Skip to content

Method is_linearly_dependent() is broken #37075

@Cloudifold

Description

@Cloudifold

Steps To Reproduce

Run the following code:

R.<a> = PolynomialRing(GF(3))

li = [2*a^705 + a^657 + 2*a^633 + a^585 + 2*a^489 + a^417 + 2*a^345 + 2*a^297 + 2*a^273,
 a^723 + 2*a^675 + a^579 + 2*a^555 + a^507 + 2*a^459 + a^435 + a^411 + 2*a^339 + 2*a^315 + a^291 + a^195 + 2*a^171 + a^147 + a^99,
 a^717 + a^669 + 2*a^621 + a^573 + a^549 + 2*a^501 + a^477 + 2*a^405 + a^381 + a^357 + 2*a^333 + 2*a^309 + 2*a^261 + 2*a^237 + 2*a^189 + a^165 + 2*a^117,
 a^711 + 2*a^687 + 2*a^639 + 2*a^615 + 2*a^591 + a^567 + 2*a^543 + a^519 + 2*a^447 + a^423 + 2*a^327 + 2*a^303 + 2*a^279 + a^255 + a^183 + 2*a^135 + a^111 + 2*a^63,
 a^723 + a^699 + a^675 + 2*a^651 + a^627 + a^603 + a^507 + a^435 + a^411 + 2*a^363 + a^315 + 2*a^291 + a^243 + a^219 + a^195 + 2*a^123 + a^75,
 2*a^717 + 2*a^693 + a^669 + 2*a^645 + a^621 + 2*a^597 + a^573 + a^525 + 2*a^453 + 2*a^429 + 2*a^405 + a^381 + a^285 + a^261 + 2*a^237 + a^189 + a^165 + a^141 + a^93 + 2*a^69 + 2*a^45,
 a^711 + 2*a^687 + 2*a^639 + 2*a^615 + 2*a^567 + 2*a^543 + 2*a^519 + 2*a^495 + a^447 + 2*a^351 + 2*a^303 + 2*a^255 + 2*a^231 + a^183 + 2*a^135 + a^111 + a^87,
 2*a^681 + a^657 + a^633 + 2*a^609 + 2*a^585 + 2*a^537 + 2*a^513 + a^465 + a^417 + a^369 + 2*a^345 + 2*a^297 + a^273 + a^249 + a^225 + a^177 + a^153 + 2*a^129 + a^105 + a^81 + 2*a^57 + a^9,
 2*a^621 + a^573 + a^549 + 2*a^525 + 2*a^501 + 2*a^477 + a^453 + a^429 + a^405 + a^381 + 2*a^357 + a^333 + a^285 + 2*a^189 + a^165 + 2*a^141 + a^117 + 2*a^93 + a^45,
 2*a^663 + 2*a^615 + a^567 + a^519 + a^495 + a^471 + 2*a^447 + a^423 + 2*a^399 + a^375 + a^351 + a^327 + a^231 + 2*a^207 + 2*a^135 + a^87 + a^39,
 a^705 + 2*a^657 + a^633 + 2*a^609 + a^585 + 2*a^537 + a^513 + a^489 + a^465 + 2*a^441 + a^417 + a^273 + 2*a^249 + a^201 + a^177 + 2*a^153 + a^81 + 2*a^57,
 a^723 + 2*a^699 + 2*a^675 + a^627 + a^603 + 2*a^507 + 2*a^459 + a^411 + a^387 + 2*a^363 + 2*a^291 + 2*a^267 + a^219 + 2*a^171 + a^147 + 2*a^123 + 2*a^75 + 2*a^27,
 2*a^663 + 2*a^615 + 2*a^591 + 2*a^495 + a^471 + 2*a^423 + 2*a^399 + a^375 + 2*a^351 + 2*a^279 + 2*a^255 + 2*a^231 + 2*a^207 + 2*a^135 + 2*a^63 + a^39,
 a^705 + 2*a^681 + 2*a^657 + 2*a^585 + 2*a^561 + 2*a^537 + a^513 + a^489 + 2*a^465 + 2*a^441 + 2*a^417 + a^393 + 2*a^345 + 2*a^321 + 2*a^249 + a^225 + a^201 + a^177 + 2*a^153 + 2*a^81 + 2*a^57 + 2*a^33,
 a^723 + a^699 + a^651 + a^579 + 2*a^555 + 2*a^507 + a^459 + a^411 + a^387 + 2*a^339 + a^315 + a^291 + 2*a^267 + 2*a^243 + a^171 + 2*a^147 + a^99 + a^75 + 2*a^27,
 a^717 + 2*a^669 + 2*a^621 + 2*a^597 + 2*a^573 + 2*a^549 + 2*a^525 + 2*a^501 + 2*a^477 + a^453 + 2*a^429 + 2*a^405 + 2*a^381 + a^333 + 2*a^285 + 2*a^261 + a^237 + a^213 + 2*a^189 + a^141 + 2*a^93 + 2*a^45 + a^21,
 2*a^633 + a^561 + 2*a^537 + a^513 + 2*a^489 + a^465 + a^441 + 2*a^417 + a^393 + 2*a^369 + a^345 + 2*a^297 + 2*a^249 + a^177 + 2*a^153 + 2*a^129 + a^81 + 2*a^57,
 2*a^723 + 2*a^699 + a^675 + 2*a^627 + 2*a^579 + a^555 + a^483 + a^411 + 2*a^387 + 2*a^363 + 2*a^339 + a^315 + 2*a^291 + a^243 + a^219 + 2*a^195 + a^171 + a^99 + 2*a^75 + a^51 + a^3,
 a^717 + a^693 + a^669 + a^645 + a^621 + 2*a^597 + 2*a^573 + 2*a^525 + 2*a^501 + a^477 + a^453 + 2*a^405 + 2*a^381 + 2*a^333 + 2*a^309 + a^285 + 2*a^261 + 2*a^237 + 2*a^213 + a^189 + a^165 + 2*a^93 + a^69 + 2*a^21,
 2*a^711 + a^687 + 2*a^663 + 2*a^639 + a^615 + a^591 + a^567 + 2*a^543 + 2*a^519 + 2*a^495 + 2*a^423 + a^399 + a^351 + 2*a^303 + 2*a^255 + a^231 + a^207 + 2*a^183 + 2*a^159 + 2*a^135 + a^111 + a^63 + 2*a^15]

print(li[1] == li[4] + 2*li[11] + 1*li[14])

print(li[1] - (li[4] + 2*li[11] + 1*li[14]))


print(sage.rings.polynomial.toy_variety.is_linearly_dependent(li))

Expected Behavior

Sage should print the following message:

True
0
True

Actual Behavior

True
0
False

Additional Information

This also happens in the Sage Cell Server:
image

Environment

- **OS**: Arch Linux 6.7.0-arch3-1
- **Sage Version**: 10.2

Checklist

  • I have searched the existing issues for a bug report that matches the one I want to file, without success.
  • I have read the documentation and troubleshoot guide

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    Type

    No type

    Projects

    No projects

    Milestone

    No milestone

    Relationships

    None yet

    Development

    No branches or pull requests

    Issue actions