[Bug]: Artist radios seem to ignore replaygain information #4299
Description
I confirm that:
- I have searched the existing open AND closed issues to see if an issue already exists for the bug I've encountered
- I'm using the latest version (your issue may have been fixed already)
Version
0.57.0 (4909232)
Current Behavior
Starting an artist radio from here:
Correctly starts the radio, but songs are played much louder than if they were played manually.
Expected Behavior
I expect a specific song's volume to be the same, regardless of how it was started. (Manually, via the radio, playlists, etc)
Steps To Reproduce
- Set the replaygain settings to this:
- Start an artist radio
- Listen to the song and take note of the perceived volume level
- Search for the song and start it manually
- Listen to the song and take note of the different perceived volume level
Environment
- Server OS: ubuntu 24.04.2 LTS
- Browser: Zen Browser 1.14b (Firefox 140.0.2) on openSUSE Tumbleweed
- Client: NavidromeUIHow Navidrome is installed?
Docker
Configuration
# Navidrome Configuration
# Generated on 2025-07-02T19:29:40.588Z
Address = "0.0.0.0"
Agents = "lastfm,spotify,deezer"
AlbumPlayCountMode = "absolute"
ArtistArtPriority = "artist.*, album/artist.*, external"
AuthRequestLimit = 5
AuthWindowLength = 20000000000
AutoImportPlaylists = true
AutoTranscodeDownload = false
BaseHost = ""
BasePath = ""
BaseScheme = ""
BaseURL = ""
CacheFolder = "/data/cache"
CoverArtPriority = "cover.*, folder.*, front.*, embedded, external"
CoverJpegQuality = 100
DataFolder = "/data"
DbPath = "/data/navidrome.db?cache=shared&_busy_timeout=15000&_journal_mode=WAL&_foreign_keys=on&synchronous=normal"
DefaultDownloadableShare = false
DefaultDownsamplingFormat = "opus"
DefaultLanguage = ""
DefaultPlaylistPublicVisibility = false
DefaultShareExpiration = 31536000000000000
DefaultTheme = "Dark"
DefaultUIVolume = 100
EnableArtworkPrecache = true
EnableCoverAnimation = true
EnableDownloads = true
EnableExternalServices = true
EnableFavourites = true
EnableGravatar = false
EnableInsightsCollector = true
EnableLogRedacting = true
EnableMediaFileCoverArt = true
EnableNowPlaying = true
EnableReplayGain = true
EnableSharing = false
EnableStarRating = true
EnableTranscodingConfig = false
EnableUserEditing = true
FFmpegPath = ""
GATrackingID = ""
IgnoredArticles = "The El La Los Las Le Les Os As O A"
ImageCacheSize = "100MB"
IndexGroups = "A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X-Z(XYZ) [Unknown]([)"
LogFile = ""
LogLevel = "info"
LyricsPriority = ".lrc,.txt,embedded"
MaxSidebarPlaylists = 100
MPVCmdTemplate = "mpv --audio-device=%d --no-audio-display %f --input-ipc-server=%s"
MPVPath = ""
MusicFolder = "/music"
PasswordEncryptionKey = ""
PlaylistsPath = ""
PluginConfig = "null"
Port = 4533
PreferSortTags = false
RecentlyAddedByModTime = false
ReverseProxyUserHeader = "Remote-User"
ReverseProxyWhitelist = ""
SearchFullString = false
SessionTimeout = 86400000000000
ShareURL = ""
SmartPlaylistRefreshDelay = 5000000000
TLSCert = ""
TLSKey = ""
TranscodingCacheSize = "100MB"
UILoginBackgroundURL = "/backgrounds"
UIWelcomeMessage = ""
UnixSocketPerm = 0660
# Development Flags (subject to change/removal)
# These are experimental settings and may be removed in future versions
DevActivityPanel = true
DevActivityPanelUpdateRate = 300000000
DevAlbumInfoTimeToLive = 604800000000000
DevArtistInfoTimeToLive = 86400000000000
DevArtworkMaxRequests = 2
DevArtworkThrottleBacklogLimit = 100
DevArtworkThrottleBacklogTimeout = 60000000000
DevAutoCreateAdminPassword = ""
DevAutoLoginUsername = ""
DevEnablePlayerInsights = true
DevEnableProfiler = false
DevExternalArtistFetchMultiplier = 1.5
DevExternalScanner = true
DevInsightsInitialDelay = 1800000000000
DevLogSourceLine = false
DevNewEventStream = true
DevOffsetOptimize = 50000
DevPluginCompilationTimeout = 60000000000
DevScannerThreads = 5
DevShowArtistPage = true
DevSidebarPlaylists = true
DevUIShowConfig = true
[Deezer]
Enabled = true
[HTTPSecurityHeaders]
CustomFrameOptionsValue = "DENY"
[Inspect]
BacklogLimit = 100
BacklogTimeout = 60000000000
Enabled = true
MaxRequests = 1
[Jukebox]
AdminOnly = true
Default = ""
Devices = [ ]
Enabled = false
[LastFM]
ApiKey = "2******************************0"
Enabled = true
Language = "en"
ScrobbleFirstArtistOnly = false
Secret = "a******************************2"
[ListenBrainz]
BaseURL = "https://api.listenbrainz.org/1/"
Enabled = true
[PID]
Album = "musicbrainz_albumid|albumartistid,album,albumversion,releasedate"
Track = "musicbrainz_trackid|albumid,discnumber,tracknumber,title"
[Plugins]
CacheSize = "100MB"
Enabled = false
Folder = "/data/plugins"
[Prometheus]
Enabled = false
MetricsPath = "/******s"
Password = ""
[Scanner]
ArtistJoiner = " • "
Enabled = true
Extractor = "taglib"
FollowSymlinks = true
GenreSeparators = ""
GroupAlbumReleases = true
PurgeMissing = "never"
ScanOnStartup = true
Schedule = ""
WatcherWait = 5000000000
[Spotify]
ID = "7******************************4"
Secret = "d******************************6"
[Subsonic]
AppendSubtitle = true
ArtistParticipations = false
DefaultReportRealPath = false
LegacyClients = "DSub"Relevant log output
time="2025-07-02T19:22:06Z" level=info msg="Streaming file" artist="The Devil Wears Prada" bitRate=0 cached=false format=raw originalBitRate=2801 originalFormat=flac requestId=91b1819d603b/Iq8sC2gycD-001356 title=Spiderhead transcoding=false user=redacted
time="2025-07-02T19:22:06Z" level=info msg="Now Playing" artist="The Devil Wears Prada" player="NavidromeUI [Firefox/Linux]" position=0 requestId=91b1819d603b/Iq8sC2gycD-001358 title=Spiderhead user=redacted
time="2025-07-02T19:24:16Z" level=info msg="Streaming file" artist="The Devil Wears Prada" bitRate=0 cached=false format=raw originalBitRate=2801 originalFormat=flac requestId=91b1819d603b/Iq8sC2gycD-001376 title=Spiderhead transcoding=false user=redacted
time="2025-07-02T19:24:17Z" level=info msg="Now Playing" artist="The Devil Wears Prada" player="NavidromeUI [Firefox/Linux]" position=0 requestId=91b1819d603b/Iq8sC2gycD-001379 title=Spiderhead user=redacted
time="2025-07-02T19:26:02Z" level=info msg=Scrobbled artist="The Devil Wears Prada" requestId=91b1819d603b/Iq8sC2gycD-001390 timestamp="2025-07-02 19:24:16.932 +0000 UTC" title=Spiderhead user=redactedAnything else?
No response
Code of Conduct
- I agree to follow Navidrome's Code of Conduct