMIT: received 4 addresses, tokens 8.78532, since last addr message: 0.146473 addr/sec, peer 70.64.27.12
2021-07-07T09:32:01Z RATE LIMIT: received 6 addresses, tokens 15.9341, since last addr message: 0.139936 addr/sec, peer bitcornrd36coazsbzsz4pdebyzvaplmsalq4kpoljmn6cg6x5zq.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:32:02Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 3.95673, since last addr message: 0.026902 addr/sec, peer 83.150.56.145
2021-07-07T09:32:15Z RATE LIMIT: received 2 addresses, tokens 74.9639, since last addr message: 0.047085 addr/sec, peer q5csjdscadbsm27ceyuk7naxveak5yevqlnrowhgcnaxxauwc24zvhqd.onion
2021-07-07T09:32:16Z RATE LIMIT: received 3 addresses, tokens 20.9848, since last addr message: 0.075882 addr/sec, peer 168.119.79.89
2021-07-07T09:32:17Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 74.5224, since last addr message: 0.023057 addr/sec, peer ppsmb5ln3rx6mfdzx2nwsleug5etsavbbzjkdealaybrh2jo2n6a.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:32:19Z RATE LIMIT: received 6 addresses, tokens 19.7569, since last addr message: 0.182688 addr/sec, peer shh2ewyegnuwnmdse5kl5toybdvzkvk2yj4zcowz6iwhhh3ykdfa.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:32:19Z RATE LIMIT: received 4 addresses, tokens 11.7915, since last addr message: 0.215358 addr/sec, peer bitcornrd36coazsbzsz4pdebyzvaplmsalq4kpoljmn6cg6x5zq.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:32:21Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 4.87072, since last addr message: 0.052247 addr/sec, peer 83.150.56.145
2021-07-07T09:32:26Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 74.4344, since last addr message: 0.109659 addr/sec, peer ppsmb5ln3rx6mfdzx2nwsleug5etsavbbzjkdealaybrh2jo2n6a.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:32:30Z RATE LIMIT: received 6 addresses, tokens 80.3127, since last addr message: 0.068518 addr/sec, peer 35.197.140.219
2021-07-07T09:32:35Z RATE LIMIT: received 6 addresses, tokens 25.8138, since last addr message: 0.073887 addr/sec, peer i3hcdakiz2tyvggkwefvdjoi7444kgvd2mbdfizjvv43q7zukezq.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:32:35Z RATE LIMIT: received 4 addresses, tokens 19.8732, since last addr message: 0.211816 addr/sec, peer 168.119.79.89
2021-07-07T09:32:37Z RATE LIMIT: received 5 addresses, tokens 9.1063, since last addr message: 0.115714 addr/sec, peer 70.64.27.12
2021-07-07T09:32:39Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 16.267, since last addr message: 0.253979 addr/sec, peer 168.119.79.89
2021-07-07T09:32:41Z RATE LIMIT: received 3 addresses, tokens 48.8933, since last addr message: 0.059546 addr/sec, peer 2a01:4f8:140:948b::2
2021-07-07T09:32:42Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 75.0179, since last addr message: 0.063151 addr/sec, peer ppsmb5ln3rx6mfdzx2nwsleug5etsavbbzjkdealaybrh2jo2n6a.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:32:46Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 46.3505, since last addr message: 0.218705 addr/sec, peer 2a01:4f8:140:948b::2
2021-07-07T09:32:49Z RATE LIMIT: received 5 addresses, tokens 28.7318, since last addr message: 0.080228 addr/sec, peer kokkmpquqlkptu5hkmzqlttsmtwxicldr4so7wqsufk6bwf32nma.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:32:49Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 74.7787, since last addr message: 0.131431 addr/sec, peer ppsmb5ln3rx6mfdzx2nwsleug5etsavbbzjkdealaybrh2jo2n6a.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:32:49Z RATE LIMIT: received 3 addresses, tokens 6.67285, since last addr message: 0.107062 addr/sec, peer 83.150.56.145
2021-07-07T09:32:54Z RATE LIMIT: received 7 addresses, tokens 42.3425, since last addr message: 0.097968 addr/sec, peer 99.108.237.173
2021-07-07T09:32:58Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 17.1481, since last addr message: 0.053158 addr/sec, peer 168.119.79.89
2021-07-07T09:32:59Z RATE LIMIT: received 8 addresses, tokens 29.1874, since last addr message: 0.117275 addr/sec, peer 127.0.0.1
2021-07-07T09:32:59Z RATE LIMIT: received 3 addresses, tokens 46.6947, since last addr message: 0.223185 addr/sec, peer 2a01:4f8:140:948b::2
2021-07-07T09:33:02Z RATE LIMIT: received 9 addresses, tokens 131.469, since last addr message: 0.031146 addr/sec, peer 94.237.44.67
2021-07-07T09:33:06Z RATE LIMIT: received 2 addresses, tokens 5.28086, since last addr message: 0.124377 addr/sec, peer 83.150.56.145
2021-07-07T09:33:09Z RATE LIMIT: received 6 addresses, tokens 18.7308, since last addr message: 0.120630 addr/sec, peer shh2ewyegnuwnmdse5kl5toybdvzkvk2yj4zcowz6iwhhh3ykdfa.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:33:21Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 13.9776, since last addr message: 0.080209 addr/sec, peer shh2ewyegnuwnmdse5kl5toybdvzkvk2yj4zcowz6iwhhh3ykdfa.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:33:22Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 27.023, since last addr message: 0.030384 addr/sec, peer kokkmpquqlkptu5hkmzqlttsmtwxicldr4so7wqsufk6bwf32nma.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:33:23Z RATE LIMIT: received 9 addresses, tokens 14.1404, since last addr message: 0.141758 addr/sec, peer bitcornrd36coazsbzsz4pdebyzvaplmsalq4kpoljmn6cg6x5zq.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:33:28Z RATE LIMIT: received 2 addresses, tokens 77.599, since last addr message: 0.052352 addr/sec, peer ppsmb5ln3rx6mfdzx2nwsleug5etsavbbzjkdealaybrh2jo2n6a.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:33:28Z RATE LIMIT: received 5 addresses, tokens 19.1636, since last addr message: 0.165813 addr/sec, peer 168.119.79.89
2021-07-07T09:33:29Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 13.7815, since last addr message: 0.124381 addr/sec, peer shh2ewyegnuwnmdse5kl5toybdvzkvk2yj4zcowz6iwhhh3ykdfa.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:33:34Z RATE LIMIT: received 3 addresses, tokens 47.1297, since last addr message: 0.087336 addr/sec, peer 2a01:4f8:140:948b::2
2021-07-07T09:33:35Z RATE LIMIT: received 2 addresses, tokens 6.34495, since last addr message: 0.166030 addr/sec, peer bitcornrd36coazsbzsz4pdebyzvaplmsalq4kpoljmn6cg6x5zq.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:33:39Z RATE LIMIT: received 8 addresses, tokens 10.347, since last addr message: 0.128192 addr/sec, peer 70.64.27.12
2021-07-07T09:33:39Z RATE LIMIT: received 5 addresses, tokens 81.3454, since last addr message: 0.059655 addr/sec, peer q5csjdscadbsm27ceyuk7naxveak5yevqlnrowhgcnaxxauwc24zvhqd.onion
2021-07-07T09:33:47Z RATE LIMIT: received 4 addresses, tokens 7.41258, since last addr message: 0.096812 addr/sec, peer 83.150.56.145
2021-07-07T09:33:47Z RATE LIMIT: received 4 addresses, tokens 40.6426, since last addr message: 0.075471 addr/sec, peer 99.108.237.173
2021-07-07T09:33:52Z RATE LIMIT: received 7 addresses, tokens 82.4911, since last addr message: 0.085591 addr/sec, peer 35.197.140.219
2021-07-07T09:33:58Z RATE LIMIT: received 2 addresses, tokens 67.6079, since last addr message: 0.004497 addr/sec, peer 3.236.255.16
2021-07-07T09:34:02Z RATE LIMIT: received 4 addresses, tokens 28.542, since last addr message: 0.045828 addr/sec, peer i3hcdakiz2tyvggkwefvdjoi7444kgvd2mbdfizjvv43q7zukezq.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:34:03Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 47.0135, since last addr message: 0.034677 addr/sec, peer 2a01:4f8:140:948b::2
2021-07-07T09:34:05Z RATE LIMIT: received 5 addresses, tokens 79.2993, since last addr message: 0.135124 addr/sec, peer ppsmb5ln3rx6mfdzx2nwsleug5etsavbbzjkdealaybrh2jo2n6a.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:34:07Z RATE LIMIT: received 2 addresses, tokens 79.1146, since last addr message: 0.072224 addr/sec, peer q5csjdscadbsm27ceyuk7naxveak5yevqlnrowhgcnaxxauwc24zvhqd.onion
2021-07-07T09:34:08Z RATE LIMIT: received 4 addresses, tokens 30.6025, since last addr message: 0.087346 addr/sec, peer kokkmpquqlkptu5hkmzqlttsmtwxicldr4so7wqsufk6bwf32nma.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:34:08Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 38.7138, since last addr message: 0.048280 addr/sec, peer 99.108.237.173
2021-07-07T09:34:08Z RATE LIMIT: received 8 addresses, tokens 18.1791, since last addr message: 0.199228 addr/sec, peer 168.119.79.89
2021-07-07T09:34:14Z RATE LIMIT: received 2 addresses, tokens 8.26433, since last addr message: 0.051028 addr/sec, peer bitcornrd36coazsbzsz4pdebyzvaplmsalq4kpoljmn6cg6x5zq.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:34:16Z RATE LIMIT: received 2 addresses, tokens 78.0296, since last addr message: 0.218570 addr/sec, peer q5csjdscadbsm27ceyuk7naxveak5yevqlnrowhgcnaxxauwc24zvhqd.onion
2021-07-07T09:34:21Z RATE LIMIT: received 7 addresses, tokens 17.9077, since last addr message: 0.136554 addr/sec, peer shh2ewyegnuwnmdse5kl5toybdvzkvk2yj4zcowz6iwhhh3ykdfa.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:34:24Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 76.829, since last addr message: 0.125097 addr/sec, peer q5csjdscadbsm27ceyuk7naxveak5yevqlnrowhgcnaxxauwc24zvhqd.onion
2021-07-07T09:34:31Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 28.9857, since last addr message: 0.041960 addr/sec, peer kokkmpquqlkptu5hkmzqlttsmtwxicldr4so7wqsufk6bwf32nma.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:34:35Z RATE LIMIT: received 5 addresses, tokens 8.21945, since last addr message: 0.104018 addr/sec, peer 83.150.56.145
2021-07-07T09:34:35Z RATE LIMIT: received 3 addresses, tokens 49.2939, since last addr message: 0.091453 addr/sec, peer 2a01:4f8:140:948b::2
2021-07-07T09:34:43Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 1.01468, since last addr message: 6.813521 addr/sec, peer 46.101.235.143
2021-07-07T09:34:44Z RATE LIMIT: received 2 addresses, tokens 28.6852, since last addr message: 0.048273 addr/sec, peer i3hcdakiz2tyvggkwefvdjoi7444kgvd2mbdfizjvv43q7zukezq.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:34:44Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 70.154, since last addr message: 0.021997 addr/sec, peer 3.236.255.16
2021-07-07T09:34:45Z RATE LIMIT: received 11 addresses, tokens 76.9947, since last addr message: 0.044663 addr/sec, peer 60.244.109.19
2021-07-07T09:34:45Z RATE LIMIT: received 2 addresses, tokens 78.3444, since last addr message: 0.049443 addr/sec, peer ppsmb5ln3rx6mfdzx2nwsleug5etsavbbzjkdealaybrh2jo2n6a.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:34:45Z RATE LIMIT: received 3 addresses, tokens 9.41524, since last addr message: 0.095211 addr/sec, peer bitcornrd36coazsbzsz4pdebyzvaplmsalq4kpoljmn6cg6x5zq.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:34:47Z RATE LIMIT: received 3 addresses, tokens 13.5318, since last addr message: 0.114324 addr/sec, peer shh2ewyegnuwnmdse5kl5toybdvzkvk2yj4zcowz6iwhhh3ykdfa.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:34:47Z RATE LIMIT: received 166 addresses, tokens 9.13735, since last addr message: 2.444632 addr/sec, peer 70.64.27.12
2021-07-07T09:34:48Z RATE LIMIT: received 4 addresses, tokens 78.2268, since last addr message: 0.166820 addr/sec, peer q5csjdscadbsm27ceyuk7naxveak5yevqlnrowhgcnaxxauwc24zvhqd.onion
2021-07-07T09:34:48Z RATE LIMIT: received 15 addresses, tokens 32.1046, since last addr message: 0.137398 addr/sec, peer 127.0.0.1
2021-07-07T09:34:55Z RATE LIMIT: received 4 addresses, tokens 48.2641, since last addr message: 0.203019 addr/sec, peer 2a01:4f8:140:948b::2
2021-07-07T09:34:55Z RATE LIMIT: received 5 addresses, tokens 81.8274, since last addr message: 0.078910 addr/sec, peer 35.197.140.219
2021-07-07T09:35:01Z RATE LIMIT: received 8 addresses, tokens 152.246, since last addr message: 0.023204 addr/sec, peer 140.143.155.41
2021-07-07T09:35:01Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 7.99851, since last addr message: 0.063160 addr/sec, peer bitcornrd36coazsbzsz4pdebyzvaplmsalq4kpoljmn6cg6x5zq.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:35:08Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 31.6315, since last addr message: 0.027429 addr/sec, peer kokkmpquqlkptu5hkmzqlttsmtwxicldr4so7wqsufk6bwf32nma.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:35:10Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 78.2754, since last addr message: 0.069060 addr/sec, peer 35.197.140.219
2021-07-07T09:35:11Z RATE LIMIT: received 6 addresses, tokens 16.4986, since last addr message: 0.094944 addr/sec, peer 168.119.79.89
2021-07-07T09:35:13Z RATE LIMIT: received 12 addresses, tokens 7.06091, since last addr message: 0.312381 addr/sec, peer 83.150.56.145
2021-07-07T09:35:15Z RATE LIMIT: received 3 addresses, tokens 79.3107, since last addr message: 0.101138 addr/sec, peer ppsmb5ln3rx6mfdzx2nwsleug5etsavbbzjkdealaybrh2jo2n6a.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:35:17Z RATE LIMIT: received 2 addresses, tokens 30.0216, since last addr message: 0.059944 addr/sec, peer i3hcdakiz2tyvggkwefvdjoi7444kgvd2mbdfizjvv43q7zukezq.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:35:21Z RATE LIMIT: received 2 addresses, tokens 78.421, since last addr message: 0.174589 addr/sec, peer 35.197.140.219
2021-07-07T09:35:21Z RATE LIMIT: received 4 addresses, tokens 45.0891, since last addr message: 0.054235 addr/sec, peer 99.108.237.173
2021-07-07T09:35:22Z RATE LIMIT: received 5 addresses, tokens 3.66563, since last addr message: 0.141712 addr/sec, peer 70.64.27.12
2021-07-07T09:35:23Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 41.2917, since last addr message: 0.493515 addr/sec, peer 99.108.237.173
2021-07-07T09:35:25Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 47.2442, since last addr message: 0.033557 addr/sec, peer 2a01:4f8:140:948b::2
2021-07-07T09:35:25Z RATE LIMIT: received 29 addresses, tokens 1.24595, since last addr message: 2.447167 addr/sec, peer 83.150.56.145
2021-07-07T09:35:27Z RATE LIMIT: received 2 addresses, tokens 12.0333, since last addr message: 0.130321 addr/sec, peer 168.119.79.89
2021-07-07T09:35:30Z RATE LIMIT: received 2 addresses, tokens 0.738324, since last addr message: 0.406198 addr/sec, peer 83.150.56.145
2021-07-07T09:35:30Z RATE LIMIT: received 2 addresses, tokens 77.8555, since last addr message: 0.129461 addr/sec, peer ppsmb5ln3rx6mfdzx2nwsleug5etsavbbzjkdealaybrh2jo2n6a.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:35:31Z RATE LIMIT: received 2 addresses, tokens 9.93625, since last addr message: 0.068080 addr/sec, peer bitcornrd36coazsbzsz4pdebyzvaplmsalq4kpoljmn6cg6x5zq.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:35:31Z RATE LIMIT: received 2 addresses, tokens 77.3954, since last addr message: 0.205255 addr/sec, peer 35.197.140.219
2021-07-07T09:35:34Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 70.9405, since last addr message: 0.020219 addr/sec, peer 60.244.109.19
2021-07-07T09:35:36Z RATE LIMIT: received 4 addresses, tokens 21.8702, since last addr message: 0.083934 addr/sec, peer 127.0.0.1
2021-07-07T09:35:42Z RATE LIMIT: received 3 addresses, tokens 30.521, since last addr message: 0.120032 addr/sec, peer i3hcdakiz2tyvggkwefvdjoi7444kgvd2mbdfizjvv43q7zukezq.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:35:46Z RATE LIMIT: received 3 addresses, tokens 48.3494, since last addr message: 0.142499 addr/sec, peer 2a01:4f8:140:948b::2
2021-07-07T09:35:50Z RATE LIMIT: received 4 addresses, tokens 80.4118, since last addr message: 0.064672 addr/sec, peer q5csjdscadbsm27ceyuk7naxveak5yevqlnrowhgcnaxxauwc24zvhqd.onion
2021-07-07T09:35:55Z RATE LIMIT: received 2 addresses, tokens 28.7855, since last addr message: 0.158164 addr/sec, peer i3hcdakiz2tyvggkwefvdjoi7444kgvd2mbdfizjvv43q7zukezq.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:35:56Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 72.1071, since last addr message: 0.046156 addr/sec, peer 60.244.109.19
2021-07-07T09:35:57Z RATE LIMIT: received 6 addresses, tokens 13.0157, since last addr message: 0.201181 addr/sec, peer 168.119.79.89
2021-07-07T09:36:01Z RATE LIMIT: received 2 addresses, tokens 77.4711, since last addr message: 0.188820 addr/sec, peer q5csjdscadbsm27ceyuk7naxveak5yevqlnrowhgcnaxxauwc24zvhqd.onion
2021-07-07T09:36:08Z RATE LIMIT: received 3 addresses, tokens 4.49408, since last addr message: 0.079877 addr/sec, peer 83.150.56.145
2021-07-07T09:36:11Z RATE LIMIT: received 4 addresses, tokens 5.58052, since last addr message: 0.081385 addr/sec, peer 70.64.27.12
2021-07-07T09:36:14Z RATE LIMIT: received 6 addresses, tokens 12.2396, since last addr message: 0.139425 addr/sec, peer bitcornrd36coazsbzsz4pdebyzvaplmsalq4kpoljmn6cg6x5zq.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:36:18Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 78.5741, since last addr message: 0.010616 addr/sec, peer 3.236.255.16
2021-07-07T09:36:19Z RATE LIMIT: received 3 addresses, tokens 48.6127, since last addr message: 0.091933 addr/sec, peer 2a01:4f8:140:948b::2
2021-07-07T09:36:21Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 9.46512, since last addr message: 0.040826 addr/sec, peer 168.119.79.89
2021-07-07T09:36:23Z RATE LIMIT: received 9 addresses, tokens 20.1561, since last addr message: 0.093514 addr/sec, peer shh2ewyegnuwnmdse5kl5toybdvzkvk2yj4zcowz6iwhhh3ykdfa.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:36:28Z RATE LIMIT: received 2 addresses, tokens 81.6888, since last addr message: 0.034286 addr/sec, peer ppsmb5ln3rx6mfdzx2nwsleug5etsavbbzjkdealaybrh2jo2n6a.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:36:30Z RATE LIMIT: received 2 addresses, tokens 9.3169, since last addr message: 0.234801 addr/sec, peer 168.119.79.89
2021-07-07T09:36:32Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 74.6905, since last addr message: 0.027906 addr/sec, peer 60.244.109.19
2021-07-07T09:36:34Z RATE LIMIT: received 2 addresses, tokens 47.1096, since last addr message: 0.133611 addr/sec, peer 2a01:4f8:140:948b::2
2021-07-07T09:36:36Z RATE LIMIT: received 5 addresses, tokens 47.5107, since last addr message: 0.069262 addr/sec, peer 99.108.237.173
2021-07-07T09:36:48Z RATE LIMIT: received 5 addresses, tokens 9.69295, since last addr message: 0.144789 addr/sec, peer bitcornrd36coazsbzsz4pdebyzvaplmsalq4kpoljmn6cg6x5zq.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:36:49Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 32.2199, since last addr message: 0.018401 addr/sec, peer i3hcdakiz2tyvggkwefvdjoi7444kgvd2mbdfizjvv43q7zukezq.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:36:55Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 5.36315, since last addr message: 0.149209 addr/sec, peer bitcornrd36coazsbzsz4pdebyzvaplmsalq4kpoljmn6cg6x5zq.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:36:55Z RATE LIMIT: received 2 addresses, tokens 25.8086, since last addr message: 0.025194 addr/sec, peer 127.0.0.1
2021-07-07T09:36:56Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 31.9382, since last addr message: 0.139211 addr/sec, peer i3hcdakiz2tyvggkwefvdjoi7444kgvd2mbdfizjvv43q7zukezq.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:36:59Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 81.6314, since last addr message: 0.024647 addr/sec, peer 3.236.255.16
2021-07-07T09:37:03Z RATE LIMIT: received 6 addresses, tokens 81.7179, since last addr message: 0.096048 addr/sec, peer q5csjdscadbsm27ceyuk7naxveak5yevqlnrowhgcnaxxauwc24zvhqd.onion
2021-07-07T09:37:21Z RATE LIMIT: received 20 addresses, tokens 8.7848, since last addr message: 0.274321 addr/sec, peer 83.150.56.145
2021-07-07T09:37:22Z RATE LIMIT: received 9 addresses, tokens 47.1074, since last addr message: 0.195796 addr/sec, peer 99.108.237.173
2021-07-07T09:37:24Z RATE LIMIT: received 45 addresses, tokens 1.10409, since last addr message: 14.093766 addr/sec, peer 83.150.56.145
2021-07-07T09:37:30Z RATE LIMIT: received 3 addresses, tokens 27.231, since last addr message: 0.087656 addr/sec, peer 127.0.0.1
2021-07-07T09:37:32Z RATE LIMIT: received 147 addresses, tokens 18.0625, since last addr message: 2.128447 addr/sec, peer shh2ewyegnuwnmdse5kl5toybdvzkvk2yj4zcowz6iwhhh3ykdfa.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:37:40Z RATE LIMIT: received 12 addresses, tokens 88.2762, since last addr message: 0.093162 addr/sec, peer 35.197.140.219
2021-07-07T09:37:46Z RATE LIMIT: received 3 addresses, tokens 9.43458, since last addr message: 0.059155 addr/sec, peer bitcornrd36coazsbzsz4pdebyzvaplmsalq4kpoljmn6cg6x5zq.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:37:49Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 40.8886, since last addr message: 0.035954 addr/sec, peer 99.108.237.173
2021-07-07T09:38:04Z RATE LIMIT: received 18 addresses, tokens 48.2704, since last addr message: 0.102047 addr/sec, peer kokkmpquqlkptu5hkmzqlttsmtwxicldr4so7wqsufk6bwf32nma.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:38:06Z RATE LIMIT: received 9 addresses, tokens 8.19879, since last addr message: 0.125021 addr/sec, peer 94.237.44.67
2021-07-07T09:38:11Z RATE LIMIT: received 101 addresses, tokens 89.9936, since last addr message: 0.980125 addr/sec, peer ppsmb5ln3rx6mfdzx2nwsleug5etsavbbzjkdealaybrh2jo2n6a.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:38:12Z RATE LIMIT: received 9 addresses, tokens 83.6881, since last addr message: 0.090022 addr/sec, peer 60.244.109.19
2021-07-07T09:38:14Z RATE LIMIT: received 2 addresses, tokens 5.11676, since last addr message: 0.039899 addr/sec, peer 83.150.56.145
2021-07-07T09:38:18Z RATE LIMIT: received 5 addresses, tokens 9.68561, since last addr message: 0.153798 addr/sec, peer bitcornrd36coazsbzsz4pdebyzvaplmsalq4kpoljmn6cg6x5zq.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:38:29Z RATE LIMIT: received 5 addresses, tokens 84.271, since last addr message: 0.058458 addr/sec, peer q5csjdscadbsm27ceyuk7naxveak5yevqlnrowhgcnaxxauwc24zvhqd.onion
2021-07-07T09:38:29Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 89.6849, since last addr message: 0.011045 addr/sec, peer 3.236.255.16
2021-07-07T09:38:30Z RATE LIMIT: received 8 addresses, tokens 19.3853, since last addr message: 0.066289 addr/sec, peer 168.119.79.89
2021-07-07T09:38:31Z RATE LIMIT: received 3 addresses, tokens 32.9822, since last addr message: 0.110629 addr/sec, peer kokkmpquqlkptu5hkmzqlttsmtwxicldr4so7wqsufk6bwf32nma.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:38:36Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 6.5182, since last addr message: 0.054568 addr/sec, peer bitcornrd36coazsbzsz4pdebyzvaplmsalq4kpoljmn6cg6x5zq.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:38:38Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 5.67741, since last addr message: 0.628110 addr/sec, peer bitcornrd36coazsbzsz4pdebyzvaplmsalq4kpoljmn6cg6x5zq.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:38:40Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 77.554, since last addr message: 0.034893 addr/sec, peer 60.244.109.19
2021-07-07T09:38:43Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 90.0297, since last addr message: 0.074362 addr/sec, peer 3.236.255.16
2021-07-07T09:38:43Z RATE LIMIT: received 3 addresses, tokens 82.6335, since last addr message: 0.047190 addr/sec, peer 35.197.140.219
2021-07-07T09:38:53Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 7.00546, since last addr message: 0.025716 addr/sec, peer 83.150.56.145
2021-07-07T09:38:58Z RATE LIMIT: received 70 addresses, tokens 8.67673, since last addr message: 0.812611 addr/sec, peer shh2ewyegnuwnmdse5kl5toybdvzkvk2yj4zcowz6iwhhh3ykdfa.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:39:01Z RATE LIMIT: received 8 addresses, tokens 43.4237, since last addr message: 0.064074 addr/sec, peer i3hcdakiz2tyvggkwefvdjoi7444kgvd2mbdfizjvv43q7zukezq.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:39:03Z RATE LIMIT: received 2 addresses, tokens 6.1267, since last addr message: 0.038963 addr/sec, peer ppsmb5ln3rx6mfdzx2nwsleug5etsavbbzjkdealaybrh2jo2n6a.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:39:05Z RATE LIMIT: received 7 addresses, tokens 82.8845, since last addr message: 0.193719 addr/sec, peer q5csjdscadbsm27ceyuk7naxveak5yevqlnrowhgcnaxxauwc24zvhqd.onion
2021-07-07T09:39:06Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 7.3268, since last addr message: 0.075680 addr/sec, peer 83.150.56.145
2021-07-07T09:39:09Z RATE LIMIT: received 2 addresses, tokens 82.1869, since last addr message: 0.078329 addr/sec, peer 35.197.140.219
2021-07-07T09:39:10Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 15.341, since last addr message: 0.025280 addr/sec, peer 168.119.79.89
2021-07-07T09:39:14Z RATE LIMIT: received 2 addresses, tokens 79.9275, since last addr message: 0.059286 addr/sec, peer 60.244.109.19
2021-07-07T09:39:29Z RATE LIMIT: received 5 addresses, tokens 8.60318, since last addr message: 0.219647 addr/sec, peer 83.150.56.145
2021-07-07T09:39:31Z RATE LIMIT: received 14 addresses, tokens 50.0018, since last addr message: 0.138434 addr/sec, peer 99.108.237.173
2021-07-07T09:39:35Z RATE LIMIT: received 2 addresses, tokens 7.36424, since last addr message: 0.061775 addr/sec, peer ppsmb5ln3rx6mfdzx2nwsleug5etsavbbzjkdealaybrh2jo2n6a.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:39:36Z RATE LIMIT: received 2 addresses, tokens 79.0007, since last addr message: 0.064181 addr/sec, peer q5csjdscadbsm27ceyuk7naxveak5yevqlnrowhgcnaxxauwc24zvhqd.onion
2021-07-07T09:39:37Z RATE LIMIT: received 9 addresses, tokens 36.5186, since last addr message: 0.137689 addr/sec, peer kokkmpquqlkptu5hkmzqlttsmtwxicldr4so7wqsufk6bwf32nma.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:39:42Z RATE LIMIT: received 18 addresses, tokens 37.5215, since last addr message: 0.135436 addr/sec, peer 127.0.0.1
2021-07-07T09:39:43Z RATE LIMIT: received 8 addresses, tokens 39.622, since last addr message: 0.190555 addr/sec, peer i3hcdakiz2tyvggkwefvdjoi7444kgvd2mbdfizjvv43q7zukezq.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:39:48Z RATE LIMIT: received 2 addresses, tokens 37.7395, since last addr message: 0.115091 addr/sec, peer 99.108.237.173
2021-07-07T09:39:51Z RATE LIMIT: received 3 addresses, tokens 18.4526, since last addr message: 0.072964 addr/sec, peer 168.119.79.89
2021-07-07T09:39:57Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 7.50869, since last addr message: 0.046632 addr/sec, peer ppsmb5ln3rx6mfdzx2nwsleug5etsavbbzjkdealaybrh2jo2n6a.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:40:01Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 33.4199, since last addr message: 0.055620 addr/sec, peer i3hcdakiz2tyvggkwefvdjoi7444kgvd2mbdfizjvv43q7zukezq.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:40:01Z RATE LIMIT: received 2 addresses, tokens 21.4168, since last addr message: 0.105524 addr/sec, peer 127.0.0.1
2021-07-07T09:40:04Z RATE LIMIT: received 8 addresses, tokens 13.298, since last addr message: 0.092801 addr/sec, peer bitcornrd36coazsbzsz4pdebyzvaplmsalq4kpoljmn6cg6x5zq.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:40:08Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 37.7125, since last addr message: 0.050683 addr/sec, peer 99.108.237.173
2021-07-07T09:40:08Z RATE LIMIT: received 87 addresses, tokens 7.64895, since last addr message: 7.629815 addr/sec, peer ppsmb5ln3rx6mfdzx2nwsleug5etsavbbzjkdealaybrh2jo2n6a.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:40:11Z RATE LIMIT: received 2 addresses, tokens 86.4075, since last addr message: 0.032151 addr/sec, peer 35.197.140.219
2021-07-07T09:40:15Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 84.8092, since last addr message: 0.248938 addr/sec, peer 35.197.140.219
2021-07-07T09:40:16Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 31.4715, since last addr message: 0.025298 addr/sec, peer kokkmpquqlkptu5hkmzqlttsmtwxicldr4so7wqsufk6bwf32nma.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:40:18Z RATE LIMIT: received 19 addresses, tokens 67.5595, since last addr message: 0.084633 addr/sec, peer 2a01:4f8:140:948b::2
2021-07-07T09:40:20Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 1.80042, since last addr message: 0.086846 addr/sec, peer ppsmb5ln3rx6mfdzx2nwsleug5etsavbbzjkdealaybrh2jo2n6a.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:40:20Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 6.83211, since last addr message: 0.065183 addr/sec, peer bitcornrd36coazsbzsz4pdebyzvaplmsalq4kpoljmn6cg6x5zq.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:40:20Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 21.2516, since last addr message: 0.054502 addr/sec, peer 127.0.0.1
2021-07-07T09:40:28Z RATE LIMIT: received 6 addresses, tokens 9.50376, since last addr message: 0.101685 addr/sec, peer 83.150.56.145
2021-07-07T09:40:34Z RATE LIMIT: received 6 addresses, tokens 85.9494, since last addr message: 0.074795 addr/sec, peer 60.244.109.19
2021-07-07T09:40:35Z RATE LIMIT: received 2 addresses, tokens 32.36, since last addr message: 0.105902 addr/sec, peer kokkmpquqlkptu5hkmzqlttsmtwxicldr4so7wqsufk6bwf32nma.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:40:37Z RATE LIMIT: received 2 addresses, tokens 21.9911, since last addr message: 0.114970 addr/sec, peer 127.0.0.1
2021-07-07T09:40:39Z RATE LIMIT: received 2 addresses, tokens 86.1762, since last addr message: 0.084493 addr/sec, peer 35.197.140.219
2021-07-07T09:40:39Z RATE LIMIT: received 82 addresses, tokens 10.796, since last addr message: 0.810331 addr/sec, peer shh2ewyegnuwnmdse5kl5toybdvzkvk2yj4zcowz6iwhhh3ykdfa.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:40:41Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 20.4395, since last addr message: 0.020053 addr/sec, peer 168.119.79.89
2021-07-07T09:40:44Z RATE LIMIT: received 2 addresses, tokens 36.7779, since last addr message: 0.045893 addr/sec, peer i3hcdakiz2tyvggkwefvdjoi7444kgvd2mbdfizjvv43q7zukezq.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:40:49Z RATE LIMIT: received 6 addresses, tokens 21.1393, since last addr message: 0.522559 addr/sec, peer 127.0.0.1
2021-07-07T09:40:52Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 20.5433, since last addr message: 0.090589 addr/sec, peer 168.119.79.89
2021-07-07T09:40:55Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 6.18741, since last addr message: 0.037263 addr/sec, peer 83.150.56.145
2021-07-07T09:40:55Z RATE LIMIT: received 2 addresses, tokens 41.4496, since last addr message: 0.042221 addr/sec, peer 99.108.237.173
2021-07-07T09:41:02Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 36.4862, since last addr message: 0.058538 addr/sec, peer i3hcdakiz2tyvggkwefvdjoi7444kgvd2mbdfizjvv43q7zukezq.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:41:02Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 20.5747, since last addr message: 0.096961 addr/sec, peer 168.119.79.89
2021-07-07T09:41:03Z RATE LIMIT: received 3 addresses, tokens 3.20141, since last addr message: 0.124722 addr/sec, peer shh2ewyegnuwnmdse5kl5toybdvzkvk2yj4zcowz6iwhhh3ykdfa.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:41:03Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 5.19149, since last addr message: 0.022773 addr/sec, peer ppsmb5ln3rx6mfdzx2nwsleug5etsavbbzjkdealaybrh2jo2n6a.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:41:07Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 0.602009, since last addr message: 0.249623 addr/sec, peer shh2ewyegnuwnmdse5kl5toybdvzkvk2yj4zcowz6iwhhh3ykdfa.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:41:08Z RATE LIMIT: received 6 addresses, tokens 33.6194, since last addr message: 0.184085 addr/sec, peer kokkmpquqlkptu5hkmzqlttsmtwxicldr4so7wqsufk6bwf32nma.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:41:12Z RATE LIMIT: received 10 addresses, tokens 176.895, since last addr message: 0.010638 addr/sec, peer 188.166.69.73
2021-07-07T09:41:14Z RATE LIMIT: received 11 addresses, tokens 11.2737, since last addr message: 0.202147 addr/sec, peer bitcornrd36coazsbzsz4pdebyzvaplmsalq4kpoljmn6cg6x5zq.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:41:14Z RATE LIMIT: received 7 addresses, tokens 92.2651, since last addr message: 0.007647 addr/sec, peer 2a03:b0c0:2:d0::4bc:2001
2021-07-07T09:41:18Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 18.0789, since last addr message: 0.034019 addr/sec, peer 127.0.0.1
2021-07-07T09:41:21Z RATE LIMIT: received 2 addresses, tokens 5.9012, since last addr message: 0.116979 addr/sec, peer ppsmb5ln3rx6mfdzx2nwsleug5etsavbbzjkdealaybrh2jo2n6a.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:41:23Z RATE LIMIT: received 10 addresses, tokens 182.417, since last addr message: 0.026198 addr/sec, peer 140.143.155.41
2021-07-07T09:41:26Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 4.40764, since last addr message: 0.197455 addr/sec, peer ppsmb5ln3rx6mfdzx2nwsleug5etsavbbzjkdealaybrh2jo2n6a.b32.i2p
2021-07-07T09:41:26Z RATE LIMIT: received 1 addresses, tokens 1.49683, since last addr message: 0.081757 addr/sec, peer bitcornrd36coazsbzsz4pdebyzvaplmsalq4kpoljmn6cg6x5zq.b32.i2p

There seems to be way too many cases where we receive more addresses than available tokens (so addresses will be dropped) and rates of more than 0.1 addr/sec (not necessary meaning that addresses will be dropped because that is only since the last addr message received). I assume nobody was attacking my node at the time with addr messages flood.

src/net_processing.cpp

naumenkogs · 2021-07-07T11:46:55Z

I have 2 conceptual questions to this PR:

How does it work against the "bottlenecking problem" (something we saw in the dandelion/rate-limiting discussion too)?
Let's say your reachable node has 10 outbound conns, and couple inbounds.
An attacker makes 100 connections to your node, and constantly spends all tokens by transmitting more-than-average addrs. Now, when your peers receive announcements from your node, they might very likely exclude your honest inbounds (you announced to them) from relay, and announce only those Sybil nodes instead.
Previously, they would relay everything I guess?
Do we want to design these tokens while keeping in mind that we also wanna reuse them for other kinds of p2p dos? Or are we going to have separate tokens for other use-cases in the future? Or do you want to ignore this aspect for now?

glozow · 2021-07-07T13:13:55Z

re ACK dc8a186 via git range-diff dade562...dc8a186

New constant MAX_ADDR_PROCESSING_TOKEN_BUCKET
Comments about exceeding [soft] limit when incrementing for GETADDR
const time_diff and increment
break out of addrs loop when tokens run out
rand ranges {1,255} + refactors in test

maflcko

post-merge cr ACK

maflcko · 2021-07-19T15:36:44Z

src/net_processing.cpp

+            if (rate_limited) {
+                if (peer->m_addr_token_bucket < 1.0) {
+                    ++num_rate_limit;
+                    continue;
+                }
+                peer->m_addr_token_bucket -= 1.0;
+            }


Is there a reason to increment the bucket when rate limiting is disabled? I presume you want to prepare for the future where permission flags can be changed at runtime? In that case, shouldn't the code here be:

if (peer->m_addr_token_bucket < 1.0) { if (rate_limited) { ++num_rate_limit; continue; } } else { peer->m_addr_token_bucket -= 1.0; }

Proposed in #22604.

maflcko · 2021-07-19T15:41:47Z

src/net_processing.cpp

+                 num_proc,
+                 num_rate_limit,
+                 pfrom.GetId(),
+                 fLogIPs ? ", peeraddr=" + pfrom.addr.ToString() : "");


Is there a reason to log the ip address outside of the version handshake? This seems redundant, as the ip shouldn't change afterwards and should be easy to lookup by grepping for the handshake of the peer id.

Otherwise this encourages to put other redundant stuff (ua-string, ...) into this log messages and other log messages as well.

Proposed in #22604.

maflcko · 2021-07-19T15:45:28Z

src/rpc/net.cpp

@@ -242,6 +242,8 @@ static RPCHelpMan getpeerinfo()
                heights.push_back(height);
            }
            obj.pushKV("inflight", heights);
+            obj.pushKV("addr_processed", statestats.m_addr_processed);
+            obj.pushKV("addr_rate_limited", statestats.m_addr_rate_limited);


is there a reason to omit this from the documentation?

can use the descriptions in a5cc9e2 if so inclined

helps added in #22604.

While limitations on the influence of attackers on addrman already exist (affected buckets are restricted to a subset based on incoming IP / network group), there is no reason to permit them to let them feed us addresses at more than a multiple of the normal network rate. This commit introduces a "token bucket" rate limiter for the processing of addresses in incoming ADDR and ADDRV2 messages. Every connection gets an associated token bucket. Processing an address in an ADDR or ADDRV2 message from non-whitelisted peers consumes a token from the bucket. If the bucket is empty, the address is ignored (it is not forwarded or processed). The token counter increases at a rate of 0.1 tokens per second, and will accrue up to a maximum of 1000 tokens (the maximum we accept in a single ADDR or ADDRV2). When a GETADDR is sent to a peer, it immediately gets 1000 additional tokens, as we actively desire many addresses from such peers (this may temporarily cause the token count to exceed 1000). The rate limit of 0.1 addr/s was chosen based on observation of honest nodes on the network. Activity in general from most nodes is either 0, or up to a maximum around 0.025 addr/s for recent Bitcoin Core nodes. A few (self-identified, through subver) crawler nodes occasionally exceed 0.1 addr/s. Github-Pull: bitcoin#22387 Rebased-From: 0d64b8f

Github-Pull: bitcoin#22387 Rebased-From: 5648138

Includes logging improvements by Vasil Dimov and John Newbery. Github-Pull: bitcoin#22387 Rebased-From: f424d60

fanquake · 2021-07-28T23:57:36Z

Backported in #22569.

Includes logging improvements by Vasil Dimov and John Newbery. Github-Pull: bitcoin#22387 Rebased-From: f424d60

While limitations on the influence of attackers on addrman already exist (affected buckets are restricted to a subset based on incoming IP / network group), there is no reason to permit them to let them feed us addresses at more than a multiple of the normal network rate. This commit introduces a "token bucket" rate limiter for the processing of addresses in incoming ADDR and ADDRV2 messages. Every connection gets an associated token bucket. Processing an address in an ADDR or ADDRV2 message from non-whitelisted peers consumes a token from the bucket. If the bucket is empty, the address is ignored (it is not forwarded or processed). The token counter increases at a rate of 0.1 tokens per second, and will accrue up to a maximum of 1000 tokens (the maximum we accept in a single ADDR or ADDRV2). When a GETADDR is sent to a peer, it immediately gets 1000 additional tokens, as we actively desire many addresses from such peers (this may temporarily cause the token count to exceed 1000). The rate limit of 0.1 addr/s was chosen based on observation of honest nodes on the network. Activity in general from most nodes is either 0, or up to a maximum around 0.025 addr/s for recent Bitcoin Core nodes. A few (self-identified, through subver) crawler nodes occasionally exceed 0.1 addr/s. Github-Pull: bitcoin#22387 Rebased-From: 0d64b8f

Github-Pull: bitcoin#22387 Rebased-From: 5648138

Github-Pull: bitcoin#22387 Rebased-From: b4ece8a

Includes logging improvements by Vasil Dimov and John Newbery. Github-Pull: bitcoin#22387 Rebased-From: f424d60

While limitations on the influence of attackers on addrman already exist (affected buckets are restricted to a subset based on incoming IP / network group), there is no reason to permit them to let them feed us addresses at more than a multiple of the normal network rate. This commit introduces a "token bucket" rate limiter for the processing of addresses in incoming ADDR and ADDRV2 messages. Every connection gets an associated token bucket. Processing an address in an ADDR or ADDRV2 message from non-whitelisted peers consumes a token from the bucket. If the bucket is empty, the address is ignored (it is not forwarded or processed). The token counter increases at a rate of 0.1 tokens per second, and will accrue up to a maximum of 1000 tokens (the maximum we accept in a single ADDR or ADDRV2). When a GETADDR is sent to a peer, it immediately gets 1000 additional tokens, as we actively desire many addresses from such peers (this may temporarily cause the token count to exceed 1000). The rate limit of 0.1 addr/s was chosen based on observation of honest nodes on the network. Activity in general from most nodes is either 0, or up to a maximum around 0.025 addr/s for recent Bitcoin Core nodes. A few (self-identified, through subver) crawler nodes occasionally exceed 0.1 addr/s. Github-Pull: bitcoin#22387 Rebased-From: 0d64b8f

Github-Pull: bitcoin#22387 Rebased-From: 5648138

Github-Pull: bitcoin#22387 Rebased-From: b4ece8a

Includes logging improvements by Vasil Dimov and John Newbery. Github-Pull: bitcoin#22387 Rebased-From: f424d60

While limitations on the influence of attackers on addrman already exist (affected buckets are restricted to a subset based on incoming IP / network group), there is no reason to permit them to let them feed us addresses at more than a multiple of the normal network rate. This commit introduces a "token bucket" rate limiter for the processing of addresses in incoming ADDR and ADDRV2 messages. Every connection gets an associated token bucket. Processing an address in an ADDR or ADDRV2 message from non-whitelisted peers consumes a token from the bucket. If the bucket is empty, the address is ignored (it is not forwarded or processed). The token counter increases at a rate of 0.1 tokens per second, and will accrue up to a maximum of 1000 tokens (the maximum we accept in a single ADDR or ADDRV2). When a GETADDR is sent to a peer, it immediately gets 1000 additional tokens, as we actively desire many addresses from such peers (this may temporarily cause the token count to exceed 1000). The rate limit of 0.1 addr/s was chosen based on observation of honest nodes on the network. Activity in general from most nodes is either 0, or up to a maximum around 0.025 addr/s for recent Bitcoin Core nodes. A few (self-identified, through subver) crawler nodes occasionally exceed 0.1 addr/s. Github-Pull: bitcoin#22387 Rebased-From: 0d64b8f

Github-Pull: bitcoin#22387 Rebased-From: 5648138

Github-Pull: bitcoin#22387 Rebased-From: b4ece8a

Includes logging improvements by Vasil Dimov and John Newbery. Github-Pull: bitcoin#22387 Rebased-From: f424d60

2a57108 Avoid Appveyor compilation failure (Pieter Wuille) a653aac Add logging and addr rate limiting statistics (Pieter Wuille) aaa4833 Functional tests for addr rate limiting (Pieter Wuille) 8df3e5b Randomize the order of addr processing (Pieter Wuille) 83dfe6c Rate limit the processing of incoming addr messages (Pieter Wuille) Pull request description: Backport of #22387. The rate at which IP addresses are rumoured (through ADDR and ADDRV2 messages) on the network seems to vary from 0 for some non-participating nodes, to 0.005-0.025 addr/s for recent Bitcoin Core nodes. However, the current codebase will happily accept and process an effectively unbounded rate from attackers. There are measures to limit the influence attackers can have on the addrman database (bucket restrictions based on source IPs), but still - there is no need to permit them to feed us addresses at a rate that's orders of magnitude larger than what is common on the network today, especially as it will cause us to spam our peers too. This PR implements a [token bucket](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Token_bucket) based rate limiter, allowing an average of 0.1 addr/s per connection, with bursts up to 1000 addresses at once. Whitelisted peers as well as responses to GETADDR requests are exempt from the limit. New connections start with 1 token, so as to not interfere with the common practice of peers' self-announcement. Due to the lack of the `Peer` struct in 0.21, the relevant fields have been added to `CNodeState` instead, necessitating additional locks, and slightly different structure to avoid too much `cs_main` grabbing. The last test-improving commit has also been dropped, as the code has changed too much. Most of the behavior is still tested however, just not the part that compares with RPC statistics. ACKs for top commit: achow101: ACK 2a57108 GeneFerneau: Approach + code review ACK [2a57108](2a57108) jnewbery: reACK 2a57108 Tree-SHA512: ecf4891ac6173d732aa40b4d05fc0dce94127a613cb9051bf6188a2f95824f8234b17d386dd0b352ddf3d352202cc2ff07915ae35657d8e64907e3f80703d1d9

d930c7f p2p, rpc, test: address rate-limiting follow-ups (Jon Atack) Pull request description: Incorporates review feedback in #22387. Edit, could be considered separately: should a release note (or two) be added for 22.0? e.g. the new getpeerinfo fields in `Updated RPCs` and the rate-limiting itself in `P2P and network changes`. ACKs for top commit: MarcoFalke: review ACK d930c7f theStack: re-ACK d930c7f 🌮 Zero-1729: crACK d930c7f Tree-SHA512: b2101cad87f59c238603f38bd8e8df7a4d48929794e4de9e0e0ff2afa935a68475c2d369aa669d124a0bec2f50280fb47e8b980bde6ad812db08cf67b71c066a

Github-Pull: bitcoin#22387 Partially-Rebased-From: 5648138

Summary: > While limitations on the influence of attackers on addrman already > exist (affected buckets are restricted to a subset based on incoming > IP / network group), there is no reason to permit them to let them > feed us addresses at more than a multiple of the normal network > rate. > > This commit introduces a "token bucket" rate limiter for the > processing of addresses in incoming ADDR and ADDRV2 messages. > Every connection gets an associated token bucket. Processing an > address in an ADDR or ADDRV2 message from non-whitelisted peers > consumes a token from the bucket. If the bucket is empty, the > address is ignored (it is not forwarded or processed). The token > counter increases at a rate of 0.1 tokens per second, and will > accrue up to a maximum of 1000 tokens (the maximum we accept in a > single ADDR or ADDRV2). When a GETADDR is sent to a peer, it > immediately gets 1000 additional tokens, as we actively desire many > addresses from such peers (this may temporarily cause the token > count to exceed 1000). > > The rate limit of 0.1 addr/s was chosen based on observation of > honest nodes on the network. Activity in general from most nodes > is either 0, or up to a maximum around 0.025 addr/s for recent > Bitcoin Core nodes. A few (self-identified, through subver) crawler > nodes occasionally exceed 0.1 addr/s. > Randomize the order of addr processing > Functional tests for addr rate limiting > Add logging and addr rate limiting statistics > > Includes logging improvements by Vasil Dimov and John Newbery. > Improve addr relay tests using statistics Note: this backport bypasses an intermediate change in `p2p_addrv2_relay.py` from [[bitcoin/bitcoin#22211 | core#22211]] This is a backport of [[bitcoin/bitcoin#22387 | core#22387]] Test Plan: `ninja all check-all` IBD tests Reviewers: #bitcoin_abc, Fabien Reviewed By: #bitcoin_abc, Fabien Subscribers: Fabien Differential Revision: https://reviews.bitcoinabc.org/D10941

Summary: Incorporates review feedback in [[bitcoin/bitcoin#22387 | core#22387]] This is a backport of [[bitcoin/bitcoin#22604 | core#22604]] Depends on D10941 Test Plan: `ninja all check-all` Reviewers: #bitcoin_abc, Fabien Reviewed By: #bitcoin_abc, Fabien Differential Revision: https://reviews.bitcoinabc.org/D10942

… of rumoured addresses (sipa)

fanquake added the P2P label Jul 2, 2021

fanquake added this to the 22.0 milestone Jul 2, 2021

fanquake mentioned this pull request Jul 2, 2021

ci: Android CI failing to download packages #22389

Closed

DrahtBot mentioned this pull request Jul 2, 2021

[p2p] Reduce addr blackholes #21528

Merged

jnewbery reviewed Jul 2, 2021

View reviewed changes

sipa force-pushed the 202106_rate_limit_addr branch 2 times, most recently from 80ce2e9 to bb42151 Compare July 2, 2021 16:54

amitiuttarwar closed this Jul 3, 2021

amitiuttarwar reopened this Jul 3, 2021

mzumsande reviewed Jul 4, 2021

View reviewed changes

sipa force-pushed the 202106_rate_limit_addr branch 2 times, most recently from 74f46c9 to dade562 Compare July 6, 2021 04:54

vasild reviewed Jul 6, 2021

View reviewed changes

jnewbery reviewed Jul 6, 2021

View reviewed changes

src/net_processing.cpp Outdated Show resolved Hide resolved

test/functional/p2p_invalid_messages.py Show resolved Hide resolved

test/functional/p2p_addr_relay.py Outdated Show resolved Hide resolved

vasild reviewed Jul 6, 2021

View reviewed changes

glozow reviewed Jul 6, 2021

View reviewed changes

src/net_processing.cpp Show resolved Hide resolved

src/net_processing.cpp Outdated Show resolved Hide resolved

src/net_processing.cpp Outdated Show resolved Hide resolved

sipa force-pushed the 202106_rate_limit_addr branch 2 times, most recently from c643c73 to dc8a186 Compare July 7, 2021 01:37

jnewbery reviewed Jul 7, 2021

View reviewed changes

src/net_processing.cpp Outdated Show resolved Hide resolved

vasild reviewed Jul 7, 2021

View reviewed changes

src/net_processing.cpp Outdated Show resolved Hide resolved

maflcko reviewed Jul 19, 2021

View reviewed changes

sidhujag pushed a commit to syscoin/syscoin that referenced this pull request Jul 23, 2021

erge bitcoin#22387: Rate limit the processing of rumoured addresses

d2db5ff

sipa added a commit to sipa/bitcoin that referenced this pull request Jul 28, 2021

Randomize the order of addr processing

6c32ceb

Github-Pull: bitcoin#22387 Rebased-From: 5648138

sipa added a commit to sipa/bitcoin that referenced this pull request Jul 28, 2021

Add logging and addr rate limiting statistics

6da0776

Includes logging improvements by Vasil Dimov and John Newbery. Github-Pull: bitcoin#22387 Rebased-From: f424d60

sipa mentioned this pull request Jul 28, 2021

[0.21] Rate limit the processing of rumoured addresses #22569

Merged

sipa added a commit to sipa/bitcoin that referenced this pull request Jul 28, 2021

Add logging and addr rate limiting statistics

a4ae2a6

Includes logging improvements by Vasil Dimov and John Newbery. Github-Pull: bitcoin#22387 Rebased-From: f424d60

sipa added a commit to sipa/bitcoin that referenced this pull request Jul 29, 2021

Add logging and addr rate limiting statistics

55fcbde

Includes logging improvements by Vasil Dimov and John Newbery. Github-Pull: bitcoin#22387 Rebased-From: f424d60

sipa added a commit to sipa/bitcoin that referenced this pull request Jul 29, 2021

Randomize the order of addr processing

6dec444

Github-Pull: bitcoin#22387 Rebased-From: 5648138

sipa added a commit to sipa/bitcoin that referenced this pull request Jul 29, 2021

Functional tests for addr rate limiting

b65129e

Github-Pull: bitcoin#22387 Rebased-From: b4ece8a

sipa added a commit to sipa/bitcoin that referenced this pull request Jul 29, 2021

Add logging and addr rate limiting statistics

651216e

Includes logging improvements by Vasil Dimov and John Newbery. Github-Pull: bitcoin#22387 Rebased-From: f424d60

sipa added a commit to sipa/bitcoin that referenced this pull request Jul 29, 2021

Randomize the order of addr processing

5cf36bb

Github-Pull: bitcoin#22387 Rebased-From: 5648138

sipa added a commit to sipa/bitcoin that referenced this pull request Jul 29, 2021

Functional tests for addr rate limiting

d21ebf6

Github-Pull: bitcoin#22387 Rebased-From: b4ece8a

sipa added a commit to sipa/bitcoin that referenced this pull request Jul 29, 2021

Add logging and addr rate limiting statistics

4e6661f

Includes logging improvements by Vasil Dimov and John Newbery. Github-Pull: bitcoin#22387 Rebased-From: f424d60

jonatack mentioned this pull request Aug 2, 2021

p2p, rpc, test: address rate-limiting follow-ups #22604

Merged

sipa added a commit to sipa/bitcoin that referenced this pull request Aug 5, 2021

Randomize the order of addr processing

8df3e5b

Github-Pull: bitcoin#22387 Rebased-From: 5648138

sipa added a commit to sipa/bitcoin that referenced this pull request Aug 5, 2021

Functional tests for addr rate limiting

aaa4833

Github-Pull: bitcoin#22387 Rebased-From: b4ece8a

sipa added a commit to sipa/bitcoin that referenced this pull request Aug 5, 2021

Add logging and addr rate limiting statistics

a653aac

Includes logging improvements by Vasil Dimov and John Newbery. Github-Pull: bitcoin#22387 Rebased-From: f424d60

luke-jr pushed a commit to bitcoinknots/bitcoin that referenced this pull request Dec 15, 2021

QA: p2p_addrv2_relay: Be flexible with the order of addr processing

2af73be

Github-Pull: bitcoin#22387 Partially-Rebased-From: 5648138

stickies-v pushed a commit to stickies-v/bitcoin-devwiki that referenced this pull request Mar 24, 2022

update changelog with bitcoin/bitcoin#22387 Rate limit the processing…

716a21d

… of rumoured addresses (sipa)

gwillen pushed a commit to ElementsProject/elements that referenced this pull request Jun 1, 2022

Merge d3474b8 into merged_master (Bitcoin PR bitcoin/bitcoin#22387)

d4c7159

bitcoin locked as resolved and limited conversation to collaborators Aug 18, 2022

Rate limit the processing of rumoured addresses #22387

Rate limit the processing of rumoured addresses #22387

Uh oh!

Conversation

sipa commented Jul 2, 2021 • edited Loading Uh oh! There was an error while loading. Please reload this page.

Uh oh!

Uh oh!

DrahtBot commented Jul 2, 2021 • edited Loading Uh oh! There was an error while loading. Please reload this page.

Uh oh!

Conflicts

Uh oh!

ghost commented Jul 2, 2021

Uh oh!

vasild commented Jul 2, 2021

Uh oh!

jnewbery left a comment

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

Uh oh!

Uh oh!

Uh oh!

Uh oh!

Uh oh!

Uh oh!

Uh oh!

ghost commented Jul 2, 2021

Uh oh!

sipa commented Jul 2, 2021

Uh oh!

mzumsande commented Jul 2, 2021 • edited Loading Uh oh! There was an error while loading. Please reload this page.

Uh oh!

Uh oh!

sipa commented Jul 2, 2021

Uh oh!

amitiuttarwar commented Jul 3, 2021

Uh oh!

Uh oh!

Uh oh!

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

Uh oh!

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

Uh oh!

vasild left a comment

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

Uh oh!

Uh oh!

Uh oh!

Uh oh!

Uh oh!

Uh oh!

Uh oh!

Uh oh!

jnewbery left a comment

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

Uh oh!

Uh oh!

Uh oh!

Uh oh!

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

Uh oh!

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

Uh oh!

glozow left a comment

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

Uh oh!

Uh oh!

Uh oh!

Uh oh!

jnewbery left a comment

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

Uh oh!

Uh oh!

vasild left a comment • edited Loading Uh oh! There was an error while loading. Please reload this page.

Uh oh!

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

Uh oh!

Uh oh!

naumenkogs commented Jul 7, 2021

Uh oh!

glozow commented Jul 7, 2021

Uh oh!

sipa commented Jul 2, 2021 •

edited

Loading

DrahtBot commented Jul 2, 2021 •

edited

Loading

mzumsande commented Jul 2, 2021 •

edited

Loading

vasild left a comment •

edited

Loading

maflcko Jul 19, 2021 •

edited

Loading