Skip to content

LoadPinned* silently succeeds on objects of wrong type #1566

@mtardy

Description

@mtardy

I was writing something to parse objects from a /sys/fs/bpf fs and was expecting to receive an error when using ebpf.LoadPinnedMap on a prog and ebpf.LoadPinnedProg on a map. Instead, the function properly returns a struct but with garbage data in each "wrong" case.

So I've looked into it, it seems that the kernel doesn't expose anything to know in advance, given a BPF pinned object file, if it's a map or a prog. When you stat such a file there's no way to know if it's going to be a BPF map or prog.

However, when you open such a file and you end up with a file descriptor, if you readlink this fd, you retrieve something like anon_inode:bpf-map or anon_inode:bpf-prog. See here for map fd for example. This, and reading /proc/self/fdinfo/<fd> allows you to discriminate, since you'll bump into fields named map_<...> for maps and prog_<...> for progs.

All of that to say that we could use the readlink tricks to return an error properly instead of bogus information from LoadPinnedMap or LoadPinnedProg, @dylandreimerink suggested adding this to the newProgramInfoFromFd for example, we could also do newMapInfoFromFd respectively:

ebpf/info.go

Line 149 in 88736f4

func newProgramInfoFromFd(fd *sys.FD) (*ProgramInfo, error) {

ebpf/info.go

Line 54 in 88736f4

func newMapInfoFromFd(fd *sys.FD) (*MapInfo, error) {

On another topic, I think it would be great to have an API to parse objects indifferently if they are a map or a prog. A bit of what we can do right now with a "hack": reading everything, map and prog, as prog for example, since it doesn't return an error and then read common fields like memlock in fdinfo. It could be something like LoadPinned that would be common between maps and progs, and thus we could retrieve memlock using this object, or cast it into a map or prog if we want to go further.

I could elaborate on my use case and see if it makes sense but would love to know what people think :)!

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    bugSomething isn't workingrelease-blockerNeeds resolution before the next release

    Type

    No type

    Projects

    No projects

    Milestone

    No milestone

    Relationships

    None yet

    Development

    No branches or pull requests

    Issue actions