Inbox relay not respecting filters on subscription #80
Description
The inbox relay implementation is not respecting filters on subscriptions.
Notice that nak has detected that filter does not match. The filter was requesting for all kind 1 events with a specific q tag, and none of the returned notes have that q tag. Instead, it gave me notes that have that q-tag id value in the e tag, which is incorrect.
./nak-v0.14.2-darwin-amd64 req -k 1 -t q=be6229b88699d59ea555a7aa72c6ba60a2aacceff470a5912875ae0c9d7b582f -l 10 wss://nostr-relay.tyiu.xyz/inbox
connecting to wss://nostr-relay.tyiu.xyz/inbox... ok.
[nl][info] 2025/06/03 20:32:27 {wss://nostr-relay.tyiu.xyz/inbox} filter does not match: {"kinds":[1],"limit":10,"#q":["be6229b88699d59ea555a7aa72c6ba60a2aacceff470a5912875ae0c9d7b582f"]} ~ {"kind":1,"id":"31bb804a10a73f65494440062d4051f6a52a2e4c6d747abe145f99fc7a1cdbb1","pubkey":"6e75f7972397ca3295e0f4ca0fbc6eb9cc79be85bafdd56bd378220ca8eee74e","created_at":1748986768,"tags":[["e","be6229b88699d59ea555a7aa72c6ba60a2aacceff470a5912875ae0c9d7b582f","wss://Nostr21.Com","root"],["e","ef2e0b5a776022348633f2f4602c11907ea184278a901e93fae31d446b3cdb68","wss://relay.primal.net/","reply","17e2889fba01021d048a13fd0ba108ad31c38326295460c21e69c43fa8fbe515"],["p","2779f3d9f42c7dee17f0e6bcdcf89a8f9d592d19e3b1bbd27ef1cffd1a7f98d1"],["p","32e1827635450ebb3c5a7d12c1f8e7b2b514439ac10a67eef3d9fd9c5c68e245"],["p","c7acabf1fed201a53185e4dc5e0c6bae2bc5db19d73abf840535f305d8f05180"],["p","17e2889fba01021d048a13fd0ba108ad31c38326295460c21e69c43fa8fbe515"]],"content":"localhost is probably the nostr-tray relay","sig":"e6a7f1feebe20b04b165a7fe26fcbcdd3cdcfc0f9187ef99434cbdcb76ea423a0b588e935f1a16d563b05a2ab000b2ade4b17bd36342e7ab79bba5c951305d38"}
[nl][info] 2025/06/03 20:32:27 {wss://nostr-relay.tyiu.xyz/inbox} filter does not match: {"kinds":[1],"limit":10,"#q":["be6229b88699d59ea555a7aa72c6ba60a2aacceff470a5912875ae0c9d7b582f"]} ~ {"kind":1,"id":"2b7b2ec35cf094f48fc983933041072084466805600669f9b47754c790d35d3c","pubkey":"6e75f7972397ca3295e0f4ca0fbc6eb9cc79be85bafdd56bd378220ca8eee74e","created_at":1748986714,"tags":[["e","be6229b88699d59ea555a7aa72c6ba60a2aacceff470a5912875ae0c9d7b582f","wss://relay.snort.social/","root","32e1827635450ebb3c5a7d12c1f8e7b2b514439ac10a67eef3d9fd9c5c68e245"],["e","be6229b88699d59ea555a7aa72c6ba60a2aacceff470a5912875ae0c9d7b582f","wss://relay.snort.social/","reply","32e1827635450ebb3c5a7d12c1f8e7b2b514439ac10a67eef3d9fd9c5c68e245"],["p","2779f3d9f42c7dee17f0e6bcdcf89a8f9d592d19e3b1bbd27ef1cffd1a7f98d1"],["p","32e1827635450ebb3c5a7d12c1f8e7b2b514439ac10a67eef3d9fd9c5c68e245"]],"content":"keep it up Ser and thanks for everything you do.","sig":"36780bc85fcbcbc2cb3c384472e4dfaea4b36d56b7b0c2560a385999fb4c18deea7f12ddad1f10f43a149d0ab30dfc072dddebbbd15636851f27d3df8d813d32"}
[nl][info] 2025/06/03 20:32:27 {wss://nostr-relay.tyiu.xyz/inbox} filter does not match: {"kinds":[1],"limit":10,"#q":["be6229b88699d59ea555a7aa72c6ba60a2aacceff470a5912875ae0c9d7b582f"]} ~ {"kind":1,"id":"ef2e0b5a776022348633f2f4602c11907ea184278a901e93fae31d446b3cdb68","pubkey":"17e2889fba01021d048a13fd0ba108ad31c38326295460c21e69c43fa8fbe515","created_at":1748978438,"tags":[["e","be6229b88699d59ea555a7aa72c6ba60a2aacceff470a5912875ae0c9d7b582f","wss://Nostr21.Com","root"],["e","0e845060e95216ae5e29de7d951a8b84873455d2a160deb2e5e8555b235c73cb","wss://Nostr21.Com","reply"],["p","2779f3d9f42c7dee17f0e6bcdcf89a8f9d592d19e3b1bbd27ef1cffd1a7f98d1"],["p","32e1827635450ebb3c5a7d12c1f8e7b2b514439ac10a67eef3d9fd9c5c68e245"],["p","c7acabf1fed201a53185e4dc5e0c6bae2bc5db19d73abf840535f305d8f05180"],["r","wss://nos.lol/"],["r","wss://relay.angor.io/"],["r","wss://relay.damus.io/"],["r","wss://relay.primal.net/"]],"content":"You have 11 relays defined, one of them is localhost. When I reply to you or send a DM, you expect \"me\" to publish that to all your 10 public available relays?\n\nThere is also an following list with 34 relays that you have published.\n\nWhere should I publish my events for your to see them? Randomly pick perhaps 3 of the 10 relays?","sig":"c9032b44e37774303a7236b83d5bbccf277dca069aacb87ad2f800f500a5272d6f6403b15f616bad8aaec361f3cbe8fbe59aaad9e2e6dd9902661a82f0c660ff"}
[nl][info] 2025/06/03 20:32:27 {wss://nostr-relay.tyiu.xyz/inbox} filter does not match: {"kinds":[1],"limit":10,"#q":["be6229b88699d59ea555a7aa72c6ba60a2aacceff470a5912875ae0c9d7b582f"]} ~ {"kind":1,"id":"fab42ccb0c8da8865fa397da631073485457a1dff115e63ba3cb6d92210a7bbe","pubkey":"17e2889fba01021d048a13fd0ba108ad31c38326295460c21e69c43fa8fbe515","created_at":1748978085,"tags":[["e","be6229b88699d59ea555a7aa72c6ba60a2aacceff470a5912875ae0c9d7b582f","wss://Nostr21.Com","root"],["e","0e845060e95216ae5e29de7d951a8b84873455d2a160deb2e5e8555b235c73cb","wss://Nostr21.Com","reply"],["p","2779f3d9f42c7dee17f0e6bcdcf89a8f9d592d19e3b1bbd27ef1cffd1a7f98d1"],["p","32e1827635450ebb3c5a7d12c1f8e7b2b514439ac10a67eef3d9fd9c5c68e245"],["p","c7acabf1fed201a53185e4dc5e0c6bae2bc5db19d73abf840535f305d8f05180"],["r","wss://nos.lol/"],["r","wss://relay.angor.io/"],["r","wss://relay.primal.net/"],["r","wss://relay.damus.io/"]],"content":"Does your paid relays allow me to write a reply to them? If I use The Outbox Model will I will be able publish to you?","sig":"cfae4c51ed8a2a9eeea290cd05c8b607ae5cab03691243c40f9d019d25fbc7c6e2a1026cb5289bf9d9ac9ea96f24fde2d3c6bd54c992aa9e35424ff386de8fa0"}
[nl][info] 2025/06/03 20:32:27 {wss://nostr-relay.tyiu.xyz/inbox} filter does not match: {"kinds":[1],"limit":10,"#q":["be6229b88699d59ea555a7aa72c6ba60a2aacceff470a5912875ae0c9d7b582f"]} ~ {"kind":1,"id":"e21e28dd8e769d64f0487fa1d5551ac49ad15f7e766a2a3f73d36b3b2efe031f","pubkey":"fd208ee8c8f283780a9552896e4823cc9dc6bfd442063889577106940fd927c1","created_at":1748975926,"tags":[["e","be6229b88699d59ea555a7aa72c6ba60a2aacceff470a5912875ae0c9d7b582f","wss://nostr.wine/","root","32e1827635450ebb3c5a7d12c1f8e7b2b514439ac10a67eef3d9fd9c5c68e245"],["p","2779f3d9f42c7dee17f0e6bcdcf89a8f9d592d19e3b1bbd27ef1cffd1a7f98d1"],["p","52b4a076bcbbbdc3a1aefa3735816cf74993b1b8db202b01c883c58be7fad8bd"],["p","32e1827635450ebb3c5a7d12c1f8e7b2b514439ac10a67eef3d9fd9c5c68e245"]],"content":"Thank you, nostr:npub1yaul8k059377u9lsu67de7y637w4jtgeuwcmh5n7788l6xnlnrgs3tvjmf and nostr:npub12262qa4uhw7u8gdwlgmntqtv7aye8vdcmvszkqwgs0zchel6mz7s6cgrkj for getting us out of the WoT anti-spam gulag.\n\nMake global great again.","sig":"952bf70f4fbbfe370f31aa97fa1f13c81f148a5d2fa19f886e613dc2596b1df5dfa8761ce6df6947242708e1208d2b1edfa74446adc666dba7f5419c60974554"}