.github/workflows/test.yml (1)

15-21: ⚠️ Potential issue

Fix CLI argument interpolation
The --github-token GH_TOKEN flag passes the literal string GH_TOKEN. It must interpolate the environment variable:

- run: dagger call check --github-token GH_TOKEN --model gpt-4.1 --commit $GITHUB_SHA
+ run: dagger call check --github-token $GH_TOKEN --model gpt-4.1 --commit $GITHUB_SHA

.dagger/main.go (1)

112-118: Same alias problem leaks here

dag.GithubRelease() won’t compile until the alias issue above is fixed (or call dagger.GithubRelease()). Be sure to update this block after adjusting the import.

.dagger/develop.go (1)

3-9: Consistent aliasing required across modules

All three new files import the same internal dagger package but rely on the identifier dag. Apply the alias fix here as well, otherwise none of the generated code will build.

.dagger/prompts/fix_tests.md (2)

9-9: Hyphenate “Problem-Solving” for consistency
Per LanguageTool’s suggestion, use a hyphen in the section title to match standard terminology.

-## Problem Solving Process
+## Problem-Solving Process

🧰 Tools

🪛 LanguageTool

[grammar] ~9-~9: This noun or verb “Problem-Solving” is spelled with a hyphen.
Context: ...to build, test, and modify the code ## Problem Solving Process 1. Run the tests to identify wh...

(PROBLEM_SOLVE_HYPHEN)

---

24-24: Use concise wording for task status
Avoid wordiness by replacing “not complete” with “incomplete”:

-- The task is not complete until all tests pass successfully
+- The task is incomplete until all tests pass successfully

🧰 Tools

🪛 LanguageTool

[style] ~24-~24: Consider using “incomplete” to avoid wordiness.
Context: ...r each significant change - The task is not complete until all tests pass successfully

(NOT_ABLE_PREMIUM)

.dagger/workspace/.gitignore (1)

2-4: Ensure directory patterns include trailing slash
To explicitly denote directories and avoid ambiguity, append / to each directory path:

-/internal/dagger
-/internal/querybuilder
-/internal/telemetry
+/internal/dagger/
+/internal/querybuilder/
+/internal/telemetry/

.dagger/.gitignore (1)

4-5: Normalize directory ignore patterns with trailing slashes
For consistency across .gitignore files, explicitly mark directories:

-/internal/dagger
-/internal/telemetry
+/internal/dagger/
+/internal/telemetry/

.dagger/backend/.gitignore (1)

4-5: Add trailing slashes to directory entries
Align with other modules by clearly indicating these are directories:

-/internal/dagger
-/internal/telemetry
+/internal/dagger/
+/internal/telemetry/

.github/workflows/usage-comments.yml (2)

1-5: Expand workflow triggers for comment updates
The workflow only runs on PR opened events. To ensure comments stay updated when the PR changes, include synchronize and reopened events under pull_request.types.

---

6-25: Add concurrency to prevent redundant jobs
Without a concurrency group, rapid updates can queue multiple comment jobs. Define a concurrency block to cancel in-progress runs for the same PR.

Example addition:

  comment:
    concurrency:
      group: usage-comment-${{ github.event.pull_request.number }}
      cancel-in-progress: true

.dagger/backend/go.mod (1)

46-53: Consolidate or remove redundant replace directives
You’re replacing packages at the same version you already require (v0.8.0). Consider removing these replaces if they’re not overriding a different transitive version, or grouping them together for readability.

dagger.json (1)

17-21: Avoid duplicate commit specifiers
For github-release, both source and pin specify the same commit. You can streamline by removing @c6081b3210407d5ea49fce8874c5104afa8373cb from source and relying solely on pin.

.github/workflows/test.yml (2)

1-4: Simplify branch filters
Using branches: ["**", "!main"] works but can be simplified to:

on:
  push:
    branches-ignore:
      - main

This is clearer and more idiomatic.

---

10-12: Streamline token setup
Instead of manually echoing the GitHub token, consider:

- uses: actions/github-script@v6
  id: generate-token
  with:
    script: return process.env.GITHUB_TOKEN

This reduces shell usage and simplifies token retrieval.

.dagger/go.mod (1)

46-53: Consolidate replace directives
As with the backend module, consider grouping or removing replaces that match required versions exactly.

.dagger/prompts/assignment.md (2)

3-3: Apply hyphenation for consistency
The heading “Problem solving process” should be hyphenated for clarity:

- ## Problem solving process
+ ## Problem-solving process

🧰 Tools

🪛 LanguageTool

[grammar] ~3-~3: This noun or verb “Problem-solving” is spelled with a hyphen.
Context: ...ement Control Plane) Server project ## Problem solving process 1. Consider the assignment's i...

(PROBLEM_SOLVE_HYPHEN)

---

29-30: Prefer concise wording
To reduce wordiness, change:

- The assignment is not complete until all tests pass and the implementation meets requirements
+ The assignment is incomplete until all tests pass and the implementation meets requirements

🧰 Tools

🪛 LanguageTool

[style] ~30-~30: Consider using “incomplete” to avoid wordiness.
Context: ...fter making changes - The assignment is not complete until all tests pass and the implementa...

(NOT_ABLE_PREMIUM)

.dagger/prompts/review.md (1)

1-61: Well-structured review prompt with comprehensive guidelines

This review prompt provides an excellent framework for structured code reviews of the HAProxy MCP Server project. The format is clear, comprehensive, and covers all essential aspects of a thorough code review process.

Consider adding a section about how to handle follow-up comments or responses to address reviewer feedback, which would complete the review cycle.

Consider hyphenating "Problem solving" on line 4 to "Problem-solving" for grammatical correctness.

🧰 Tools

🪛 LanguageTool

[misspelling] ~26-~26: This word is normally spelled as one.
Context: ...ards? - Are there any code smells or anti-patterns? ## Good Pull Request Criteria - The ...

(EN_COMPOUNDS_ANTI_PATTERNS)

---

[style] ~41-~41: Consider using a different verb for a more formal wording.
Context: ...Any show-stopping problems that must be fixed - Suggestions: Recommended improvem...

(FIX_RESOLVE)

.dagger/prompts/feedback.md (1)

4-5: Grammar correction needed

The term should be hyphenated as "Problem-solving process" rather than "Problem solving process".

-## Problem solving process
+## Problem-solving process

🧰 Tools

🪛 LanguageTool

[grammar] ~4-~4: This noun or verb “Problem-solving” is spelled with a hyphen.
Context: ...eceived feedback on a pull request. ## Problem solving process 1. Carefully review the origin...

(PROBLEM_SOLVE_HYPHEN)

.github/workflows/slash-commands.yml (1)

9-11: Unnecessary token generation step

This step simply echoes the github.token to an output variable, but GitHub Actions already provides github.token directly. You could simplify by using ${{ github.token }} directly in later steps.

.dagger/suggestions.go (1)

16-80: Consider refactoring complex diff parsing logic

The parseDiff function handles multiple concerns (file detection, line tracking, suggestion building) in one large function. Consider breaking it into smaller, focused functions for better readability and maintainability.

.dagger/workspace/go.mod (1)

10-21: Version drift between OpenTelemetry core (v1.34.x) and log exporter (v0.8.x)

Mixing major-version series (v1.* vs v0.*) can introduce subtle incompatibilities.
Consider pinning all OpenTelemetry-log packages to the same minor stream as the core SDK, or explicitly document why the mix is required.

.dagger/review.go (1)

37-40: Unbounded .Loop() may create runaway token usage

LLM(...).Loop() will iterate until the agent decides to stop. For safety (cost / latency), consider adding an explicit iteration or token cap if the API supports it, e.g.:

agent := dag.LLM(dagger.LLMOpts{Model: model}).
    WithEnv(env).
    WithPromptFile(prompt).
-   Loop()
+   Loop(dagger.LoopOpts{MaxIterations: 5})

.dagger/debugger.go (1)

75-90: Handle parseDiff errors and empty suggestions early

If parseDiff returns an unexpected structure (nil slice, malformed hunks, etc.) the subsequent loop will silently no-op or panic.

Add simple validation:

if len(codeSuggestions) == 0 {
    return fmt.Errorf("unable to parse diff into suggestions")
}

.dagger/develop.go (2)

33-37: Potential infinite loop with LLM().Loop()

dag.LLM(...).Loop() keeps sending the prompt until the agent signals it is finished. If the prompt template or model mis-behaves this can create an endless run and burn API credits. Consider introducing a max-iterations guard or time-out parameter so CI jobs don’t hang indefinitely.

---

144-145: Slash-command stripping misses newline-only invocations

You only remove the exact substring "/agent " (note the space). A user typing /agent\n or /agent will not be stripped. A safer approach is:

feedback = strings.TrimPrefix(strings.TrimSpace(feedback), "/agent")

.dagger/backend/main.go (6)

97-97: Pinned container image with SHA is good, but needs update process

Using a pinned image with SHA is excellent for reproducibility. However, ensure you have a process to periodically update this hash to receive security updates.

---

103-103: Port configuration documentation needs improvement

The comment indicates port 8080 is the "default HAProxy MCP Server port" but suggests it might need to be updated. Consider making this port configurable via a parameter to increase flexibility.

-	// Expose the default HAProxy MCP Server port (update if different)
-	WithExposedPort(8080).
+	// Expose the HAProxy MCP Server port
+	WithExposedPort(port).

And update the method signature:

func (b *Backend) Container(
	// +optional
	arch string,
	// +optional
	port int,
) *dagger.Container {
	if arch == "" {
		arch = runtime.GOARCH
	}
	if port == 0 {
		port = 8080  // Default port
	}
	// ... rest of the method

---

148-149: Using specific Go version without future-proofing

The code uses "golang:1.24" which might become outdated. Consider using a more flexible version reference or documenting the version requirement.

-	From("golang:1.24").
+	From("golang:latest").  // Or a specific version with a comment about update process

---

152-153: Error handling missing for file formatting operations

The FormatFile method doesn't handle potential errors if the file doesn't exist or if gopls fails to format it. Consider adding error checking or documenting the expected behavior.

The Dagger model might handle these errors implicitly, but it would be good to document this behavior or add explicit checks.

---

36-43: Format method could be more explicit

The Format method combines two operations (standard Go formatting and lint fixing) without explicit documentation. Consider adding a comment to clarify what formatting operations are being performed.

// Formatter
+// Format applies standard Go formatting (gofmt) and fixes golangci-lint auto-fixable issues
func (b *Backend) Format() *dagger.Directory {
	return dag.
		Golang().
		WithSource(b.Source).
		Fmt().
		GolangciLintFix()
}

---

58-70: Build method parameter validation

The Build method accepts an architecture parameter but doesn't validate it beyond checking if it's empty. Consider adding validation to ensure the architecture is supported.

func (b *Backend) Build(
	// +optional
	arch string,
) *dagger.Directory {
	if arch == "" {
		arch = runtime.GOARCH
+	} else {
+		// Validate architecture is supported
+		supportedArchs := map[string]bool{"amd64": true, "arm64": true, "386": true}
+		if _, supported := supportedArchs[arch]; !supported {
+			// Log a warning or return an error
+			// For now, falling back to current architecture
+			arch = runtime.GOARCH
+		}
	}
	return dag.
		Golang().
		WithSource(b.Source).
		Build([]string{}, dagger.GolangBuildOpts{Arch: arch})
}

Configuration used: CodeRabbit UI
Review profile: CHILL
Plan: Pro
Cache: Disabled due to data retention organization setting
Knowledge Base: Disabled due to data retention organization setting

.dagger/backend/main.go (2)

66-66: Update hardcoded binary name to match project context.

The binary name "greetings-api" is inconsistent with the HAProxy MCP Server project context and comments in the file.

This issue was previously identified in past reviews. The binary name should be updated to match the project's actual binary name.

---

22-25: Undefined dag variable prevents compilation.

The dag variable is used but not declared, which will cause compilation errors.

This issue was previously identified in past reviews. The dag variable needs to be properly imported or defined.

.dagger/backend/main.go (1)

38-44: Simplify redundant error handling.

The Check method has unnecessary complexity - it immediately returns the same result as Lint without adding any value.

Consider simplifying this method:

-func (b *Backend) Check(ctx context.Context) (string, error) {
-	lint, err := b.Lint(ctx)
-	if err != nil {
-		return "", err
-	}
-	return lint, nil
-}
+func (b *Backend) Check(ctx context.Context) (string, error) {
+	return b.Lint(ctx)
+}

Configuration used: CodeRabbit UI
Review profile: CHILL
Plan: Pro