If shifting security left is the silver bullet, why does it still feel like we’re getting lit up in a corporate firing squad?
Shift left was supposed to save us. Catch bugs early. Save money. Ship flawless code with angelic choirs singing through the CI/CD pipeline. That’s what the suits preached in 2015, when DevOps became gospel.
The pitch: fix early, avoid disasters later. Sounds smart until you meet the folks doing the work.
Spoiler: they’re drowning.
Security teams parachuted into sprints like substitute teachers in a chem lab explosion. Expected to turn devs into security wizards with a few slides and a lunch session. The devs? Buried in sprints, choking on Jira, judged by how fast they ship broken features.
So now what?
We’ve got a flaming dumpster rolling downhill with corp logos on the side. Tickets vanish. Static analysis tools scream like smoke alarms in a dorm kitchen. Security champions get crowned, then ignored. Lunch-and-learns feel like time theft.
Security’s the backseat driver yelling slow down while product’s flooring it toward a cliff.
And here’s what no one puts on the dashboard: this isn’t shifting left. It’s shifting blame and hoping no one reads the postmortem.
We act like a few hours of training turns coders into encryption sorcerers. That’s fantasy. Might as well hand out CPR manuals and ask them to do open-heart surgery during deploy.
Security tickets? Buried under features, duct-taped to hotfixes, or left to rot in backlogs untouched since the Obama era.
Speed wins. Security’s the blocker. The hero is the one who ships a barely-working feature five minutes before the investor demo.
Security teams, for all their Slack-thread diplomacy, have zero power. They escalate, but once the app catches fire, it’s finger-pointing bingo.
And the tools? Loud, brittle, misconfigured. False positives flood inboxes. Devs learn to hit dismiss faster than commit.
Worst part? It looks great on paper. Clean dashboards. Tickets marked done. Everyone high-fiving their own PRs while vulnerable code ships like discount fireworks.
So what works?
Security engineers need to live in dev teams. Not as compliance cops, but builders. People who write code under pressure and can bake security in instead of stapling it on. Stop rewarding speed over safety. We’ll fix it later just means don’t get breached before IPO. Make the secure way the easy way. Use libraries, and workflows that make good choices easier. Treat developers like grown-ups. They want to build good things. But pride doesn’t survive under vague tickets, broken tools, and meetings that treat them like kids.
Security needs real backing. Money, headcount, and a leader willing to say no when the feature’s garbage and the timeline’s suicidal.
So here’s the real question:
If shift-left was supposed to stop the shooting,
why are we still bleeding out?
A more detailed article is here
https://lnkd.in/dnzRejdm
The Cult of Shift Left Security: Why It Sounds Great but Fails in Practice - SV EOTI
The Cult of Shift Left Security: Why It Sounds Great but Fails in Practice - SV EOTI