exceptiongroup, importlib_metadata, importlib_resources, typing_extensions: Require 3.12 features
#37402
Conversation
|
Since Gentoo doesn't have an importlib_metadata package, I really don't want to have to install importlib_metadata "just in case." |
|
Could you explain how this PR changes anything regarding this? |
|
Before I needed python-3.11 to skip the package that does nothing, but now I need python-3.12 to skip it. |
Is this not correct? |
Oh, yeah. It's the other one. We don't have importlib-resources any more since https://gitweb.gentoo.org/repo/gentoo.git/commit/?id=ef0ca954c |
|
Well, this removal may have been a mistake... |
It's almost like encoding the same information in two places is prone to failure :P |
|
Which two places? |
|
gentoo.git and sage.git |
|
Oh, OK. Well, as you know, we have this information system for users and to provision the testing environment, and both is done in a way that is robust to inaccuracies. |
Is this a packaging concern, or about what you have on your machine? |
Little of both. When doing sage development, I shouldn't have to install these as SPKGs -- that's one part of it. For distribution packaging they're either superfluous or problematic. Right now they're superfluous. But if someone actually uses a python-3.12 feature from importlib-resources, then not having it would be problematic. |
|
The spam bot just pinged me on this! I fail to understand your motivation. What feature of python 3.12 is so important that you need to do this? It seems much more reasonable to drop the packages altogether and avoid features not available in the range of supported python (3.9 - 3.12). Can you make a list of the features you would like to have available that are not available on 3.9? Note that 3.9 is already outside the NEP range (42 months) so it wouldn't be such a shame to drop it if there is a strong reason. |
Why would you say that? |
Can you make a list of the features you would like to have available that are not available on 3.9? |
|
Can you make a list of the features you would like to have available that are not available on python 3.9? |
|
Documentation preview for this PR (built with commit 46077c5; changes) is ready! 🎉 |
📝 Checklist
We tighten the lower bounds of these backport packages in install-requires so that the features of Python 3.12 can be used.
Also some updates to latest.
⌛ Dependencies
build/pkgs/setuptools_scm: Upgrade to 8.1.0, fix dependency typing_extensions, change some packages towheel#38226