@Umcaruje i have added pictures, does that help?

current behavior

Suggested behavior

from experience i find that there are two primary reason for semi-tone-marking:

I want to mark the tone, because i want to insert notes on that tone
I want to exclude that note from already existing markings (f.i. a marked scale)

If i want to insert, then i may like to insert on the note on more than one octave, if so, its neat that all identical semitones in all octaves are marked, if i dont, its quite easy to see what octave im working in, because they have numbers, so additional marked notes wont be a real problem.

If i want to exclude a note from already marked notes, it is logical to exclude that note from all octaves, and with current behavior, i will have to that manually, Suggested will do that for me.

most valuable would be where you examine f.i. a midi score, and like to see which semitones a certain notes has been used over many octaves. Specific, which notes has been doubled over 4 octaves. Marking.method like picture Suggested behavior, would make that task almost automatically

weather or not the current 'single method' still is needed, must be discussed, but a method to achieve, picture Suggested behavior, would enhance the workflow

Uh oh!

Marked semitones should be marked across all octaves. #2193

Description

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

Labels

Type

Projects

Milestone

Relationships

Development

Issue actions